Chapter 8 of 10 · 21 min read

Chapter 6: Transgenic Animals, Ethical Issues, Biopiracy and Patents

Transgenic animals carry and express a foreign gene, and they help us study genes, model disease, make medicines and test safety. The same power raises questions of ethics, safety and ownership, which India handles through GEAC and patent law.

What you will learn

  • What transgenic animals are and why over 95% of them are mice.

  • The five main uses of transgenic animals, with NCERT examples.

  • Rosie, the first transgenic cow.

  • The ethical issues of genetic modification and the role of GEAC.

  • Patents, biopiracy and the basmati, turmeric and neem cases.

6.1 Transgenic animals

Animals whose DNA has been manipulated to possess and express an extra (foreign) gene are called transgenic animals. Transgenic rats, rabbits, pigs, sheep, cows and fish have been produced. Even so, over 95% of all existing transgenic animals are mice. Mice are small, breed fast, are cheap to keep and share many genes with humans.

6.2 Why make transgenic animals?

UseWhat it meansNCERT example
Normal physiology and developmentStudy how genes are regulated and how they affect normal body functions and growthInsulin-like growth factor: introduce genes that alter its formation and watch the effect
Study of diseaseBuild models of human disease to study it and test new treatmentsModels for cancer, cystic fibrosis, rheumatoid arthritis, Alzheimer's disease
Biological productsAnimals make useful human proteins, often in milkα-1-antitrypsin for emphysema; Rosie's milk with human alpha-lactalbumin
Vaccine safetyTest vaccines on transgenic animals before using them on humansTransgenic mice used to test the safety of polio vaccine
Chemical safety (toxicity) testingAnimals carry genes that make them more sensitive to toxic substances, so results come fasterTesting new drugs and chemicals

A few details NEET likes:

  • Some medicines need costly biological products. Transgenic animals can produce them, for example α-1-antitrypsin, a human protein used to treat emphysema. Similar attempts have been made for phenylketonuria (PKU) and cystic fibrosis.

  • In 1997, the first transgenic cow, Rosie, produced milk enriched with human protein, 2.4 grams per litre. The milk contained human alpha-lactalbumin and was nutritionally a more balanced product for human babies than natural cow milk.

  • If transgenic mice give reliable results in vaccine testing, they could replace monkeys for such tests.

Think of a transgenic mouse as a cricket net session. You test the new bowler (the drug or vaccine) in a safe, controlled setting before letting him play the real match (the human trial).

6.3 Ethical issues

Human beings cannot keep manipulating living organisms without rules. Concerns include:

  • Introducing genetically modified organisms into an ecosystem may have unpredictable results.

  • Using animals in research can cause them great suffering.

  • Moving genes across species may violate the integrity of species.

  • Biotechnology may pose unforeseen risks to human health and the environment.

To address these, the Indian Government has set up the Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee (GEAC). GEAC makes decisions about:

  • the validity of GM research, and

  • the safety of introducing GM organisms for public services.

For example, a company that wants to grow a new GM crop in Indian fields must get GEAC approval.

6.4 Patents and biopiracy

A patent is a right granted by a government to an inventor. It prevents others from making commercial use of the invention without permission. Patents reward inventors, but they can also be misused to claim ownership of traditional knowledge.

The basmati case

  • India grows about 2,00,000 varieties of rice. Basmati is famous for its unique aroma and flavour; India has 27 documented varieties of basmati.

  • In 1997, an American company got patent rights on basmati rice through the US Patent and Trademark Office.

  • This let the company sell a "new" variety of basmati in the US and abroad.

  • The "new" variety was actually derived from Indian farmers' varieties. Indian basmati was crossed with semi-dwarf varieties and the result was claimed as an invention.

  • The patent also covered functional equivalents, which could have restricted other people selling basmati.

Turmeric and neem

There have been several attempts to patent uses, products and processes based on Indian traditional herbal medicines, such as turmeric and neem. Indian grandmothers have used haldi on wounds and neem against pests for generations. That knowledge is old, not a new invention.

