Chapter 10 of 12 · 22 min read

Chapter 8: Beats

What you will learn

  • What beats are and why they happen.

  • The derivation showing that the beat frequency equals ν₁ − ν₂.

  • The pitch you hear during beats and how loud the maxima are.

  • How to find an unknown frequency using beats, wax loading and filing.

  • How beats arise between strings and pipes that are slightly out of tune.

8.1 What beats are

Strike two tuning forks of 256 Hz and 260 Hz together. You do not hear two separate notes. You hear one note whose loudness rises and falls, "waa-waa-waa", four times every second. These regular swells of loudness are called beats.

Beats are an example of superposition. Here the two waves interfere in time at one place, rather than in space.

8.2 Derivation of beat frequency

Let two sound waves of equal amplitude a reach the ear, with angular frequencies ω₁ and ω₂ that are close to each other:

s1=acos⁡ω1t,s2=acos⁡ω2ts_1 = a\cos\omega_1 t, \qquad s_2 = a\cos\omega_2 t

Using cos C + cos D = 2 cos((C − D)/2) cos((C + D)/2):

s=[2acos⁡(ω1−ω22 t)]cos⁡(ω1+ω22 t)s = \left[2a\cos\left(\frac{\omega_1 - \omega_2}{2}\,t\right)\right]\cos\left(\frac{\omega_1 + \omega_2}{2}\,t\right)

Read this as a fast oscillation at the average frequency (ω₁ + ω₂)/2, whose amplitude (the bracket) changes slowly with time.

  • The pitch you hear is the average frequency, (ν₁ + ν₂)/2.

  • The amplitude 2a cos((ω₁ − ω₂)t/2) swings between 0 and 2a.

Loudness depends on the size of the amplitude, not its sign. |cos θ| reaches its peak twice in each cycle of cos θ. So the loudness peaks at twice the frequency of the cosine in the bracket:

νbeat=2×ω1−ω22⋅2π=ν1−ν2\nu_{\text{beat}} = 2 \times \frac{\omega_1 - \omega_2}{2\cdot 2\pi} = \nu_1 - \nu_2

The beat frequency is simply the difference of the two frequencies. The time between two loud sounds (the beat period) is

Tbeat=1∣ν1−ν2∣T_{\text{beat}} = \frac{1}{|\nu_1 - \nu_2|}
Figure 8.1 · Beats: two close frequencies and their sum
Figure 8.1 · Beats: two close frequencies and their sum

Where the waves are in step the sum is loud; half a beat period later they cancel. Loud moments repeat every 1/(ν₁ − ν₂) seconds.

At a maximum, the amplitude is 2a, so the intensity is 4 times that of one wave alone. At a minimum, with equal amplitudes, the sound dies away to silence. The average intensity is twice that of one wave.

8.3 When can beats be heard?

The ear keeps an impression of a sound for about 0.1 s. If loudness peaks come faster than about 10 per second, they blur together. So beats are heard clearly only when |ν₁ − ν₂| is less than about 10 Hz. A larger difference sounds rough or like two separate notes.

8.4 Uses of beats

  1. Tuning instruments. A sitar or veena player sounds a string with a reference note and tightens or loosens it until the beats slow down and vanish. Zero beats means the two are in unison.

  2. Finding an unknown frequency with a known tuning fork.

  3. Detecting small frequency differences that the ear cannot judge directly.

8.5 Finding an unknown frequency

Suppose a known fork A (ν_A) and an unknown fork B give x beats per second. Then ν_B = ν_A + x or ν_A − x. To decide, change B slightly and watch the beats.

  • Loading a prong with wax adds mass, so the frequency decreases.

  • Filing a prong removes mass, so the frequency increases. (Filing near the base instead lowers the frequency, but NEET questions mean filing the prongs to make them lighter.)

Change made to BBeats increaseBeats decrease
Wax on B (B goes down)ν_B = ν_A − xν_B = ν_A + x
File B (B goes up)ν_B = ν_A + xν_B = ν_A − x

The logic: if B was above A and B goes down, the gap shrinks, so beats decrease. If B was below A and goes down, the gap grows, so beats increase. If the change is made to the known fork A instead, apply the same logic with A moving.

