Chapter 6 of 10 · 24 min read

Chapter 4: Wave Theory Failures and the Particle Nature of Light

What you will learn

  • What the wave theory of light predicts about the photoelectric effect.

  • The three observations that the wave theory cannot explain.

  • How to estimate the time lag that the wave theory would predict.

  • Why the photon picture succeeds, and what "particle nature of light" means.

  • The dual nature of radiation: which experiments show waves, which show particles.

4.1 The wave picture of light

By 1900, light was firmly known to be an electromagnetic wave. Interference, diffraction and polarisation all fitted, and Maxwell's equations predicted its speed.

In the wave picture:

  • Energy is spread evenly and continuously over the whole wavefront.

  • The intensity (energy per second per unit area) depends on the square of the amplitude, not on the frequency.

  • Any surface in the path soaks up energy continuously, a little at a time.

Think of monsoon rain falling as a fine, even drizzle over a whole field. Each blade of grass gets a little water every second, and slowly fills up.

4.2 What the wave theory predicts for the photoelectric effect

Apply this picture to electrons in a metal.

  1. Energy and intensity. Brighter light has a bigger electric field amplitude. It shakes electrons harder. So the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted electrons should rise with intensity.

  2. No threshold. Even low-frequency light carries energy. If it is bright enough, or shines long enough, electrons should collect enough energy to escape. So any frequency should work.

  3. Time lag. With very dim light, an electron should need a long time to gather the energy φ₀. So emission should start only after a delay.

All three predictions are wrong.

4.3 Failure 1: maximum kinetic energy does not depend on intensity

Experiment (Chapter 2): the stopping potential is the same for all intensities. Brighter light gives more electrons, not faster ones. The wave theory has no way to keep the energy per electron fixed while the field gets stronger.

4.4 Failure 2: there is a threshold frequency

Experiment: below ν₀, there is no emission even with very intense light kept on for a long time. A 1000 W red lamp cannot free a single electron from zinc, while a faint ultraviolet lamp can. The wave theory says brightness should win. It does not.

4.5 Failure 3: there is no time lag

Experiment: emission starts within about 10⁻⁹ s, however dim the light.

Let us estimate what the wave theory predicts. An electron can only collect energy falling on about the area of one atom, roughly 10⁻²⁰ m² (an atom is about 10⁻¹⁰ m across).

t=ϕ0I×At = \frac{\phi_{0}}{I \times A}

Take φ₀ = 2.0 eV = 3.2 × 10⁻¹⁹ J, I = 0.01 W/m² (dim room light) and A = 10⁻²⁰ m². Power on one atom = 10⁻²² W. Then t = 3.2 × 10⁻¹⁹ / 10⁻²² = 3200 s, about 53 minutes.

The wave theory predicts nearly an hour of waiting. The real delay is less than a nanosecond. This mismatch is too large to fix by adjusting numbers.

4.6 The three failures side by side

ObservationWave theory predictionWhat is actually seenPhoton explanation
Effect of intensity on KₘₐₓKₘₐₓ rises with intensityKₘₐₓ independent of intensityEach electron gets one photon of energy hν; intensity only changes photon number
Threshold frequencyAny frequency works if light is bright or long enoughNo emission below ν₀ at any intensityOne photon must carry at least φ₀, so hν must be at least hν₀
Time lagLong delay for dim lightEmission within about 10⁻⁹ sEnergy arrives in a lump, delivered at once by a single photon
Effect of intensity on currentCurrent rises with intensityCurrent rises with intensityMore photons per second, more electrons per second

The last row is the only point where both theories agree. It cannot decide between them.

4.7 The particle nature of light

Einstein's photon picture explains every row. Light behaves as a stream of particles, each carrying:

E=hν,p=hλE = h\nu, \qquad p = \frac{h}{\lambda}

Back to the rain picture: light is not a fine drizzle but a shower of separate drops. Each drop is the same size for a given colour. A blade of grass is either hit by a whole drop or not at all. A heavier shower means more drops, not bigger ones.

