Approaches, Methods and Techniques; Remedial Teaching
What to remember
- An approach is a set of beliefs about language and learning; a method is a plan that follows the approach; a technique is a classroom activity that carries out the method. The order is approach, method, technique (Edward Anthony, 1963).
- Grammar-Translation stresses rules and translation; the Direct Method stresses speech and bans the mother tongue; the Bilingual Method uses the mother tongue as a tool; the Structural Approach teaches graded sentence patterns; the Communicative Approach teaches language for real communication.
- Remedial teaching diagnoses a learner's specific weakness and corrects it through extra, planned work.
Approach, method, technique
| Level | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Approach | Theory of language and learning | Structural approach, communicative approach |
| Method | Overall plan for presenting language | Direct method, grammar-translation method |
| Technique | A specific classroom activity | Substitution drill, role play, dictation |
Grammar-Translation Method (GTM)
This method grew out of the way Latin and Greek were taught in Europe. It is also called the classical method or traditional method.
- The mother tongue is the medium of teaching.
- Rules of grammar are taught first and in detail (deductive: rule first, example next).
- Translation from and into the mother tongue is the main activity.
- Reading and writing are stressed; speaking and listening are neglected.
- Long lists of words are learned with their meanings.
- Accuracy is valued more than fluency.
Merits: easy for the teacher; economical; useful for understanding literary texts; gives strong knowledge of rules; suits large classes.
Demerits: no speech practice; boring and mechanical; learners cannot use the language in life; the natural order (L-S-R-W) is reversed.
Direct Method
It arose as a reaction against GTM in the late nineteenth century and is linked with the Reform Movement (Henry Sweet, Otto Jespersen, Paul Passy and Wilhelm Viëtor). Maximilian Berlitz popularised it in his language schools. François Gouin's Series Method (describing a series of connected actions) was an early influence.
- English is taught through English; the mother tongue is not used.
- Meaning is shown by objects, pictures, actions and demonstration (association of word and object).
- Speech comes first; reading and writing follow.
- Grammar is learned inductively: examples first, rule later.
- Everyday vocabulary and sentences are used; pronunciation is stressed.
Merits: fluency and good pronunciation; interesting and lively; follows the natural order.
Demerits: needs highly skilled, fluent teachers; difficult in large classes; costs time and aids; abstract words are hard to teach without translation; weak in reading and writing in the early stage.
Bilingual Method
This method was developed by C. J. Dodson (Wales, 1960s). The teacher uses the mother tongue and English together, in a controlled way. The teacher gives the meaning of a sentence in the mother tongue, the learners repeat the English sentence, and practice then follows in English. The mother tongue is used to give meaning, not to teach rules. It is suitable for Indian classrooms where learners share one mother tongue and teachers may not be fully fluent.
Merits: saves time; clear meaning; less strain on the teacher; suits beginners.
Demerits: over-use of the mother tongue; learners may depend on translation.
Structural Approach
This approach rests on the idea that language is a system of structures (sentence patterns). It owes much to the work of Harold Palmer, A. S. Hornby and Charles Fries. In India, it was promoted from the 1950s and 60s, and the Central Institute of English (now the English and Foreign Languages University, Hyderabad) and Regional Institutes of English were active in its spread. It is also called the Structural-Situational Approach because each pattern is taught in a real situation.
Principles:
- Speech before writing.
- Selection of structures by usefulness and simplicity; grading from simple to complex.
- Presentation in a situation (object, picture, action).
- Practice through drills (repetition, substitution, transformation, expansion).
- The mother tongue is not the main tool.
- Vocabulary is controlled (a limited, graded word list).
- Habit formation: language is learned by practice, a view linked with behaviourism and the Audio-Lingual Method of the United States.
Merits: systematic; gives a firm base for correct sentences; useful for beginners.
Demerits: mechanical drills; less attention to meaning and communication; cannot prepare learners for real conversations.
Communicative Approach (Communicative Language Teaching, CLT)
It developed in the 1970s in answer to the weakness of structural teaching. It is based on the work of Dell Hymes (communicative competence), D. A. Wilkins (the notional-functional syllabus), Henry Widdowson, and Christopher Candlin. It is also called the functional approach.
- The aim is communicative competence.
- Language is taught as a means to do things: request, invite, apologise, describe.
- Meaning and use matter more than form.
- Fluency has equal importance with accuracy.
- Pair work, group work, role play, information-gap tasks and games are used.
- The teacher is a facilitator, guide and resource; the learner is active.
- Authentic materials (newspapers, advertisements, timetables) are used.
- Errors are accepted as part of learning.
Task-based learning (TBL) is a form of CLT. In India, N. S. Prabhu's Bangalore Project tried task-based teaching. Information-gap tasks are those where one learner has information the partner lacks.