A careful case: if beats decrease and then become larger than before after a big change, B has crossed over A. NEET questions assume a small change unless they say otherwise.

8.6 Beats with strings and pipes

Any two sources a few hertz apart give beats. For two identical strings with slightly different tensions, ν ∝ √T. For a small change, Δν/ν ≈ ½ ΔT/T. For two pipes of slightly different lengths, ν ∝ 1/L, so the shorter pipe has the higher note.

Worked example 8.1: Forks of 256 Hz and 260 Hz are sounded together. Find the beat frequency and the time between successive loud sounds.

Solution: ν_beat = 260 − 256 = 4 Hz. Time between loud sounds = 1/4 = 0.25 s.

Worked example 8.2: Forks of 400 Hz and 405 Hz are sounded together. What pitch is heard, and how many times a second does the loudness rise to a maximum?

Solution: The pitch is the average, (400 + 405)/2 = 402.5 Hz. The loudness peaks 405 − 400 = 5 times a second.

Worked example 8.3: A fork of 512 Hz gives 4 beats per second with an unknown fork B. When B is loaded with a little wax, the beats rise to 6 per second. Find the frequency of B.

Solution: B is 516 Hz or 508 Hz. Wax lowers B. If B were 516 Hz, lowering it would reduce the beats. The beats increased, so B was below 512 Hz. ν_B = 508 Hz.

Worked example 8.4: A fork of 384 Hz gives 6 beats per second with fork B. After B's prongs are filed slightly, the beats drop to 2 per second. Find B's original frequency.

Solution: B is 390 Hz or 378 Hz. Filing raises B. Beats fell, so B moved closer to 384 Hz from below. ν_B = 378 Hz.

Worked example 8.5: Find the beat frequency for y = a sin(400πt) + a sin(408πt).

Solution: ν₁ = 400π/2π = 200 Hz and ν₂ = 204 Hz. Beat frequency = 4 Hz.

Worked example 8.6: Two identical strings each give 200 Hz. The tension in one is raised by 1%. How many beats per second are heard?

Solution: Δν/ν ≈ ½ × 1% = 0.5%. Δν = 0.005 × 200 = 1 Hz. So 1 beat per second.

Worked example 8.7: Two pipes open at both ends are 84 cm and 80 cm long. Find the beat frequency between their fundamentals. (v = 336 m/s)

Solution: ν₁ = 336/(2 × 0.84) = 200 Hz. ν₂ = 336/(2 × 0.80) = 210 Hz. Beat frequency = 10 Hz.

Worked example 8.8 (NEET-hard): Twenty-one tuning forks are arranged in order of rising frequency. Each gives 4 beats per second with the next one. The last fork has twice the frequency of the first. Find the frequencies of the first and last forks.

Solution: There are 20 gaps of 4 Hz, so ν_last = ν_first + 80. Also ν_last = 2ν_first. So ν_first = 80 Hz and ν_last = 160 Hz.

Quick revision

  • Beats: periodic rise and fall of loudness when two close frequencies combine.

  • Beat frequency = |ν₁ − ν₂|; beat period = 1/|ν₁ − ν₂|.

  • Pitch heard = (ν₁ + ν₂)/2.

  • Equal amplitudes a: maximum amplitude 2a, maximum intensity 4I₀, minimum 0.

  • Clearly audible only up to about 10 beats per second.

  • Wax lowers a fork's frequency; filing the prongs raises it.

  • Strings: Δν/ν ≈ ½ ΔT/T. Pipes: ν ∝ 1/L.

NEET traps

  • Taking the beat frequency as (ν₁ − ν₂)/2 from the bracket cos((ω₁ − ω₂)t/2). Loudness peaks twice per cycle of that cosine.

  • Thinking wax raises the frequency. Extra mass makes the prong vibrate slower.

  • Forgetting to check which fork was changed: the known one or the unknown one.

  • Expecting beats from 256 Hz and 290 Hz. A 34 Hz difference is too fast to hear as beats.