Even dim light delivers photons quickly. At 10⁻⁶ W/m² of 500 nm light, about 2.5 × 10⁸ photons hit each square centimetre every second. Any one of them can free an electron at once.

More evidence for photons came in 1923. Arthur Compton scattered X-rays off electrons and found the scattered X-rays had a longer wavelength. The shift matched a billiard-ball collision between a photon (with momentum h/λ) and an electron. This is the Compton effect. Treat it as background; NEET only needs to know it supports the particle nature of light.

4.8 Dual nature of radiation

So is light a wave or a particle? It shows both behaviours, depending on the experiment.

PhenomenonNature it shows
InterferenceWave
DiffractionWave
PolarisationWave
Photoelectric effectParticle (photon)
Compton effectParticle (photon)
Emission and absorption of light by atoms in fixed lumpsParticle (photon)

In a single experiment, light shows one face or the other, not both at once. The two pictures are linked by E = hν and p = h/λ: the particle quantities (E, p) are set by the wave quantities (ν, λ). This is the dual nature of radiation.

In Chapter 5 we see that matter has the same double nature.

4.9 Photocells in daily life

A photocell is a practical photoelectric tube or its semiconductor cousin. Light on it makes a current; block the light and the current stops. Uses include:

  • automatic doors at malls and metro stations, where a person cuts a light beam,

  • burglar alarms and counting devices on factory belts,

  • exposure meters in cameras,

  • street lights that switch on at dusk.

Worked examples

Worked example 4.1: Using the wave picture, estimate how long an electron in a metal (φ₀ = 2.0 eV) would take to escape under light of intensity 0.01 W/m². Assume it collects energy over 10⁻²⁰ m².

Solution: Power collected = 0.01 × 10⁻²⁰ = 10⁻²² W. Energy needed = 3.2 × 10⁻¹⁹ J. t = 3.2 × 10⁻¹⁹ / 10⁻²² = 3.2 × 10³ s ≈ 53 minutes.

Worked example 4.2: Repeat Worked example 4.1 for very dim light of 10⁻⁶ W/m². Compare with experiment.

Solution: Power collected = 10⁻²⁶ W. t = 3.2 × 10⁻¹⁹ / 10⁻²⁶ = 3.2 × 10⁷ s, about one year. In experiment, emission still starts within 10⁻⁹ s. The wave theory fails badly.

Worked example 4.3: For the light in Worked example 4.2 (500 nm), how many photons fall on 1 cm² each second?

Solution: Photon energy = hc/λ = 6.63 × 10⁻³⁴ × 3 × 10⁸ / 5 × 10⁻⁷ = 3.98 × 10⁻¹⁹ J. Power on 1 cm² = 10⁻⁶ × 10⁻⁴ = 10⁻¹⁰ W. N = 10⁻¹⁰ / 3.98 × 10⁻¹⁹ ≈ 2.5 × 10⁸ per second. Photons arrive at once, so emission is immediate, just fewer electrons.

Worked example 4.4: A red source (700 nm) and a violet source (400 nm) each emit 1 W. (a) Which emits more photons per second, and by what factor? (b) Which can eject electrons from potassium (φ₀ = 2.30 eV)?

Solution: (a) N = Pλ/hc, so N ∝ λ at equal power. N(red)/N(violet) = 700/400 = 1.75. Red sends more photons.

(b) Red photon energy = 1240/700 ≈ 1.77 eV, less than 2.30 eV: no emission. Violet photon energy = 1240/400 = 3.1 eV: emission. More photons do not help if each is too weak.

Worked example 4.5: Zinc has φ₀ = 4.3 eV. A 1000 W red lamp and a 1 mW ultraviolet lamp of 250 nm each shine on clean zinc. Which causes emission?