Comparison table
| Point | GTM | Direct | Bilingual | Structural | Communicative |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main focus | Rules, translation | Speech | Meaning plus practice | Sentence patterns | Communication |
| Mother tongue | Used a lot | Banned | Used for meaning | Little | Used when needed |
| Grammar | Deductive | Inductive | Through patterns | Through patterns | Through functions |
| Skill stressed | Reading, writing | Speaking | Speaking | Speaking, then others | All four |
| Teacher | Authority | Fluent model | Guide | Drill leader | Facilitator |
Other methods that may be asked
- Audio-Lingual Method: listening and speaking, pattern drills, habit formation; linked with Charles Fries and Nelson Brooks.
- Silent Way: Caleb Gattegno.
- Suggestopedia: Georgi Lozanov; relaxed atmosphere and music.
- Total Physical Response (TPR): James Asher; learners respond to commands with action.
- Natural Approach: Stephen Krashen and Tracy Terrell.
- Eclectic method: a teacher selects the best parts of several methods to match the learners.
- Reading Method / New Method: Michael West stressed reading for Indian learners; the Reading Method is also tied to his name.
Remedial teaching
Remedial teaching is teaching planned to remove specific difficulties in language learning. It comes after diagnosis. It is different from enrichment, which extends the learning of bright learners.
Steps:
- 1. Identify the weak learners through observation and tests.
- 2. Diagnose the nature and cause of the difficulty (a diagnostic test).
- 3. Plan suitable activities, material and time.
- 4. Teach with extra practice, often in small groups or individually.
- 5. Re-test and give feedback.
Causes of weakness can be: poor foundation, lack of practice, mother-tongue interference, poor hearing or sight, irregular attendance, lack of interest, home environment, and unsuitable teaching.
Error and mistake: A mistake is a slip that the learner can correct on their own. An error is a systematic deviation due to incomplete knowledge. S. P. Corder developed error analysis. Contrastive analysis (Robert Lado) compares the mother tongue and the target language to predict difficulty. Interlanguage (Larry Selinker) is the learner's own developing system between the first and the second language.
Remedial techniques: extra drills on the difficult item, games, individual attention, peer tutoring, simple graded reading, pictures and charts, and encouragement. Mark and record progress.
Classroom angle
No single method is best for all. A good teacher follows an eclectic path: uses oral work and situations for new patterns, uses the mother tongue sparingly for clear meaning, gives communicative tasks, and plans remedial work for those who lag behind.
Exam traps
- 1. Approach, method, technique: approach is theory; method is plan; technique is activity.
- 2. GTM vs Direct: GTM uses the mother tongue and deductive grammar; Direct bans it and uses inductive grammar.
- 3. Bilingual vs GTM: the Bilingual Method uses the mother tongue for meaning only, not for teaching rules.
- 4. Dodson vs Berlitz: Dodson is the Bilingual Method; Berlitz popularised the Direct Method.
- 5. Structural vs communicative: structural focuses on form and drills; communicative focuses on meaning and function.
- 6. Error vs mistake: an error is systematic; a mistake is a slip.
- 7. Remedial vs enrichment: remedial helps the weak; enrichment extends the bright.
- 8. Contrastive analysis vs error analysis: contrastive predicts difficulty by comparing languages; error analysis studies actual learner errors.
One-liners
- 1. GTM follows the pattern of teaching Latin and Greek.
- 2. The Direct Method avoids translation and the mother tongue.
- 3. Berlitz popularised the Direct Method.
- 4. The Bilingual Method was developed by C. J. Dodson.
- 5. The Structural Approach is also called the Structural-Situational Approach.
- 6. Palmer, Hornby and Fries are linked with structural teaching.
- 7. The Communicative Approach aims at communicative competence.
- 8. Wilkins is linked with the notional-functional syllabus.
- 9. TPR was developed by James Asher.
- 10. Interlanguage is a term of Selinker.
- 11. Corder developed error analysis.
- 12. Remedial teaching begins with diagnosis.
Practice questions
Which is the correct order from broad to specific?
- Approach, method, technique
- Technique, method, approach
- Method, approach, technique
- Method, technique, approach
Answer
A. Approach, method, technique
An approach is the theory; a method is the plan; a technique is the activity.
The Grammar-Translation Method is modelled on the way which languages were taught?
- Arabic and Persian
- Hindi and Telugu
- French and German
- Latin and Greek
Answer
D. Latin and Greek
GTM comes from the teaching of the classical languages.
In the Grammar-Translation Method, grammar is taught
- inductively, examples first
- only through songs
- deductively, rules first
- only through games
Answer
C. deductively, rules first
The rule is stated first and then applied.