What is biopiracy?

Biopiracy is the use of bio-resources by multinational companies and other organisations without proper authorisation from the countries and people concerned, and without compensatory payment.

Group of nationsMoney and technologyBiodiversity and traditional knowledge
Industrialised nationsRichPoor
Developing and under-developed nationsPoorRich

This imbalance creates a need for fair rules. Nations are framing laws to prevent unauthorised use of their bio-resources and traditional knowledge, and to share benefits. In India, Parliament cleared the second amendment of the Indian Patents Bill, which takes such issues into account, including patent terms, emergency provisions, and research and development initiatives.

Worked examples: Chapter 6

Worked example 6.1: Name the use of transgenic animals in each case: (i) a mouse model of Alzheimer's disease; (ii) a sheep that secretes a human protein in its milk; (iii) mice used to check a new polio vaccine.

Solution: (i) Study of disease. (ii) Biological products. (iii) Vaccine safety.

Worked example 6.2: Give three facts about Rosie.

Solution: Rosie was the first transgenic cow (1997). Her milk had 2.4 g of human protein per litre. The protein was human alpha-lactalbumin, making the milk more balanced for human babies.

Worked example 6.3: Why are more than 95% of transgenic animals mice?

Solution: Mice are small, cheap to house and breed quickly, so many generations can be studied. They also share many genes and disease pathways with humans.

Worked example 6.4: A foreign firm collects a medicinal plant used by a tribal community, patents a drug from it and pays the community nothing. Name the practice and the problem.

Solution: This is biopiracy. The bio-resource and the traditional knowledge were used without authorisation from the country and people concerned and without compensatory payment.

Worked example 6.5: Why was the 1997 basmati patent opposed in India?

Solution: The "new" rice was derived from varieties developed by Indian farmers, crossed with semi-dwarf varieties. Claiming it as an invention ignored the farmers' work and could restrict trade in basmati.

Worked example 6.6: A seed company plans open-field trials of a GM mustard in Rajasthan. Which body must approve it and what will it check?

Solution: GEAC. It judges the validity of the GM research and the safety of releasing the GM organism for public use.

Worked example 6.7: How do transgenic animals cut the time needed for toxicity testing?

Solution: They carry genes that make them more sensitive to toxic substances. Effects show up quickly and at lower doses, so results come in less time.

Quick revision

  • Transgenic animal: DNA manipulated to possess and express a foreign gene; over 95% are mice.

  • Uses: normal physiology, disease models, biological products, vaccine safety, chemical safety testing.

  • α-1-antitrypsin treats emphysema. Polio vaccine safety tested on transgenic mice.

  • Rosie (1997): 2.4 g/L human protein, alpha-lactalbumin.

  • GEAC: validity of GM research and safety of GMOs for public services.

  • Basmati patent, 1997, US Patent and Trademark Office; India has 27 documented basmati varieties.

  • Biopiracy: use of bio-resources without authorisation or compensatory payment. Turmeric and neem also targeted.

  • India: second amendment of the Indian Patents Bill.

NEET traps

  • Rosie is the transgenic cow; Dolly was a cloned sheep. Do not swap them.

  • Rosie's milk had human alpha-lactalbumin, not α-1-antitrypsin.

  • α-1-antitrypsin treats emphysema, not diabetes or haemophilia.

  • GEAC appraises GM research; it does not grant patents.

  • The basmati patent was in the US (1997), not in India.