Solution: UV photon energy = 1240/250 = 4.96 eV, more than 4.3 eV. Emission, with Kₘₐₓ = 0.66 eV. Red photons (about 1.8 eV) are below 4.3 eV, so no emission, despite a million times more power.

Worked example 4.6: At a certain intensity, Kₘₐₓ = 1.2 eV and saturation current = 3 µA. The intensity is made four times larger. What does (a) the wave theory predict, (b) experiment show?

Solution: (a) Wave theory: Kₘₐₓ should go up (a stronger field shakes electrons harder). (b) Experiment and the photon picture: Kₘₐₓ stays 1.2 eV, and the saturation current becomes 4 × 3 = 12 µA.

Worked example 4.7: Sort these into wave or particle evidence: (i) colours in a soap film, (ii) photocell in an automatic door, (iii) spreading of light past a thin hair, (iv) Compton scattering, (v) sunglasses that cut glare.

Solution: (i) interference: wave. (ii) photoelectric effect: particle. (iii) diffraction: wave. (iv) Compton effect: particle. (v) polarisation: wave.

Quick revision

  • Wave theory: energy spread continuously; intensity depends on amplitude squared, not frequency.

  • Wave theory fails on three counts: Kₘₐₓ independent of intensity, threshold frequency, no time lag.

  • Both theories agree that current rises with intensity, so that fact cannot choose between them.

  • Wave estimate of time lag for dim light: minutes to years. Observed: below 10⁻⁹ s.

  • Photon: E = hν, p = h/λ; absorbed whole by one electron.

  • Wave nature: interference, diffraction, polarisation. Particle nature: photoelectric and Compton effects.

NEET traps

  • Listing "photocurrent increases with intensity" as a failure of wave theory. Wave theory explains that too.

  • Thinking a very bright beam below threshold will eventually cause emission. It never does.

  • Saying red light of high power has more energetic photons. It has more photons, each with less energy than violet.

  • Calling polarisation particle evidence. Polarisation shows light is a transverse wave.

  • Assuming light is "half wave, half particle" in every experiment. In one experiment, it shows one behaviour.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 4

Level 1: Concept check

1. According to the wave theory, the maximum kinetic energy of photoelectrons should depend on (a) frequency only (b) intensity (c) neither intensity nor frequency (d) colour only

2. Which of these cannot be explained by the wave theory of light? (a) Interference (b) Diffraction (c) Threshold frequency in the photoelectric effect (d) Polarisation

3. Which phenomenon shows the particle nature of light? (a) Photoelectric effect (b) Interference (c) Diffraction (d) Polarisation

4. The wave theory predicts a time lag for dim light because (a) light travels slowly in metals (b) electrons are heavy (c) the metal must warm up first (d) energy is spread over the wavefront and collected gradually

5. In the photon picture, raising the intensity at fixed frequency increases (a) the energy of each photon (b) the frequency (c) the number of photons per second (d) the speed of photons

6. "Dual nature of radiation" means that light (a) shows wave behaviour in some experiments and particle behaviour in others (b) is a wave in vacuum and a particle in glass (c) is made of two kinds of photons (d) has two speeds

7. The Compton effect supports (a) the wave nature of light (b) the particle nature of light (c) the wave nature of electrons (d) neither

8. According to the wave theory, light of any frequency should eject electrons provided (a) the intensity is large enough or the light falls long enough (b) the metal is cold (c) the frequency is above threshold (d) the wavelength is short

9. Which was NOT a failure of the wave theory? (a) Existence of a threshold frequency (b) Kₘₐₓ independent of intensity (c) Instantaneous emission (d) Photocurrent increasing with intensity

10. Interference of light is best explained by (a) the photon theory (b) the wave theory (c) neither theory (d) Einstein's photoelectric equation

Level 2: NEET standard

11. In the wave picture, a metal (φ₀ = 2.5 eV) receives light of intensity 5 × 10⁻³ W/m², and an electron collects energy over 10⁻¹⁹ m². The predicted time lag is about (a) 13 s (b) 0.8 s (c) 13 min (d) 13 h