Which skills does the Grammar-Translation Method stress most?
- Listening and speaking
- Reading and writing
- Speaking and listening
- Pronunciation only
Answer
B. Reading and writing
Speech is neglected in GTM.
Which method bans the use of the mother tongue in the classroom?
- Direct Method
- Bilingual Method
- Eclectic method
- Grammar-Translation Method
Answer
A. Direct Method
The Direct Method teaches English through English.
Maximilian Berlitz is associated with the popularisation of the
- Communicative Approach
- Bilingual Method
- Structural Approach
- Direct Method
Answer
D. Direct Method
Berlitz schools used the Direct Method.
In the Direct Method grammar is learned
- by translation of rules
- deductively
- inductively
- through a rule book first
Answer
C. inductively
Examples come first and the rule is drawn later.
François Gouin is known for the
- Series Method
- Silent Way
- Bilingual Method
- Suggestopedia
Answer
A. Series Method
The Series Method describes a series of connected actions.
The Bilingual Method was developed by
- Harold Palmer
- C. J. Dodson
- Dell Hymes
- A. S. Hornby
Answer
B. C. J. Dodson
Dodson developed it in the 1960s.
In the Bilingual Method the mother tongue is used mainly to
- give the meaning of a sentence
- teach grammar rules in detail
- replace English practice
- test the learners
Answer
A. give the meaning of a sentence
Meaning is given in the mother tongue and practice follows in English.
The Structural Approach teaches English mainly through
- literary classics
- word lists in the mother tongue
- graded sentence patterns
- long translation exercises
Answer
C. graded sentence patterns
Structures are graded and practised.
Another name for the Structural Approach is
- Natural Approach
- Notional-functional Approach
- Silent Way
- Structural-Situational Approach
Answer
D. Structural-Situational Approach
Each pattern is taught in a situation.
Which scholars are linked with the Structural Approach?
- Chomsky, Hymes and Krashen
- Palmer, Hornby and Fries
- Gattegno, Asher and Lozanov
- Bloom, Krathwohl and Simpson
Answer
B. Palmer, Hornby and Fries
These names are standard for structural teaching.
Which drill replaces one word in a sentence by another of the same class?
- Transformation drill
- Dictation
- Substitution drill
- Précis
Answer
C. Substitution drill
Substitution changes a word or phrase in a fixed pattern.
Changing 'He reads a book' to 'He does not read a book' is a
- translation exercise
- transformation drill
- substitution drill
- dictation drill
Answer
B. transformation drill
The sentence is changed from one form to another.
The Audio-Lingual Method is based mainly on the theory of
- constructivism
- humanism
- cognitivism
- behaviourism
Answer
D. behaviourism
Habit formation through stimulus and response.
The aim of the Communicative Approach is
- communicative competence
- perfect handwriting
- mastery of translation
- memorising rules
Answer
A. communicative competence
Learners should use English to communicate.
The notional-functional syllabus is associated with
- D. A. Wilkins
- Berlitz
- C. J. Dodson
- Gouin
Answer
A. D. A. Wilkins
Wilkins described notions and functions in the 1970s.
In the Communicative Approach the teacher is mainly a
- strict rule giver
- translator
- facilitator
- examiner only
Answer
C. facilitator
The teacher guides and creates communication tasks.
A task in which one learner has information that the partner lacks is called an
- drill
- information-gap task
- cloze test
- dictation
Answer
B. information-gap task
Learners must talk to fill the gap.
N. S. Prabhu's Bangalore Project is associated with
- the Silent Way
- Grammar-Translation
- Suggestopedia
- task-based teaching
Answer
D. task-based teaching
It tried a task-based approach in Indian schools.
Total Physical Response (TPR) was developed by
- Tracy Terrell
- James Asher
- Caleb Gattegno
- Georgi Lozanov
Answer
B. James Asher
Learners respond with actions to commands.
The Silent Way is associated with
- Caleb Gattegno
- Charles Fries
- James Asher
- Georgi Lozanov
Answer
A. Caleb Gattegno
The teacher stays mostly silent and uses rods and charts.
Suggestopedia stresses
- translation
- grammar rules
- a relaxed atmosphere with music
- strict drills
Answer
C. a relaxed atmosphere with music
Georgi Lozanov's method uses a relaxed setting.
An eclectic method means
- using only one method
- using only the mother tongue
- choosing the best parts of several methods
- using no method
Answer
C. choosing the best parts of several methods
The teacher selects according to need.
Which statements are correct? 1. The Direct Method avoids translation. 2. Grammar-Translation Method uses the mother tongue.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
C. Both 1 and 2
Both are correct.
