Chapter 1: History and Need for Classification
Chemists sorted elements long before anyone knew about protons. Each attempt solved part of the puzzle and broke somewhere else. NEET asks what each scientist proposed, what worked, and where it failed.
What you will learn
Why a classification of elements was needed at all.
Döbereiner's triads and how to test whether three elements form a triad.
Newlands' law of octaves and why it stopped working after calcium.
Lothar Meyer's atomic volume curve in one line.
Mendeleev's periodic law, his bold predictions, and the limits of a mass-based table.
1.1 Why classify elements?
Think of a kirana shop with 118 items thrown into one sack. You would never find the jeera. The shopkeeper sorts by type, so similar things sit together.
By 1800 about 31 elements were known. By 1865 the count was about 63. Learning each one separately was hopeless. Chemists wanted a pattern that would:
group elements with similar chemistry together,
let you predict the behaviour of one element from its neighbours,
show the gaps where new elements might be found.
Today 118 elements are known. A good table lets you learn one family and know roughly how all its members behave.
1.2 Döbereiner's triads (1829)
Johann Döbereiner noticed groups of three similar elements. When arranged in order of atomic mass, the middle element had a mass close to the average of the other two. Its properties were also roughly in between.
| Triad | Masses (first, middle, third) | Average of first and third | Close to middle? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Li, Na, K | 6.94, 22.99, 39.10 | 23.02 | Yes |
| Ca, Sr, Ba | 40.08, 87.62, 137.33 | 88.71 | Yes |
| Cl, Br, I | 35.45, 79.90, 126.90 | 81.18 | Yes |
Achievement: first clear hint that properties and atomic mass are linked.
Limitation: only a handful of triads could be found. Most known elements did not fit any triad, so the idea could not organise the whole set.
1.3 Newlands' law of octaves (1865)
John Newlands arranged the known elements in increasing order of atomic mass. He found that every eighth element resembled the first, like the eighth note of a music scale (sa re ga ma pa dha ni sa).
For example, counting from lithium: Li, Be, B, C, N, O, F, Na. Sodium, the eighth, behaves like lithium. Noble gases were not yet known, so they do not appear in his count.
Achievement: first arrangement of all known elements in a single sequence showing periodicity.
Limitations:
It worked only for lighter elements, up to about calcium.
Beyond calcium, heavier elements did not repeat every eighth place, so dissimilar elements landed in the same column (for example, Co and Ni with the halogens).
It left no room for elements yet to be discovered.
His idea was mocked at first. The Royal Society later honoured him with the Davy Medal in 1887.
1.4 Lothar Meyer's curve (1869)
Lothar Meyer plotted the atomic volume of elements against their atomic mass. The graph rose and fell in waves. Alkali metals sat on the peaks, and similar elements occupied similar positions on each wave. This was strong visual proof that properties repeat periodically.
1.5 Mendeleev's periodic law (1869)
Dmitri Mendeleev gave the most complete table of his time.
Mendeleev's periodic law: The physical and chemical properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic masses.
He arranged about 63 known elements in rows and columns by increasing atomic mass. He also used the formulas of oxides and hydrides to decide which column an element belonged to. Similar elements fell into the same vertical group.
His genius was that he trusted properties over strict mass order when the two clashed.
What Mendeleev achieved
Systematic study: all known elements fitted into one table with groups and periods.
Gaps for undiscovered elements: he left blank places and named the missing elements with the Sanskrit prefix eka (one): eka-boron, eka-aluminium, eka-silicon.
Correct predictions: these were later found as scandium, gallium and germanium, with properties close to his forecasts.
Correction of atomic masses: he revised doubtful masses. Beryllium's mass was revised from about 13.5 to 9, because its valency is 2, not 3.
Properties before mass: he placed tellurium (127.6) before iodine (126.9), so that Te sits with O, S, Se and I sits with the halogens.
| Property | Eka-aluminium (predicted) | Gallium (found 1875) | Eka-silicon (predicted) | Germanium (found 1886) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atomic mass | 68 | 69.7 | 72 | 72.6 |
| Density (g cm⁻³) | 5.9 | about 5.9 | 5.5 | about 5.3 |
| Melting point | Low | 303 K (melts in your palm) | High | 1211 K |
| Oxide formula | E₂O₃ | Ga₂O₃ | EO₂ | GeO₂ |
| Chloride formula | ECl₃ | GaCl₃ | ECl₄ | GeCl₄ |
Limitations of Mendeleev's table
Position of hydrogen: hydrogen resembles alkali metals (forms H⁺, valency 1) and also halogens (forms H⁻, diatomic gas). It had no unique place.