12. In experiments, the time lag in photoelectric emission is found to be (a) about 13 min (b) less than about 10⁻⁹ s (c) about 1 s (d) larger for dimmer light

13. A red source (600 nm) and a violet source (400 nm) each emit 1 W. The ratio of photons emitted per second (red : violet) is (a) 3 : 2 (b) 2 : 3 (c) 1 : 1 (d) 9 : 4

14. Light of 550 nm and of 450 nm falls in turn on a metal of work function 2.5 eV. Emission occurs with (a) both (b) neither (c) only 550 nm (d) only 450 nm

15. Clean zinc (φ₀ = 4.3 eV) is lit by a 1 kW red lamp and separately by a 1 mW ultraviolet lamp of 250 nm. Emission occurs with (a) only the red lamp (b) both lamps (c) only the ultraviolet lamp (d) neither lamp

16. The intensity of light (above threshold) on a photocell is made four times larger. Then (a) Kₘₐₓ is unchanged and the saturation current becomes four times (b) Kₘₐₓ and current both double (c) Kₘₐₓ becomes four times, current unchanged (d) both become four times

17. Light of 500 nm and intensity 10⁻⁶ W/m² falls on a surface. About how many photons strike 1 cm² per second? (a) 2.5 × 10¹² (b) 2.5 × 10⁸ (c) 2.5 × 10⁴ (d) 4 × 10⁻¹⁹

18. Which observation can be explained by both the wave and photon theories? (a) Threshold frequency (b) Instantaneous emission (c) Kₘₐₓ independent of intensity (d) Photocurrent increasing with intensity

19. In the wave theory, the energy carried by a light wave depends on (a) its frequency (b) the square of its amplitude (c) its wavelength (d) its speed

20. Which pairing of phenomenon and nature of light is wrong? (a) Diffraction – wave (b) Photoelectric effect – particle (c) Polarisation – particle (d) Compton effect – particle

21. In the photon picture, the photocurrent saturates at a given intensity because (a) photons slow down in the metal (b) electrons repel each other (c) the work function rises (d) the number of electrons emitted per second is fixed by the rate of photon arrival

22. In the wave picture, brighter light means a larger field amplitude. So electrons should come out with (a) a larger maximum kinetic energy (b) the same maximum kinetic energy (c) lower speed (d) no kinetic energy

Level 3: Challenge

23. In the wave picture, a metal of work function 3.0 eV is lit with intensity 10⁻³ W/m², and each electron collects energy over 2 × 10⁻²⁰ m². The predicted time lag is about (a) 6.7 min (b) 6.7 h (c) 24 s (d) 40 min

24. Source A emits 2 W at 400 nm and source B emits 1 W at 800 nm. The ratio of photons per second (A : B) is (a) 2 : 1 (b) 1 : 2 (c) 4 : 1 (d) 1 : 1

25. Potassium (φ₀ = 2.3 eV) is lit in turn by 620 nm, 496 nm and 413 nm light. Which cause emission, and what is the largest Kₘₐₓ? (a) All three; 1.0 eV (b) Only 413 nm; 0.7 eV (c) 496 nm and 413 nm; 0.7 eV (d) 496 nm and 413 nm; 0.2 eV

26. A 1 mW beam of 400 nm light falls on a photocell. One electron is emitted for every 100 photons. The saturation current is about (a) 3.2 µA (b) 0.32 mA (c) 32 µA (d) 0.32 µA

27. If the wave theory were correct, which would be observed? (a) No emission below a threshold frequency (b) Instantaneous emission for dim light (c) Stopping potential depending only on frequency (d) Kₘₐₓ rising with intensity

28. At ordinary intensities, light of photon energy 2.5 eV falls on a metal of work function 3.0 eV. What happens? (a) Emission with Kₘₐₓ = 2.0 eV, since two photons combine (b) No emission (c) Emission with zero kinetic energy (d) Emission with Kₘₐₓ = 5.0 eV