  • Saying the pitch heard is ν₁ or ν₂. It is the average.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 8

Level 1: Concept check

1. The beat frequency of two sounds of frequencies ν₁ and ν₂ is (a) ν₁ + ν₂ (b) |ν₁ − ν₂| (c) (ν₁ + ν₂)/2 (d) ν₁ν₂

2. Forks of 256 Hz and 262 Hz are sounded together. The number of beats per second is (a) 6 (b) 3 (c) 12 (d) 518

3. Beats are produced by (a) reflection of sound (b) refraction of sound (c) superposition of two waves of slightly different frequencies (d) diffraction of sound

4. Loading a prong of a tuning fork with wax makes its frequency (a) increase (b) stay the same (c) double (d) decrease

5. Filing the prongs of a tuning fork makes its frequency (a) increase (b) decrease (c) stay the same (d) become zero

6. Beats are heard distinctly only if the frequency difference is less than about (a) 50 Hz (b) 10 Hz (c) 100 Hz (d) 1 Hz

7. Two sounds give 5 beats per second. The time between two successive maxima of loudness is (a) 5 s (b) 0.1 s (c) 0.2 s (d) 0.4 s

8. A common use of beats is (a) measuring the speed of light (b) finding the mass of a fork (c) measuring the length of a pipe (d) tuning musical instruments

9. Forks of 400 Hz and 404 Hz sound together for 3 s. The number of beats heard is (a) 4 (b) 12 (c) 8 (d) 1212

10. For beats to be produced, the two sources must have (a) slightly different frequencies (b) the same frequency and different amplitudes (c) very different frequencies (d) the same frequency and a fixed phase difference

Level 2: NEET standard

11. A 512 Hz fork gives 6 beats per second with fork B. Waxing B makes the beats increase. The frequency of B was (a) 518 Hz (b) 506 Hz (c) 512 Hz (d) 500 Hz

12. A 320 Hz fork gives 4 beats per second with fork B. Filing B's prongs makes the beats increase. The frequency of B was (a) 316 Hz (b) 320 Hz (c) 324 Hz (d) 328 Hz

13. A known 256 Hz fork A gives 4 beats per second with fork B. Wax is put on A, and the beats decrease. The frequency of B is (a) 260 Hz (b) 256 Hz (c) 248 Hz (d) 252 Hz

14. The beat frequency for y = 0.1 sin(500πt) + 0.1 sin(506πt) is (a) 3 Hz (b) 6 Hz (c) 1.5 Hz (d) 503 Hz

15. For the waves in Q14, the pitch heard is (a) 250 Hz (b) 251.5 Hz (c) 253 Hz (d) 3 Hz

16. Two identical strings each give 300 Hz. The tension in one is raised by 2%. The number of beats per second is about (a) 6 (b) 1.5 (c) 3 (d) 0.3

17. Pipes open at both ends, 84 cm and 80 cm long, sound their fundamentals together (v = 336 m/s). The beat frequency is (a) 20 Hz (b) 4 Hz (c) 5 Hz (d) 10 Hz

18. Pipes closed at one end, 21 cm and 20 cm long, sound their fundamentals together (v = 336 m/s). The beat frequency is (a) 20 Hz (b) 10 Hz (c) 40 Hz (d) 5 Hz

19. Forks of 300 Hz and 304 Hz sound together. The time between two successive minima of loudness is (a) 4 s (b) 0.25 s (c) 0.5 s (d) 0.125 s

20. A fork gives 5 beats per second with a 288 Hz fork and 3 beats per second with a 296 Hz fork. Its frequency is (a) 283 Hz (b) 291 Hz (c) 293 Hz (d) 301 Hz

21. Two waves of amplitude a each produce beats. The maximum amplitude of the resultant is (a) a (b) √2 a (c) a/2 (d) 2a

22. Sounds of 500 Hz and 495 Hz are heard together. The loudness reaches a maximum how many times per second? (a) 5 (b) 10 (c) 2.5 (d) 995

Level 3: Challenge

23. Twenty-six forks are arranged in order of rising frequency. Each gives 3 beats per second with the next. The last has twice the frequency of the first. The frequency of the first fork is (a) 150 Hz (b) 75 Hz (c) 78 Hz (d) 72 Hz

24. A fork gives 4 beats per second with a sonometer wire at a tension of 49 N, and again 4 beats per second at 64 N (same length). The frequency of the fork is (a) 56 Hz (b) 64 Hz (c) 60 Hz (d) 68 Hz