Anomalous pairs: to keep families together he had to break mass order in a few places (Te before I, Co before Ni; later Ar before K). A law based on mass cannot explain these.
Isotopes: isotopes of one element have different masses but identical chemistry. A mass-based law would need a separate slot for each isotope.
No cause of periodicity: the table showed that properties repeat but could not say why.
Odd groupings: chemically unlike metals shared a group (alkali metals with coinage metals Cu, Ag, Au in group I), while some similar elements were separated.
Lanthanoids: fourteen similar elements after lanthanum did not fit naturally.
All these problems vanish when atomic number replaces atomic mass. That is the subject of Chapter 2.
1.6 Comparing the early attempts
| Scientist (year) | Basis | Key idea | Main weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Döbereiner (1829) | Atomic mass | Triads: middle mass is about the average | Very few triads exist |
| Newlands (1865) | Atomic mass | Every eighth element is similar | Fails after calcium |
| Lothar Meyer (1869) | Atomic mass | Atomic volume curve repeats | Graph, not a full working table |
| Mendeleev (1869) | Atomic mass plus properties | Periodic law, gaps, predictions | Anomalous pairs, isotopes, hydrogen |
Worked examples
Worked example 1.1: Show that Li, Na and K form a Döbereiner triad. Masses: Li 6.94, Na 22.99, K 39.10.
Solution: Average of the outer two = (6.94 + 39.10) / 2 = 46.04 / 2 = 23.02. This is very close to 22.99 for Na. Their chemistry is also similar (soft, reactive metals, form MOH). So they form a triad.
Worked example 1.2: Phosphorus (30.97), arsenic (74.92) and antimony (121.76) are similar non-metal to metalloid elements. Do they fit the triad rule?
Solution: Average of P and Sb = (30.97 + 121.76) / 2 = 76.37. Actual mass of As = 74.92. The gap is 1.45, about 2% of 74.92. This is a reasonable triad fit, about as good as Cl, Br, I.
Worked example 1.3: In Newlands' scheme (no noble gases), which element would resemble magnesium?
Solution: Count Mg as the first note: Mg, Al, Si, P, S, Cl, K, Ca. The eighth is calcium. Indeed Ca and Mg are both alkaline earth metals.
Worked example 1.4: Mendeleev left a gap between Zn and As, below Al. Predict the formulas of the oxide and chloride of the missing element.
Solution: The gap lies in aluminium's group, where the valency is 3. With O (valency 2), the oxide is E₂O₃. With Cl (valency 1), the chloride is ECl₃. Gallium, found later, gives Ga₂O₃ and GaCl₃.
Worked example 1.5: Mendeleev estimated properties of a missing element by averaging its four neighbours. Estimate the atomic mass of eka-silicon from Si (28.09) above, Sn (118.71) below, Ga (69.72) on the left and As (74.92) on the right.
Solution: Sum = 28.09 + 118.71 + 69.72 + 74.92 = 291.44. Average = 291.44 / 4 = 72.86. Germanium's actual mass is 72.63, an error of only about 0.3%.
Worked example 1.6: Beryllium's equivalent mass is 4.5. Chemists first took its valency as 3. What atomic mass did they get, and what did Mendeleev's table suggest?
Solution: Atomic mass = equivalent mass × valency. With valency 3, mass = 13.5, which would place Be between C and N, among non-metals. Mendeleev saw that Be resembles Mg, so its valency should be 2. Mass = 4.5 × 2 = 9. That fits between Li (6.9) and B (10.8).
Worked example 1.7: Argon (39.95) is heavier than potassium (39.10). If a strict mass order were used, what would go wrong?
Solution: Potassium would come before argon. Potassium, a highly reactive metal, would then sit in the noble gas column. Argon, an inert gas, would sit with the alkali metals. Both placements clash with their chemistry. A mass-based law cannot fix this; atomic number (Ar 18, K 19) fixes it at once.
Quick revision
Döbereiner (1829): triads; middle mass is about the average of the other two. Only a few triads exist.
Newlands (1865): law of octaves; every eighth element is similar; works only up to Ca.
Lothar Meyer (1869): atomic volume vs atomic mass curve; alkali metals at peaks.
Mendeleev (1869): properties are a periodic function of atomic masses.
Mendeleev left gaps and predicted eka-boron (Sc), eka-aluminium (Ga) and eka-silicon (Ge).