29. Assertion (A): Light of very high intensity but below the threshold frequency cannot cause photoelectric emission. Reason (R): Photon energy depends on frequency, and one electron absorbs one photon. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true

30. Statement I: Light shows wave behaviour in interference. Statement II: Light shows particle behaviour in the photoelectric effect. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true

Answer key with reasons

QAnsReason
1bWave energy grows with intensity
2cThreshold has no wave explanation
3aPhotoelectric effect needs photons
4dSpread-out energy must be gathered slowly
5cIntensity sets photon number
6aWave in some experiments, particle in others
7bPhoton–electron collision explains the shift
8aWave theory relies on enough energy reaching the electron
9dWave theory also predicts current rising with intensity
10bSuperposition of waves
11ct = 4 × 10⁻¹⁹ / (5 × 10⁻³ × 10⁻¹⁹) = 800 s ≈ 13 min
12bEmission is practically instant
13aN ∝ λ at equal power: 600 : 400
14d1240/550 = 2.25 eV (too low), 1240/450 = 2.76 eV (enough)
15cUV photon 4.96 eV exceeds 4.3 eV; red photons do not
16aIntensity changes number, not energy, of electrons
17b10⁻¹⁰ W / 3.98 × 10⁻¹⁹ J ≈ 2.5 × 10⁸
18dMore energy flow, more electrons, in both pictures
19bIntensity ∝ amplitude²
20cPolarisation is wave evidence
21dAll emitted electrons are collected; their rate is set by photons
22aStronger field, harder shaking, in the wave picture
23bt = 4.8 × 10⁻¹⁹ / (10⁻³ × 2 × 10⁻²⁰) = 2.4 × 10⁴ s ≈ 6.7 h
24dN ∝ Pλ: 2 × 400 = 1 × 800
25cPhoton energies 2.0, 2.5, 3.0 eV; Kₘₐₓ = 3.0 − 2.3 = 0.7 eV
26a2.0 × 10¹⁵ photons/s gives 2.0 × 10¹³ electrons/s, I ≈ 3.2 µA
27dWave theory links electron energy to intensity
28bOne photon per electron; 2.5 eV is below 3.0 eV
29aR is exactly why intensity cannot help below threshold
30aBoth statements describe the dual nature correctly

Chapter 4 revision sheet

One-page summary

  • Wave theory: light energy spreads continuously over the wavefront. Intensity depends on amplitude squared, not on frequency.

  • Wave theory prediction 1: brighter light should give faster electrons. Observed: Kₘₐₓ does not depend on intensity.

  • Prediction 2: any frequency should work if you wait long enough. Observed: no emission below ν₀, however bright the light.

  • Prediction 3: dim light should need a time lag (minutes to years by estimate). Observed: emission within about 10⁻⁹ s.

  • Wave theory does explain current rising with intensity, so that fact cannot decide between the two theories.

  • Photon picture: energy comes in packets E = hν, each absorbed whole by one electron.

  • More intensity means more photons per second, so more electrons per second, but each with the same Kₘₐₓ.

  • One photon must carry at least φ₀; that gives the threshold frequency.

  • A single photon delivers its energy at once, so there is no time lag.

  • Compton effect: a photon collides with an electron like a particle, transfers momentum, and comes out with a longer wavelength.

  • Wave nature shows in interference, diffraction and polarisation. Particle nature shows in the photoelectric and Compton effects.

  • In any single experiment, light shows one face clearly. This is the dual nature of radiation.

  • A photocell turns a light signal into an electric current; it is used in light meters, automatic doors and alarms.