Which statements are correct? 1. GTM stresses speech. 2. The Direct Method stresses speech.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
B. 2 only
GTM stresses reading and writing; the Direct Method stresses speech.
Which statements are correct? 1. The Bilingual Method was developed by Dodson. 2. The Bilingual Method uses the mother tongue to teach all grammar rules.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
A. 1 only
The mother tongue is used mainly for meaning.
Which statements are correct about the Structural Approach? 1. It teaches speech before writing. 2. It uses drills for practice.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
C. Both 1 and 2
Both are principles of the approach.
Which statements are correct? 1. The Communicative Approach treats errors as part of learning. 2. It values only accuracy and not fluency.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
A. 1 only
Fluency matters equally.
Which statements are correct? 1. A mistake is a slip that the learner can self-correct. 2. An error shows incomplete knowledge.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
C. Both 1 and 2
Both are standard definitions.
Which statements are correct? 1. Remedial teaching comes before diagnosis. 2. Remedial teaching removes specific weaknesses.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
B. 2 only
Diagnosis comes first.
Which statements are correct? 1. Contrastive analysis compares two languages. 2. Error analysis studies the actual errors of learners.
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Answer
C. Both 1 and 2
Both are correct.
Match the method with its feature. (a) GTM (b) Direct (c) Structural (d) Communicative
- (a) no mother tongue, (b) translation, (c) functions, (d) graded patterns
- (a) graded patterns, (b) functions, (c) translation, (d) no mother tongue
- (a) functions, (b) graded patterns, (c) no mother tongue, (d) translation
- (a) translation, (b) no mother tongue, (c) graded patterns, (d) functions
Answer
D. (a) translation, (b) no mother tongue, (c) graded patterns, (d) functions
Each is matched to its main feature.
Match the scholar with the idea. (a) Selinker (b) Corder (c) Lado (d) Krashen
- (a) error analysis, (b) interlanguage, (c) input hypothesis, (d) contrastive analysis
- (a) contrastive analysis, (b) input hypothesis, (c) interlanguage, (d) error analysis
- (a) input hypothesis, (b) contrastive analysis, (c) error analysis, (d) interlanguage
- (a) interlanguage, (b) error analysis, (c) contrastive analysis, (d) input hypothesis
Answer
D. (a) interlanguage, (b) error analysis, (c) contrastive analysis, (d) input hypothesis
Selinker: interlanguage; Corder: error analysis; Lado: contrastive analysis; Krashen: input hypothesis.
A teacher teaches 'This is a pen' by holding up a pen and saying the sentence. This is
- a cloze test
- dictation
- translation
- presentation in a situation
Answer
D. presentation in a situation
Structures are presented through objects and actions.
A teacher uses the Direct Method and wants to explain the word 'run'. The best way is to
- give a long definition
- demonstrate the action
- translate in Telugu
- write it on the board only
Answer
B. demonstrate the action
The Direct Method uses demonstration.
Which is a disadvantage of the Direct Method?
- It uses too much translation
- It does not teach pronunciation
- It neglects speech
- It needs a highly fluent teacher
Answer
D. It needs a highly fluent teacher
It is hard for teachers who lack fluency.
Which is a demerit of the Grammar-Translation Method?
- Learners cannot speak the language
- It ignores grammar
- It bans reading
- It has too many oral drills
Answer
A. Learners cannot speak the language
It gives little speech practice.
Teaching meant for learners who have specific difficulties is called
- group lecture
- revision lecture
- enrichment teaching
- remedial teaching
Answer
D. remedial teaching
Remedial teaching removes weaknesses.
The first step in remedial teaching is
- identifying and diagnosing the difficulty
- punishing the learner
- transferring the learner
- setting an examination
Answer
A. identifying and diagnosing the difficulty
Diagnosis must come before treatment.
A learner often writes 'He go to school.' The best remedial work is
- skipping grammar
- extra practice on third person singular verbs
- a long lecture on history
- copying the text a hundred times
Answer
B. extra practice on third person singular verbs
Targeted practice on the specific error.
Peer tutoring in remedial teaching means
- no help is given
- the weaker learner teaches the class
- a parent takes the class
- a stronger learner helps a weaker learner
Answer
D. a stronger learner helps a weaker learner
Peers support each other.
Enrichment programmes are meant for
- only weak learners
- teachers
- parents
- bright learners who need extra challenge
Answer
D. bright learners who need extra challenge
Enrichment extends learning for able learners.
A learner uses a rule wrongly, such as saying 'goed' for 'went', because he is applying a general pattern. This is an example of an
- slip of the tongue
- spelling mistake only
- motor skill failure
- error showing incomplete knowledge
Answer
D. error showing incomplete knowledge
Over-generalisation is a systematic error.