He corrected Be's mass from 13.5 to 9 and placed Te before I by properties.
Weak points: hydrogen, isotopes, anomalous pairs, no reason for periodicity.
NEET traps
Students say Mendeleev used atomic number. He used atomic mass; atomic number came from Moseley in 1913.
Eka-aluminium is gallium, not aluminium; eka-silicon is germanium, not tin.
Newlands counted every eighth element without noble gases. Do not include Ne or Ar when counting.
The Te–I inversion was Mendeleev's choice by properties. It was not a mass measurement error.
"Left gaps" is an achievement, not a limitation. Read the question stem carefully.
Lothar Meyer plotted atomic volume, not atomic radius or density.
Practice MCQs: Chapter 1
Level 1: Concept check
1. Döbereiner arranged similar elements in groups of (a) two (b) three (c) seven (d) eight
2. In the triad Li, Na, K, the atomic mass of Na is close to (a) the sum of the masses of Li and K (b) the difference of the masses of K and Li (c) the average of the masses of Li and K (d) the product of the masses of Li and K
3. Newlands compared the repetition of properties with (a) the notes of a music scale (b) the phases of the moon (c) the days of a week (d) the colours of a rainbow
4. Newlands' law of octaves worked well only for elements up to (a) calcium (b) iron (c) uranium (d) neon
5. Mendeleev's periodic law is based on (a) atomic number (b) atomic mass (c) number of neutrons (d) number of valence electrons
6. The element Mendeleev called eka-aluminium is now known as (a) scandium (b) germanium (c) gallium (d) aluminium
7. The scientist who plotted atomic volume against atomic mass was (a) Döbereiner (b) Newlands (c) Moseley (d) Lothar Meyer
8. Mendeleev placed tellurium before iodine because (a) Te is lighter than I (b) Te resembles S and Se, while I resembles the halogens (c) Te was discovered first (d) the names follow alphabetical order
9. Eka-silicon predicted by Mendeleev is (a) tin (b) gallium (c) scandium (d) germanium
10. Which of the following was NOT a limitation of Mendeleev's table? (a) Hydrogen had no fixed position (b) Isotopes had no separate place (c) Gaps were left for undiscovered elements (d) The cause of periodicity was not explained
Level 2: NEET standard
11. Sulfur (32.0), selenium (x) and tellurium (127.6) behave as a triad. The expected value of x is about (a) 79.8 (b) 95.6 (c) 159.6 (d) 47.8
12. The predicted formula of the oxide of eka-aluminium was (a) EO (b) EO₂ (c) E₂O₃ (d) E₂O₅
13. In Newlands' arrangement (noble gases unknown), counting sodium as the first element, the eighth element is (a) Cl (b) Ca (c) Ar (d) K
14. In the modern table, which pair appears in the reverse order of atomic mass? (a) Na, Mg (b) Co, Ni (c) N, O (d) Ca, Sc
15. When Mendeleev published his table, the number of known elements was about (a) 92 (b) 118 (c) 63 (d) 36
16. Döbereiner's idea was given up mainly because (a) the middle element was always the heaviest (b) only a few triads could be found among the known elements (c) it was based on atomic number (d) it used oxide formulas
17. Under Mendeleev's law, ³⁵Cl and ³⁷Cl would need separate places because they have different (a) atomic masses (b) atomic numbers (c) chemical properties (d) numbers of electrons
18. The equivalent mass of beryllium is 4.5. Mendeleev assigned it valency 2. Its atomic mass is (a) 13.5 (b) 4.5 (c) 18 (d) 9
19. The predicted formula of the chloride of eka-silicon was (a) ECl₂ (b) ECl₃ (c) ECl₄ (d) E₂Cl₆
20. Averaging the masses of the four neighbours Si (28.1), Sn (118.7), Ga (69.7) and As (74.9) gives the expected mass of eka-silicon as about (a) 58.5 (b) 72.9 (c) 97.0 (d) 46.5
21. The family later added to Mendeleev's table as a new group without disturbing the others was (a) the noble gases (b) the halogens (c) the lanthanoids (d) the alkali metals
22. On Lothar Meyer's atomic volume curve, the peaks are occupied by (a) halogens (b) alkaline earth metals (c) noble gases (d) alkali metals
Level 3: Challenge
23. Three similar elements have masses 9.01, y and 40.08. If they form a perfect Döbereiner triad, the middle element is most likely (a) Na (b) Al (c) Mg (d) K