Must-remember table

ObservationWave theory predictionPhoton picture explanation
Kₘₐₓ vs intensityShould increaseFixed by hν − φ₀; intensity only changes photon number
Threshold frequencyShould not existOne photon must supply at least φ₀ = hν₀
Time lagMinutes to years for dim lightBelow 10⁻⁹ s; energy arrives in one packet
Current vs intensityIncreasesIncreases (both agree)
Interference, diffraction, polarisationExplainedNot explained by the photon picture alone
Compton scatteringNot explainedPhoton carries momentum h/λ

Memory aids

  • "KTT failures": K = Kₘₐₓ independent of intensity, T = Threshold frequency, T = no Time lag. Three failures of wave theory.

  • "IDP waves, PC particles": Interference, Diffraction, Polarisation for waves; Photoelectric and Compton for particles.

  • "One photon, one electron": the whole-packet rule explains all three failures at once.

  • "Compton stretches light": after scattering the photon has less energy, so its wavelength is stretched longer.

Concept connections

  • Interference, diffraction and polarisation are studied in Physics Book 16: Optics.

  • Energy carried by electromagnetic waves and intensity link to Physics Book 15: Electromagnetic Waves.

  • Photodiodes and light sensors build on this in Physics Book 19: Electronic Devices.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 4, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)

31. Match each observation with its photon-picture explanation.

List I

  • A. Kₘₐₓ does not depend on intensity

  • B. A threshold frequency exists

  • C. Emission starts without measurable delay

  • D. Photocurrent rises with intensity

List II

  • (i) Photon energy hν must be at least φ₀

  • (ii) More photons arrive each second

  • (iii) Each electron absorbs one photon whose energy depends only on ν

  • (iv) Energy is delivered in a single packet at once

(a) A-iii, B-i, C-iv, D-ii (b) A-i, B-iii, C-iv, D-ii (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (d) A-ii, B-i, C-iv, D-iii

32. Match the phenomenon with what it shows.

List I

  • A. Interference

  • B. Polarisation

  • C. Photoelectric effect

  • D. Compton effect

List II

  • (i) Light waves are transverse

  • (ii) One photon gives its whole energy to one electron

  • (iii) A photon carries momentum and comes out with a longer wavelength after hitting an electron

  • (iv) Bright and dark fringes from superposition

(a) A-i, B-iv, C-ii, D-iii (b) A-iv, B-i, C-iii, D-ii (c) A-iv, B-i, C-ii, D-iii (d) A-ii, B-i, C-iv, D-iii

33. Match the wave-theory prediction with what experiments actually show.

List I

  • A. Kₘₐₓ should rise with intensity

  • B. Any frequency should work if we wait

  • C. Dim light should need a long time lag

  • D. Photocurrent should rise with intensity

List II

  • (i) Emission within about 10⁻⁹ s

  • (ii) Agrees with experiment

  • (iii) Kₘₐₓ is independent of intensity

  • (iv) No emission below ν₀

(a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (d) A-i, B-iv, C-iii, D-ii

34. Match the wavelength with the photon energy (hc = 1240 eV nm).

List I

  • A. 700 nm

  • B. 550 nm

  • C. 400 nm

  • D. 250 nm

List II

  • (i) 3.10 eV

  • (ii) 4.96 eV

  • (iii) 1.77 eV

  • (iv) 2.25 eV

(a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-i, C-iv, D-ii (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (d) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii

35. How many of the following statements are correct?

  • A. In wave theory, intensity is proportional to the square of the amplitude.

  • B. Wave theory can explain why photocurrent rises with intensity.

  • C. Wave theory predicts a threshold frequency.

  • D. The Compton effect supports the particle nature of light.

(a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 4

36. Choose the correct set of statements.

  • A. Light shows wave nature in some experiments and particle nature in others.

  • B. The energy of a photon depends on the intensity of the beam.

  • C. In Compton scattering, the scattered photon has a longer wavelength.

  • D. Diffraction is fully explained by the photon picture alone.

(a) A and C only (b) A, B and C only (c) B and D only (d) A, C and D only

37. A metal has φ₀ = 4.3 eV. Choose the correct set of statements (hc = 1240 eV nm).

  • A. Very intense red light of 700 nm cannot eject electrons from it.