  • Biopiracy needs both missing authorisation and missing compensation; legal, paid use with consent is not biopiracy.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 6

Level 1: Concept check

1. Of all existing transgenic animals, mice make up about (a) 50% (b) over 95% (c) 25% (d) 10%

2. The first transgenic cow was named (a) Dolly (b) Molly (c) Polly (d) Rosie

3. The milk of the first transgenic cow contained human (a) alpha-lactalbumin (b) insulin (c) α-1-antitrypsin (d) adenosine deaminase

4. The first transgenic cow was produced in (a) 1990 (b) 1983 (c) 1997 (d) 2002

5. α-1-antitrypsin made by transgenic animals is used to treat (a) emphysema (b) diabetes (c) haemophilia (d) ADA deficiency

6. GEAC stands for (a) Gene Expression Analysis Council (b) General Environment Assessment Committee (c) Genetic Evaluation and Assay Centre (d) Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee

7. The number of documented varieties of basmati rice in India is (a) 27 (b) 7 (c) 200 (d) 2,00,000

8. The use of bio-resources without authorisation from the people concerned and without compensatory payment is called (a) biofortification (b) bioremediation (c) biomagnification (d) biopiracy

9. The 1997 patent on basmati rice was granted by the (a) US Patent and Trademark Office (b) Indian Patent Office (c) World Health Organization (d) GEAC

10. Transgenic mice have been used to test the safety of which vaccine before its use on humans? (a) Hepatitis B (b) BCG (c) Polio (d) Rabies

Level 2: NEET standard

11. Transgenic animals are animals that (a) are cloned from a body cell (b) are produced only by hybridisation (c) have DNA manipulated to possess and express a foreign gene (d) carry a viral infection

12. Transgenic models have been made to study which human diseases? (a) Common cold and malaria (b) Cancer, cystic fibrosis, rheumatoid arthritis and Alzheimer's (c) Scurvy and rickets (d) Diabetes only

13. The job of GEAC is to (a) decide on the validity of GM research and the safety of introducing GM organisms for public services (b) grant patents to inventors (c) manufacture vaccines (d) run clinical trials of all drugs

14. Rosie's milk was considered better for human babies than natural cow milk because it (a) had no fat (b) had extra lactose (c) contained insulin (d) contained human alpha-lactalbumin and was nutritionally more balanced

15. Match Column I with Column II. Column I: A. Rosie B. α-1-antitrypsin C. Transgenic mice D. Basmati Column II: i. Polio vaccine safety ii. Biopiracy debate iii. Human alpha-lactalbumin iv. Emphysema (a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (d) A-i, B-iv, C-iii, D-ii

16. Besides basmati, which Indian traditional resources faced attempts to patent their uses? (a) Tea and coffee (b) Cotton and jute (c) Wheat and maize (d) Turmeric and neem

17. In studying normal physiology with transgenic animals, the NCERT example is the regulation of (a) α-1-antitrypsin (b) insulin-like growth factor (c) alpha-lactalbumin (d) Cry protein

18. Transgenic animals speed up chemical safety testing because they (a) carry genes that make them more sensitive to toxic substances, so results come faster (b) need no testing at all (c) break down every toxin (d) are always plants

19. The "new" basmati variety patented in 1997 was derived from (a) wild African rice (b) a gene taken from E. coli (c) Indian farmers' varieties crossed with semi-dwarf varieties (d) Japanese rice only

20. Which of these is NOT an ethical concern about genetic modification? (a) Unpredictable results when GMOs enter ecosystems (b) Suffering caused to research animals (c) Violation of the integrity of species (d) The cost of agarose in school labs

21. Which statement about nations and bio-resources is correct? (a) Both industrialised and developing nations are poor in biodiversity (b) Industrialised nations are rich in biodiversity and traditional knowledge (c) Developing nations are poor in traditional knowledge (d) Industrialised nations are rich financially but poor in biodiversity and traditional knowledge

22. To deal with biopiracy and patent issues, the Indian Parliament (a) banned all GM crops (b) withdrew from world trade (c) cleared the second amendment of the Indian Patents Bill (d) stopped all rice exports

Level 3: Challenge

23. Mice carrying a gene that makes them highly sensitive to the toxic side effects of a new drug are being used for (a) study of normal physiology (b) production of biological products (c) chemical safety testing (d) vaccine safety testing