24. Newlands placed Co and Ni in the same column as F and Cl. This shows that (a) Co and Ni are halogens (b) heavier elements did not follow the octave pattern (c) Newlands used atomic numbers (d) noble gases filled the gaps
25. Gallium, the eka-aluminium of Mendeleev, melts at about 303 K. A small piece held in the palm (about 310 K) will (a) stay solid (b) sublime (c) melt (d) catch fire
26. Which statement about Mendeleev's original table is correct? (a) It was arranged by atomic number (b) Every element followed increasing mass with no exception (c) Noble gases formed group VIII (d) Alkali metals and coinage metals (Cu, Ag) were placed in the same group
27. Using the triad rule with Cl (35.5) and I (126.9), the predicted mass of Br differs from its actual mass (79.9) by about (a) 1.6% (b) 16% (c) 0.16% (d) 6.1%
28. If iodine (126.9) had been placed before tellurium (127.6) strictly by mass, then (a) both would fall among the halogens (b) iodine would fall with O, S, Se and tellurium with the halogens (c) both would fall in the oxygen family (d) nothing would change
29. Assertion (A): Mendeleev left some blank spaces in his periodic table. Reason (R): He believed that some elements were still undiscovered. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true
30. Statement I: Döbereiner's triads covered all the elements known in his time. Statement II: Newlands' law of octaves applied well to the lighter elements up to calcium. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true
Answer key with reasons
| Q | Ans | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | b | Triads are sets of three. |
| 2 | c | (6.94 + 39.10)/2 = 23.02, close to 22.99. |
| 3 | a | Every eighth element is like the eighth note of a scale. |
| 4 | a | Octaves break down beyond calcium. |
| 5 | b | Mendeleev's law uses atomic mass. |
| 6 | c | Gallium filled the eka-aluminium gap. |
| 7 | d | Lothar Meyer drew the atomic volume curve. |
| 8 | b | He grouped by properties, not strict mass. |
| 9 | d | Germanium is eka-silicon. |
| 10 | c | Leaving gaps was an achievement. |
| 11 | a | (32.0 + 127.6)/2 = 79.8. |
| 12 | c | Group valency 3 with O gives E₂O₃. |
| 13 | d | Na, Mg, Al, Si, P, S, Cl, K: K is eighth. |
| 14 | b | Co (58.93) comes before Ni (58.69). |
| 15 | c | About 63 elements were known in 1869. |
| 16 | b | Most elements fitted no triad. |
| 17 | a | Isotopes differ in mass only. |
| 18 | d | 4.5 × 2 = 9. |
| 19 | c | Silicon's group shows valency 4: ECl₄. |
| 20 | b | 291.4/4 = 72.9. |
| 21 | a | Noble gases were added as group zero. |
| 22 | d | Alkali metals have the largest atomic volumes. |
| 23 | c | (9.01 + 40.08)/2 = 24.55, close to Mg (24.31); Be, Mg, Ca are alike. |
| 24 | b | Dissimilar heavy elements shared columns. |
| 25 | c | 310 K is above its melting point of 303 K. |
| 26 | d | Group I held both Na and Cu, Ag. |
| 27 | a | Predicted 81.2; (81.2 − 79.9)/79.9 = 1.6%. |
| 28 | b | I would land in the O family, Te among halogens. |
| 29 | a | Gaps were for undiscovered elements. |
| 30 | d | Few triads existed; octaves held up to Ca. |
Chapter 1 revision sheet
One-page summary
Classification lets us study 118 elements as a few families instead of one by one.
Döbereiner (1829): triads of similar elements; the middle atomic mass is close to the mean of the other two.
Triad examples: Li–Na–K, Ca–Sr–Ba, Cl–Br–I. Only a handful of triads exist, so the idea could not be extended.
Newlands (1865): law of octaves; arranged by atomic mass, every eighth element resembles the first, like the notes sa re ga ma pa dha ni sa.
Octaves worked only up to calcium; noble gases were unknown then.
Lothar Meyer (1869): plotted atomic volume against atomic mass; alkali metals sit at the peaks of the curve.
Atomic volume = molar mass / density.
Mendeleev (1869): properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic masses.
He gave priority to properties over strict mass order: Te placed before I.
He corrected doubtful masses (Be from 13.5 to 9) and left gaps for undiscovered elements.
Predictions confirmed: eka-aluminium = Ga, eka-silicon = Ge, eka-boron = Sc.
Limitations: hydrogen's position, isotopes, anomalous pairs (Ar–K, Co–Ni, Te–I), no reason for periodicity.