25. The resultant of two sound waves is y = 2A cos(4πt) sin(400πt). The beat frequency is (a) 2 Hz (b) 8 Hz (c) 200 Hz (d) 4 Hz

26. A sonometer wire is in unison with a 400 Hz fork. Its tension is raised by 4%. The number of beats per second is about (a) 8 (b) 16 (c) 4 (d) 2

27. Fork A has a frequency 2% higher than fork B. Together they give 5 beats per second. The frequency of B is (a) 255 Hz (b) 245 Hz (c) 250 Hz (d) 260 Hz

28. Two sound waves of equal amplitude produce beats. The ratio of the maximum intensity to the average intensity is (a) 4 (b) 2 (c) 1 (d) √2

29. Assertion (A): Beats are not heard distinctly if two frequencies differ by much more than about 10 Hz. Reason (R): The ear cannot separate changes of loudness that come faster than about one every 0.1 s. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true

30. Statement I: Loading a tuning fork with wax increases its frequency. Statement II: The beat frequency equals the difference between the two frequencies. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true

Answer key with reasons

QAnsReason
1bLoudness peaks at the difference frequency.
2a262 − 256 = 6.
3cTwo close frequencies interfering in time.
4dExtra mass slows the prong.
5aLess mass on the prong raises the frequency.
6bPersistence of hearing is about 0.1 s.
7c1/5 = 0.2 s.
8dBeats vanish when the two notes match.
9b4 beats/s × 3 s = 12.
10aClose but unequal frequencies give a slow swell.
11bWax lowers B; beats rise only if B was below 512 Hz.
12cFiling raises B; beats rise only if B was above 320 Hz.
13dA goes down and gets closer to B, so B is below 256 Hz.
14a250 Hz and 253 Hz; difference 3 Hz.
15bAverage of 250 and 253 Hz.
16cΔν ≈ ½ × 2% × 300 = 3 Hz.
17d200 Hz and 210 Hz.
18a336/0.84 = 400 Hz; 336/0.80 = 420 Hz.
19bBeat period 1/4 s.
20c293 − 288 = 5 and 296 − 293 = 3.
21dWaves add in phase at a maximum: 2a.
22a500 − 495 = 5 maxima per second.
23b25 gaps × 3 Hz = 75 Hz = ν_first.
24cWire gives 7c and 8c; 7c + 4 = 8c − 4, c = 8, ν = 60 Hz.
25d(ω₁ − ω₂)/2 = 4π, so ν₁ − ν₂ = 4 Hz.
26aΔν ≈ ½ × 4% × 400 = 8 Hz.
27c0.02ν_B = 5, so ν_B = 250 Hz.
28bMaximum 4I₀, average 2I₀.
29aThe 0.1 s persistence of hearing is the reason.
30dWax lowers the frequency; II is correct.

Chapter 8 revision sheet

One-page summary

  • Beats: periodic rise and fall of loudness when two sounds of slightly different frequencies ν₁ and ν₂ are heard together.

  • Resultant s = [2a cos π(ν₁ − ν₂)t] cos π(ν₁ + ν₂)t. The ear hears the average frequency (ν₁ + ν₂)/2.

  • The amplitude term varies at (ν₁ − ν₂)/2, but loudness peaks twice per cycle of that term, so beat frequency = ν₁ − ν₂.

  • Beat period = 1/(ν₁ − ν₂). One minimum lies between two successive maxima.

  • With equal amplitudes, loudness swings from zero to four times the intensity of one wave.

  • The ear can follow beats only up to about 10 per second; faster beats blend into a rough tone.

  • Uses: tuning instruments (beats vanish at unison), finding an unknown frequency, detecting tiny frequency differences.

  • Loading a fork (wax) lowers its frequency; filing its prongs raises it. Filing the ends of the prongs is the standard way to raise the pitch.

  • Unknown frequency = known ± beat count. Decide the sign from how beats change after loading or filing.

  • Beats can come from any two sources: forks, strings, pipes. For two strings, a small tension change gives Δν ≈ ½ν(ΔT/T).