24. A foreign company uses a tribal community's knowledge of a medicinal plant to patent a drug, without permission or payment. This is (a) biopiracy (b) bioremediation (c) gene therapy (d) biofortification

25. Which statements are correct? I. Over 95% of transgenic animals are mice. II. Rosie's milk contained 2.4 g of human protein per litre. III. GEAC grants patents to inventors. IV. A patent prevents others from commercial use of an invention. (a) I and III (b) II and III (c) I, III and IV (d) I, II and IV

26. A company crosses Indian basmati with a semi-dwarf variety and patents the result as a novel invention. The main objection is that (a) such crosses are impossible (b) semi-dwarf varieties are illegal (c) the product rests on varieties developed by Indian farmers, so the novelty claim is doubtful and their contribution is ignored (d) basmati is not a rice

27. Transgenic animals that make human proteins in their milk are an example of use for (a) study of disease (b) normal physiology (c) vaccine safety (d) biological products

28. In India, which of these needs approval from GEAC? (a) Field release of a new GM crop (b) Making curd at home (c) Selling ordinary hybrid seeds (d) Running an agarose gel in a school lab

29. Assertion (A): Transgenic animals are used as models to study human diseases such as cancer and Alzheimer's disease. Reason (R): Transgenic animals cannot express foreign genes. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true

30. Statement I: Biopiracy is the use of bio-resources with full authorisation and fair payment to the people concerned. Statement II: The first transgenic cow, Rosie, was produced in 1983. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true

Answer key with reasons

QAnsReason
1bOver 95% are mice.
2dRosie was the first transgenic cow.
3aHuman alpha-lactalbumin.
4cRosie was produced in 1997.
5aIt treats emphysema.
6dGenetic Engineering Appraisal Committee.
7a27 documented basmati varieties.
8dDefinition of biopiracy.
9aUS Patent and Trademark Office.
10cPolio vaccine safety was tested on mice.
11cDefinition of a transgenic animal.
12bThese are NCERT disease models.
13aGEAC judges GM research and GMO safety.
14dHuman alpha-lactalbumin balanced the milk.
15bRosie-iii, antitrypsin-iv, mice-i, basmati-ii.
16dTurmeric and neem.
17bInsulin-like growth factor.
18aSensitive animals give quicker results.
19cIndian varieties crossed with semi-dwarfs.
20dAgarose cost is not an ethical issue.
21dRich in money, poor in biodiversity.
22cSecond amendment of the Patents Bill.
23cToxicity testing.
24aNo authorisation, no payment.
25dIII is false; GEAC does not grant patents.
26cThe work of Indian farmers was claimed as new.
27dProteins in milk = biological products.
28aGEAC approves GMO release.
29cThey do express foreign genes; R is false.
30bBiopiracy lacks consent and payment; Rosie was 1997.

Chapter 6 revision sheet

One-page summary

  • Transgenic animals have DNA manipulated to possess and express an extra (foreign) gene.

  • Rats, rabbits, pigs, sheep, cows and fish have been made transgenic, but over 95% of transgenic animals are mice.

  • Use 1, normal physiology and development: e.g. studying how insulin-like growth factor is regulated.

  • Use 2, disease study: models for cancer, cystic fibrosis, rheumatoid arthritis and Alzheimer's.

  • Use 3, biological products: α-1-antitrypsin for emphysema; work also on products for phenylketonuria and cystic fibrosis.

  • Rosie (1997), the first transgenic cow, gave milk with human alpha-lactalbumin at 2.4 g/L, more balanced for human babies than ordinary cow milk.

  • Use 4, vaccine safety: transgenic mice test the safety of polio vaccine before human use.

  • Use 5, chemical safety: animals carrying genes that make them more sensitive to toxic substances give faster toxicity results.

  • Changing organisms raises ethical questions about effects on the organism and the ecosystem.

  • India's GEAC (Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee) decides the validity of GM research and the safety of releasing GMOs for public services.

  • A patent gives an inventor the right to stop others using the invention commercially.