Moseley (1913) showed atomic number is the true basis; this removed the anomalies.
Must-remember table
| Item | Value or fact |
|---|---|
| Li–Na–K triad | mean of Li and K = (6.94 + 39.10)/2 = 23.02; Na = 22.99 |
| Ca–Sr–Ba triad | mean = 88.7; Sr = 87.62 |
| Cl–Br–I triad | mean = 81.2; Br = 79.90 |
| Newlands' limit | works up to Ca (Z = 20) |
| Eka-silicon predicted vs Ge | mass 72 vs 72.6; density 5.5 vs 5.36 g/cm³; oxide EO₂ vs GeO₂ |
| Eka-aluminium predicted vs Ga | mass about 68 vs 69.7; oxide E₂O₃; low melting point |
| Anomalous pairs (mass order broken) | Ar 39.95 / K 39.10; Co 58.93 / Ni 58.69; Te 127.60 / I 126.90 |
| Be atomic mass | corrected from 13.5 to 9 |
Memory aids
"Do New Lovers Marry Mostly?" gives the order of work: Dobereiner (1829), Newlands (1865), Lothar Meyer (1869), Mendeleev (1869), Moseley (1913).
"GA-GE-SC = Al-Si-B": eka-Aluminium is Ga, eka-Silicon is Ge, eka-Boron is Sc. Read it as "Ga below Al, Ge below Si, Sc for B".
"ArK, CoNi, TeI" for the three anomalous pairs, written in the order Mendeleev placed them (heavier first).
Octave = 8 notes: sa re ga ma pa dha ni sa. The eighth note repeats the first, just as Na repeats Li.
Concept connections
Moseley's X-ray work and atomic number link to Chemistry Book 2: Atomic Structure and Physics Book 18: Atoms and Nuclei.
Atomic mass values and averages used in triads come from Chemistry Book 1: Some Basic Concepts in Chemistry.
Mendeleev's predicted Ga and Ge are studied as group 13 and 14 members in Chemistry Book 10: p-Block Elements.
Practice MCQs: Chapter 1, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)
31. Match List I (scientist) with List II (contribution).
List I:
A. Döbereiner
B. Newlands
C. Lothar Meyer
D. Moseley
List II:
i. Curve of atomic volume against atomic mass
ii. Groups of three similar elements
iii. X-ray frequencies linked to atomic number
iv. Law of octaves
(a) A-iv, B-ii, C-i, D-iii (b) A-ii, B-iv, C-iii, D-i (c) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii (d) A-i, B-iv, C-ii, D-iii
32. Match Mendeleev's name in List I with the modern element in List II.
List I:
A. Eka-aluminium
B. Eka-silicon
C. Eka-boron
D. Eka-manganese
List II:
i. Scandium
ii. Technetium
iii. Germanium
iv. Gallium
(a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-i, B-iii, C-iv, D-ii (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (d) A-iv, B-i, C-iii, D-ii
33. Match the work in List I with its year in List II.
List I:
A. Döbereiner's triads
B. Newlands' octaves
C. Mendeleev's periodic table
D. Moseley's atomic number work
List II:
i. 1913
ii. 1865
iii. 1829
iv. 1869
(a) A-ii, B-iii, C-iv, D-i (b) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (c) A-iii, B-ii, C-i, D-iv (d) A-iii, B-ii, C-iv, D-i
34. Match the feature of Mendeleev's table in List I with the example in List II.
List I:
A. Atomic mass corrected
B. Order reversed to keep properties together
C. Gap left for an unknown element
D. Element with no fixed place
List II:
i. Hydrogen
ii. Tellurium and iodine
iii. Beryllium
iv. Germanium
(a) A-ii, B-iii, C-iv, D-i (b) A-iii, B-ii, C-iv, D-i (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (d) A-i, B-ii, C-iv, D-iii