  • Two pipes: work out each frequency from its formula, then subtract.

νbeat=∣ν1−ν2∣,Tbeat=1∣ν1−ν2∣\nu_{\text{beat}} = \lvert\nu_1 - \nu_2\rvert, \qquad T_{\text{beat}} = \frac{1}{\lvert\nu_1 - \nu_2\rvert}

Must-remember table

Change to unknown fork XBeats with known forkX was
Loaded with waxdecreaseabove the known (ν + b)
Loaded with waxincreasebelow the known (ν − b)
Prongs fileddecreasebelow the known (ν − b)
Prongs filedincreaseabove the known (ν + b)

Memory aids

  • "Wax Weighs it down": loading with Wax lowers the frequency; filing makes the fork Faster (higher).

  • "Difference you hear, average you sing": beat frequency is the difference, the heard pitch is the average.

  • "Ten is the Top": beats above about 10 per second cannot be counted by the ear.

  • "Fall means Far side": if loading makes beats fall, X was on the far (higher) side of the known fork.

Concept connections

  • Beats are superposition in time; Chapter 7 of this book gives superposition in space and Physics Book 16: Optics gives interference of light.

  • The cos A + cos B identity and frequency mixing reappear in AC circuits of Physics Book 14: Electromagnetic Induction and Alternating Currents.

  • Tuning a sonometer wire against a fork links to Physics Book 20: Experimental Skills.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 8, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)

31. Match List I (pair of sources) with List II (beats per second).

List I:

  • (A) Forks of 256 Hz and 260 Hz

  • (B) y₁ = sin(400πt) and y₂ = sin(412πt)

  • (C) Forks of 512 Hz and 510 Hz

  • (D) Forks of 340 Hz and 348 Hz

List II:

  • (i) 2

  • (ii) 8

  • (iii) 4

  • (iv) 6

(a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-i, C-iv, D-ii (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (d) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii

32. Two sounds of frequencies ν₁ and ν₂ (ν₁ slightly greater) produce beats. Match List I with List II.

List I:

  • (A) Beat frequency

  • (B) Beat period

  • (C) Frequency of the tone heard

  • (D) Frequency of the amplitude factor cos π(ν₁ − ν₂)t

List II:

  • (i) (ν₁ + ν₂)/2

  • (ii) 1/(ν₁ − ν₂)

  • (iii) (ν₁ − ν₂)/2

  • (iv) ν₁ − ν₂

(a) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii (b) A-iv, B-ii, C-iii, D-i (c) A-iv, B-ii, C-i, D-iii (d) A-iv, B-i, C-ii, D-iii

33. Match List I (observation) with List II (frequency of unknown fork X).

List I:

  • (A) With a 384 Hz fork X gives 6 beats/s; loading X reduces the beats

  • (B) With a 384 Hz fork X gives 6 beats/s; loading X increases the beats

  • (C) With a 400 Hz fork X gives 5 beats/s; filing X reduces the beats

  • (D) With a 400 Hz fork X gives 5 beats/s; filing X increases the beats

List II:

  • (i) 378 Hz

  • (ii) 395 Hz

  • (iii) 405 Hz

  • (iv) 390 Hz

(a) A-iv, B-i, C-ii, D-iii (b) A-i, B-iv, C-ii, D-iii (c) A-iv, B-i, C-iii, D-ii (d) A-iv, B-ii, C-i, D-iii

34. Two identical wires are in unison at 300 Hz. The tension in one is raised slightly. Match List I (rise in tension) with List II (beats per second, approximately).

List I:

  • (A) 2%

  • (B) 4%

  • (C) 1%

  • (D) 3%

List II:

  • (i) 1.5

  • (ii) 6

  • (iii) 3

  • (iv) 4.5

(a) A-ii, B-iii, C-i, D-iv (b) A-iii, B-ii, C-i, D-iv (c) A-iii, B-i, C-ii, D-iv (d) A-iii, B-ii, C-iv, D-i

35. How many of the following statements are correct?

  • A. Beats are heard when two sounds of slightly different frequencies overlap.

  • B. The ear can count beats only if there are fewer than about 10 per second.

  • C. The beat frequency equals the difference of the two frequencies.