  • 1997: an American company got a US patent on basmati rice through the US Patent and Trademark Office.

  • India has 27 documented basmati varieties; the "new" variety came from crossing Indian farmers' varieties with semi-dwarf varieties.

  • Turmeric and neem were also targets of such patents; biopiracy = using bio-resources without proper authorisation or compensatory payment.

  • India passed the second amendment of the Indian Patents Bill, covering patent terms, emergency provisions and research and development initiatives.

Must-remember table

TermMeaning or useExample
Transgenic animalCarries and expresses a foreign geneOver 95% are mice
Disease modelAnimal used to study a human diseaseCancer, cystic fibrosis, Alzheimer's
α-1-antitrypsinProtein to treat emphysemaBiological product
RosieFirst transgenic cow, 19972.4 g/L human alpha-lactalbumin
Vaccine safetyTesting before human usePolio vaccine on transgenic mice
GEACApproves GM research and releaseIndian body
PatentRight to stop commercial copyingBasmati patent, 1997, USPTO
BiopiracyUse of bio-resources without consent or paymentBasmati, turmeric, neem

Memory aids

  • "NDBVC" uses: Normal physiology, Disease study, Biological products, Vaccine safety, Chemical safety.

  • "Rosie, 2.4 in '97": Rosie's milk had 2.4 g of human protein per litre, and she was born in 1997.

  • "Lungs need A1AT": α-1-antitrypsin treats emphysema, a lung disease.

  • "27 Basmati, 1 patent, '97": 27 Indian varieties, one US patent, in 1997.

  • "GEAC = Gatekeeper": GEAC decides if GM research and release are safe.

Concept connections

  • Emphysema and lung function come from NEET Biology Book 5: Human Physiology.

  • Vaccines and immunity link to NEET Biology Book 8: Biology and Human Welfare.

  • Loss of biodiversity and conservation of genetic resources connect to NEET Biology Book 10: Ecology and Environment.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 6, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)

31. Match List I with List II. List I: A. Transgenic mice used before releasing polio vaccine B. α-1-antitrypsin C. Transgenic models of cancer and Alzheimer's D. Animals made more sensitive to toxic substances List II: i. Study of disease ii. Chemical safety testing iii. Biological product for emphysema iv. Vaccine safety (a) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iv, B-iii, C-ii, D-i (c) A-i, B-iii, C-iv, D-ii (d) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii

32. Match List I with List II. List I: A. GEAC B. Biopiracy C. Patent D. Second amendment of the Indian Patents Bill List II: i. Use of bio-resources without proper authorisation or payment ii. Decides validity of GM research and safety of releasing GMOs iii. Covers patent terms, emergency provisions and R&D initiatives iv. Right that stops others using an invention commercially (a) A-i, B-ii, C-iv, D-iii (b) A-ii, B-i, C-iv, D-iii (c) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii (d) A-ii, B-i, C-iii, D-iv

33. Match List I with List II. List I: A. Rosie B. 2.4 g/L C. Alpha-lactalbumin D. 1997 List II: i. Human protein in Rosie's milk ii. Year Rosie was produced iii. First transgenic cow iv. Amount of human protein in Rosie's milk (a) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-i, C-iv, D-ii (c) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (d) A-iii, B-ii, C-i, D-iv

34. Match List I with List II. List I: A. Basmati B. Turmeric and neem C. 27 D. Semi-dwarf varieties List II: i. Number of documented basmati varieties in India ii. Crossed with Indian basmati to make the patented "new" variety iii. Patented in the US in 1997 iv. Other Indian traditional products targeted by patents (a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (d) A-iii, B-i, C-iv, D-ii

35. How many of the following statements are correct? A. Over 95% of transgenic animals are mice. B. Transgenic animals help study how genes contribute to disease. C. Rosie's milk contained human alpha-lactalbumin. D. Transgenic mice are used to test the safety of polio vaccine. E. Transgenic animals are produced by ordinary hybridisation. (a) Two (b) Three (c) Four (d) Five