35. How many of the following statements are correct?
A. Newlands' law of octaves held well only up to calcium.
B. On Lothar Meyer's curve, the alkali metals occupy the peaks.
C. Mendeleev's periodic law is based on atomic number.
D. Döbereiner's triads covered all the elements known in 1829.
E. Mendeleev described germanium's properties before it was discovered.
(a) 2 (b) 3 (c) 4 (d) 5
36. Choose the correct set of statements.
A. In the triad Ca, Sr, Ba, the mass of Sr is close to the mean of Ca and Ba.
B. In the triad Cl, Br, I, the mean of Cl and I is about 81, close to Br.
C. Mendeleev placed every element strictly in order of increasing atomic mass.
D. Mendeleev's original table had no group for the noble gases.
(a) A and B only (b) B, C and D only (c) A, B and D only (d) A, C and D only
37. How many of the following are limitations of Mendeleev's table?
A. The position of hydrogen was uncertain.
B. Isotopes of an element had no separate places.
C. Argon had to be placed before potassium against the mass order.
D. It predicted the properties of unknown elements.
E. It gave no reason why properties repeat.
(a) 4 (b) 5 (c) 2 (d) 3
38. Choose the correct set of statements about Newlands' work.
A. Elements were arranged in increasing atomic mass.
B. He compared the repeat of properties to musical notes.
C. Noble gases filled the eighth position in each octave.
D. The pattern broke down for elements heavier than calcium.
(a) A, B and D only (b) A and C only (c) B, C and D only (d) All four
39. The table compares Mendeleev's predictions for eka-silicon with germanium.
| Property | Predicted | Observed (Ge) |
|---|---|---|
| Atomic mass | 72 | 72.6 |
| Density (g/cm³) | 5.5 | 5.36 |
| Oxide formula | EO₂ | GeO₂ |
| Chloride formula | ECl₄ | GeCl₄ |
Which conclusion follows from the table?
(a) Germanium belongs to group 13 (b) The predicted density is more than 10% off (c) The formulas match exactly, so the predicted valency of 4 was right (d) The predicted atomic mass is off by more than 5 units
40. Atomic volume = molar mass / density. Use these data: Na 22.99 g/mol, 0.97 g/cm³; K 39.10 g/mol, 0.86 g/cm³; Mg 24.31 g/mol, 1.74 g/cm³; Al 26.98 g/mol, 2.70 g/cm³. Which has the largest atomic volume?
(a) K (b) Na (c) Mg (d) Al
41. On a plot of atomic volume (y-axis) against atomic mass (x-axis), the curve rises to sharp peaks at regular intervals. The elements at these peaks are the
(a) halogens (b) noble gases (c) alkaline earth metals (d) alkali metals
Case for Q42–43: A student wants to test whether sulfur (32.06), selenium (78.97) and tellurium (127.60) form a Döbereiner triad. She takes the mean of the first and third masses and compares it with the middle one.
42. The mean of the atomic masses of S and Te is about
(a) 78.97 (b) 79.83 (c) 95.3 (d) 47.8
43. What should the student conclude?
(a) Se lies within about 1% of the mean, so S–Se–Te behaves like a triad (b) Se's mass is double the mean, so it is not a triad (c) The difference is above 10%, so the triad fails (d) Te, not Se, should be the middle member
44. Mendeleev predicted the formulas of the oxide and chloride of eka-aluminium (E) as
(a) EO and ECl₂ (b) EO₂ and ECl₄ (c) E₂O₃ and ECl₃ (d) E₂O₅ and ECl₅
45. In which pair does the order by modern atomic number agree with the order by atomic mass (so Mendeleev needed no reversal)?
(a) Ar and K (b) Co and Ni (c) Te and I (d) Cl and Ar
Level 4 answer key
| Q | Ans | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 31 | c | Döbereiner triads, Newlands octaves, Meyer curve, Moseley X-rays |
| 32 | a | Ga, Ge, Sc and Tc fill the eka-Al, eka-Si, eka-B and eka-Mn gaps |
| 33 | d | 1829, 1865, 1869, 1913 |
| 34 | b | Be mass corrected; Te before I; gap for Ge; hydrogen floats |
| 35 | b | A, B and E are correct; Mendeleev used atomic mass; triads were few |
| 36 | c | Means 88.7 (Sr 87.62) and 81.2 (Br 79.90); Te–I reversal makes C false; noble gases were unknown |
| 37 | a | A, B, C and E are limitations; D is a success |
| 38 | a | Noble gases were not yet discovered, so C is false |
| 39 | c | Density differs by about 2.6%, mass by 0.6; EO₂ and ECl₄ imply valency 4; Ge is group 14 |
| 40 | a | K 45.5, Na 23.7, Mg 14.0, Al 10.0 cm³/mol |
| 41 | d | Alkali metals have the largest atomic volumes in each period |
| 42 | b | (32.06 + 127.60)/2 = 79.83 |
| 43 | a | (79.83 − 78.97)/78.97 is about 1.1% |
| 44 | c | Eka-aluminium sits in the Al group, valency 3: E₂O₃ and ECl₃ |
| 45 | d | Cl 35.45 before Ar 39.95 follows mass order; the other three are reversed pairs |