  • D. Beats are an example of superposition of waves in time.

(a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 4

36. Choose the correct set of statements.

  • A. Loading a tuning fork with wax lowers its frequency.

  • B. Filing the prongs of a fork raises its frequency.

  • C. Beats are used to tune musical instruments.

  • D. Beats are produced only by longitudinal waves.

(a) A and B only (b) A, B and C only (c) C and D only (d) A, B, C and D

37. Two waves y₁ = a sin(500πt) and y₂ = a sin(506πt) reach the ear together. How many statements are correct?

  • A. 3 beats are heard per second.

  • B. The time between two successive loudest sounds is 1/3 s.

  • C. The frequency of the tone heard is 251.5 Hz.

  • D. The maximum intensity is twice the intensity of one wave alone.

(a) 4 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 1

38. Choose the correct set of statements.

  • A. If two forks give 5 beats/s, successive loudness maxima are 0.2 s apart.

  • B. Between two successive maxima there is one minimum.

  • C. The number of beats per second equals the sum of the two frequencies.

  • D. Beats can be heard only when the two amplitudes are exactly equal.

(a) A and B only (b) A, B and D only (c) B and C only (d) A, C and D only

39. A sound-level meter records loudness peaks at t = 0, 0.25 s, 0.50 s and 0.75 s when a 440 Hz fork and a slightly higher fork sound together. The second fork's frequency is (a) 436 Hz (b) 440.25 Hz (c) 442 Hz (d) 444 Hz

40. A student records:

StepBeats per second with a 288 Hz fork
Fork Q as supplied4
After a little wax is put on Q2

The original frequency of Q is (a) 292 Hz (b) 284 Hz (c) 290 Hz (d) 286 Hz

41. A fork A is tested against two standard forks:

Standard fork (Hz)256262
Beats per second with A42

The frequency of A is (a) 252 Hz (b) 264 Hz (c) 260 Hz (d) 258 Hz

Case for Q42–43: Two identical guitar strings are tuned in unison at 330 Hz. A student then tightens one of them so that its tension rises by 2.4%. Both are plucked together.

42. The number of beats heard per second is about (a) 8 (b) 4 (c) 2 (d) 1

43. The student now raises the tension of the second string by the same 2.4%. The beats will (a) double (b) halve (c) stay at the same rate (d) disappear

44. The resultant of two sound waves at a point is y = 2a cos(6πt) sin(800πt). The number of beats heard per second is (a) 6 (b) 3 (c) 400 (d) 12

45. Fork A is in unison with a pipe 25 cm long closed at one end (v = 340 m/s, no end correction). Fork B gives 4 beats/s with A. When B is loaded with a little wax, the beats rise to 6 per second. The frequency of B is (a) 344 Hz (b) 334 Hz (c) 336 Hz (d) 346 Hz

Level 4 answer key

QAnsReason
31dDifferences: 4; 206 − 200 = 6; 2; 8
32cBeat rate is the difference; heard tone is the average; the amplitude factor has half the beat frequency
33aLoading lowers ν: beats fall only if X is above (390), rise if below (378); filing raises ν: beats fall if X is below (395), rise if above (405)
34bΔν ≈ ½ × 300 × (ΔT/T): 3, 6, 1.5, 4.5
35dAll four are true
36bD false: any two waves of close frequency give beats
37c250 Hz and 253 Hz: 3 beats/s, period 1/3 s, heard tone 251.5 Hz; D false: max is (2a)², four times
38aC false: it is the difference; D false: unequal amplitudes still give (weaker) beats
39dBeat period 0.25 s gives 4 beats/s, so 440 + 4 = 444 Hz
40aQ = 284 or 292; wax lowers Q and the beats fell, so Q was above: 292 Hz
41cFrom 256: 252 or 260; from 262: 260 or 264; common value 260 Hz
42bΔν ≈ ½ × 330 × 0.024 ≈ 4 beats/s
43dBoth strings again have the same frequency
44aThis is a sin(806πt) + a sin(794πt): 403 Hz and 397 Hz, 6 beats/s
45cA = 340/(4 × 0.25) = 340 Hz; B = 336 or 344; loading raised the beats, so B was below: 336 Hz
22 min left
‹
›