36. Choose the correct set of statements. A. α-1-antitrypsin is used to treat emphysema. B. Rosie's milk is nutritionally more balanced for human babies than natural cow milk. C. GEAC decides on the validity of GM research. D. Transgenic animals are used only to produce food. (a) A, B and C only (b) A and D only (c) B and C only (d) A, B, C and D

37. How many of the following statements about biopiracy are correct? A. It is the use of bio-resources by companies without proper authorisation from the countries or people concerned. B. It involves no compensatory payment to those people. C. Developing nations are rich in biodiversity and traditional knowledge. D. Industrialised nations are rich in biodiversity but poor in money. (a) One (b) Four (c) Two (d) Three

38. Choose the correct set of statements. A. The basmati patent was granted in 1997. B. It was granted by the Indian Patent Office. C. The patented rice was derived from Indian farmers' varieties. D. Turmeric and neem were also targets of such patents. (a) A and B only (b) A, C and D only (c) B, C and D only (d) A, B, C and D

39. Study the table of uses of transgenic animals.

RowUseExample
PNormal physiologyRegulation of insulin-like growth factor
QStudy of diseaseModel for cystic fibrosis
RBiological productsTesting safety of polio vaccine
SChemical safetyAnimals more sensitive to toxic substances

Which row is wrongly matched? (a) P (b) Q (c) R (d) S

40. A bar graph shows the share of all transgenic animals by species. The bar for mice is above 95%. Rats, rabbits, pigs, sheep, cows and fish together make up the rest. Which reason best explains the tall bar for mice? (a) Mice are the only animals that can take up foreign DNA (b) Mice are small, breed quickly and cheaply, and are well studied genetically (c) The law forbids other transgenic animals (d) Mice need no ethical approval

41. Rosie's milk had 2.4 g of human protein per litre. How much human protein would 5 L of her milk hold? (a) 12 g (b) 2.4 g (c) 7.4 g (d) 24 g

Case for Q42–43: An Indian company wants to field-test a GM mustard developed in its lab. In another case, a foreign firm files a patent on a neem-based pesticide built on knowledge from Indian villages, without permission and without paying the villagers.

42. Which body must approve the GM mustard field trial in India? (a) US Patent and Trademark Office (b) World Health Organization (c) Indian Patent Office (d) GEAC

43. The foreign firm's action is best described as (a) gene therapy (b) bioprocessing (c) biopiracy (d) biofortification

44. Why are transgenic animals useful for chemical safety testing? (a) They are immune to all toxins (b) They carry genes that make them more sensitive to toxic substances, so effects show faster (c) They replace all human trials (d) They make their own toxins

45. Which pair is correctly matched? (a) α-1-antitrypsin – emphysema (b) Rosie – 1990 (c) GEAC – grants US patents (d) Basmati varieties documented in India – 72

Level 4 answer key

QAnsReason
31dPolio = vaccine safety; A1AT = emphysema; models = disease; sensitive animals = chemical safety
32bGEAC approves GM work; biopiracy = no consent/payment; patent = exclusive right; amendment = terms and provisions
33aRosie = first transgenic cow; 2.4 g/L; alpha-lactalbumin; 1997
34cBasmati patented; turmeric/neem also targeted; 27 varieties; semi-dwarf parent
35cA–D true; transgenics are made by gene transfer, not hybridisation
36aD is false: there are five uses, not only food
37dD is false: industrialised nations are rich in money, poor in biodiversity
38bThe patent came from the US Patent and Trademark Office
39cPolio vaccine testing is vaccine safety, not a biological product
40bMice are small, fast-breeding and well understood
41a2.4 × 5 = 12 g
42dGEAC approves GM research and release
43cUse of bio-resources without consent or payment = biopiracy
44bExtra sensitivity gives quicker toxicity results
45aA1AT treats emphysema; Rosie 1997; GEAC is Indian; 27 varieties
21 min left
‹
›