  • B. Weak UV light of 200 nm can eject electrons from it.

  • C. With weak 200 nm light, emission starts without measurable delay.

  • D. Red light made bright enough will eventually eject electrons.

(a) A and B only (b) A and D only (c) B, C and D only (d) A, B and C only

38. How many statements about a photocell are correct?

  • A. It turns a light signal into an electric current.

  • B. Its current does not depend on the intensity of light.

  • C. It works for light of any frequency.

  • D. For visible light, its emitter is usually coated with an alkali metal.

(a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 4

39. A wave-theory estimate uses the data below.

QuantityValue
Intensity of light on the metal1.0 × 10⁻² W/m²
Area one atom collects light from1.0 × 10⁻²⁰ m²
Work function3.2 × 10⁻¹⁹ J

The time needed for one electron to gather enough energy, by wave theory, is about:

(a) 3.2 s (b) 32 s (c) 3.2 × 10³ s (d) 3.2 × 10⁻⁹ s

40. For light of fixed frequency above ν₀, Kₘₐₓ (y-axis) is plotted against intensity (x-axis). The photon picture predicts:

(a) A horizontal straight line (b) A straight line through the origin (c) A rising curve that levels off (d) A falling straight line

41. Two sources shine on a metal with φ₀ = 2.5 eV (hc = 1240 eV nm).

SourceWavelengthPower
Red lamp650 nm100 W
Violet LED400 nm1 W

Which produces photoelectrons?

(a) Only the red lamp, because it has more power (b) Both (c) Neither (d) Only the violet LED

Case for Q42–43. Riya tests a potassium plate (φ₀ = 2.3 eV) with two sources: a 1 mW blue LED of wavelength 450 nm and a 50 W red lamp of wavelength 700 nm. Her friend says the 50 W lamp must work better because it is 50,000 times more powerful. (hc = 1240 eV nm)

42. Which source ejects photoelectrons?

(a) Red lamp only (b) Blue LED only (c) Both (d) Neither

43. The maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons is about:

(a) 2.76 eV (b) 0.53 eV (c) 0.46 eV (d) 1.77 eV

44. A 100 W source of 650 nm light and a 1 W source of 400 nm light are compared. The ratio of photons emitted per second (650 nm source : 400 nm source) is about:

(a) 100 (b) 62 (c) 1.6 (d) 163

45. Assertion (A): Making light of frequency below ν₀ more intense does not cause photoelectric emission.

Reason (R): With ordinary light, the chance of one electron absorbing two photons together is negligible.

(a) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true

Level 4 answer key

QAnsReason
31aEach failure of wave theory is explained by one-photon, one-electron absorption
32cFringes, transverse waves, whole-photon absorption, photon momentum
33bThree predictions fail; only the current–intensity link agrees
34d1240/700 = 1.77, 1240/550 = 2.25, 1240/400 = 3.10, 1240/250 = 4.96 eV
35cA, B, D true; wave theory has no threshold (C false)
36aPhoton energy depends on ν only; diffraction needs the wave picture
37d700 nm gives 1.77 eV, below 4.3 eV, at any brightness; 200 nm gives 6.2 eV
38bA and D true; current depends on intensity and frequency must exceed ν₀
39cPower on one atom = 10⁻² × 10⁻²⁰ = 10⁻²² W; t = 3.2 × 10⁻¹⁹ / 10⁻²² = 3200 s
40aKₘₐₓ = hν − φ₀ has no intensity term
41dRed photon 1.91 eV, below 2.5 eV; violet photon 3.10 eV, above it
42bBlue photon 2.76 eV, above 2.3 eV; red photon 1.77 eV, below it
43c1240/450 = 2.76 eV; 2.76 − 2.3 ≈ 0.46 eV
44dN ∝ Pλ: (100 × 650)/(1 × 400) = 162.5
45aOne electron takes one photon, so photon energy, not total energy, decides emission
24 min left
‹
›