Chapter 3 of 11 · 26 min read

Chapter 1: Alpha-Particle Scattering and Rutherford's Model

What you will learn

  • Why the Thomson model of the atom had to be dropped.

  • How the Geiger–Marsden experiment was set up and what it showed.

  • Rutherford's nuclear model and the facts it was built on.

  • How to find the distance of closest approach from energy conservation.

  • What the impact parameter is and how it fixes the scattering angle.

  • Why Rutherford's model could not explain a stable atom or a line spectrum.

1.1 The atom before Rutherford

By 1900 everyone agreed that atoms contain electrons and are neutral overall. So somewhere inside there must be an equal amount of positive charge. The question was how that positive charge is arranged.

J.J. Thomson suggested that the positive charge is spread evenly through the whole atom, like a ball of soft dough. The electrons sit in it like raisins. This is the "plum pudding" model.

If Thomson was right, the positive charge is thinly spread. A fast, heavy positive particle passing through it would feel only a weak push. It should go almost straight, with tiny deflections of a fraction of a degree. Rutherford decided to test this.

1.2 The Geiger–Marsden experiment

In 1911, Rutherford's students Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden fired alpha particles at a very thin gold foil.

An alpha particle is a helium nucleus: 2 protons and 2 neutrons. Its charge is +2e and its mass is about 4 u, roughly 7300 times the electron mass. Alpha particles from the source (bismuth-214) had a kinetic energy of about 5.5 MeV.

Figure 1.1 · Geiger–Marsden scattering set-up (top view)
Figure 1.1 · Geiger–Marsden scattering set-up (top view)

The beam leaves the lead block, is narrowed by the slits and hits the foil; the screen and microscope swing round the foil to count flashes at each angle θ.

The parts of the set-up:

  1. Source in a lead box. The alpha emitter sits in a lead block with a narrow channel. Lead stops all alpha particles except those going along the channel.

  2. Collimator. Lead slits narrow the beam into a fine pencil.

  3. Gold foil. About 2.1 × 10⁻⁷ m thick. Gold can be hammered thinner than almost any metal. A thin foil means each alpha particle is usually deflected by just one nucleus, not many.

  4. Detector. A screen coated with zinc sulphide (ZnS). Each alpha particle that hits it makes a tiny flash of light, a scintillation. A microscope fixed to the screen lets the observer count flashes.

  5. Rotation. The screen and microscope rotate around the foil, so flashes can be counted at every scattering angle θ from 0° to 180°.

The whole thing sits in a vacuum so the alpha particles are not stopped by air.

What they saw

ObservationWhat it means
Most alpha particles went straight through, undeflectedThe atom is mostly empty space
Some were deflected by small anglesThey passed near a concentrated positive charge
About 1 in 8000 was deflected by more than 90°Something very small, heavy and highly charged pushed them back
A few bounced almost straight back (θ near 180°)The positive charge and mass sit in a tiny region; the alpha came nearly head-on

Rutherford said the large-angle scattering was "as if you fired a 15-inch shell at a piece of tissue paper and it came back and hit you." Thomson's thin, spread-out charge could never do that.

1.3 Rutherford's nuclear model

Rutherford concluded:

  • All the positive charge and almost all the mass (more than 99.9%) of the atom sit in a tiny central core, the nucleus.

  • The nucleus is about 10⁻¹⁵ m to 10⁻¹⁴ m across. The atom is about 10⁻¹⁰ m across. So the nucleus is roughly 10,000 to 100,000 times smaller than the atom.

  • Electrons move around the nucleus, like planets around the Sun. The electrostatic attraction gives the centripetal force.

  • The atom is neutral: nuclear charge +Ze is balanced by Z electrons.

A simple picture: if the nucleus were a cricket ball at the centre of the Eden Gardens pitch, the electrons would be scattered over a region bigger than the whole stadium. Everything in between is empty.

The electrons are too light to deflect an alpha particle. An alpha hitting an electron is like a truck hitting a mosquito. So all the scattering comes from the nucleus. The force is Coulomb repulsion between the alpha (+2e) and the nucleus (+Ze).

The scattering formula. Rutherford worked out how many alpha particles N(θ) reach a detector at angle θ. NEET only needs the dependence on angle:

N(θ)∝1sin⁡4(θ/2)N(\theta) \propto \frac{1}{\sin^4(\theta/2)}

The count falls very steeply as θ grows. Going from 10° to 180°, N drops by a factor of about 30,000. This formula matched Geiger and Marsden's counts at every angle, which is what convinced physicists.

1.4 Distance of closest approach

Fire an alpha particle straight at the nucleus (head-on). It slows down because of the repulsion. At some distance r₀ it stops for an instant, then turns back. This r₀ is the distance of closest approach.

Take the nucleus as fixed (it is far heavier than the alpha). Use energy conservation.

  • Far away: kinetic energy K, potential energy 0.

  • At r₀: kinetic energy 0, potential energy k(2e)(Ze)/r₀, where k = 1/(4πε₀).

K=14πε0 (2e)(Ze)r0K = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\,\frac{(2e)(Ze)}{r_0}
r0=14πε0 2Ze2Kr_0 = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\,\frac{2Ze^2}{K}

For any projectile of charge q on a nucleus of charge Ze, r₀ = kqZe/K.

What this tells you:

  • r₀ ∝ 1/K. Double the energy and r₀ halves.

  • r₀ ∝ Z. A heavier target nucleus keeps the alpha further out.

  • r₀ ∝ q. A proton (charge e) gets twice as close as an alpha (charge 2e) of the same energy.

  • Since K = ½mv², r₀ ∝ q/(mv²) at a fixed speed, and r₀ ∝ qm/p² at a fixed momentum.

The alpha cannot get inside r₀, and it never touches the nucleus if the force stays purely Coulomb. So r₀ gives an upper limit on the nuclear radius. The nucleus must be smaller than r₀.

A handy shortcut: e²/(4πε₀) = 1.44 MeV fm. With K in MeV, r₀ in fm is 2Z × 1.44/K.

1.5 Impact parameter and scattering angle

Most alpha particles do not come head-on. The impact parameter b is the perpendicular distance between the alpha's initial line of motion and the centre of the nucleus. Think of it as "how far off-centre the alpha was aimed".

Figure 1.2 · Alpha-particle paths near a nucleus for three impact parameters
Figure 1.2 · Alpha-particle paths near a nucleus for three impact parameters

The impact parameter b is the sideways offset of the incoming line from the nucleus; aimed closer, the alpha is pushed back harder.

  • b = 0: head-on. The alpha bounces straight back, θ = 180°.

  • Small b: strong push, large θ.

  • Large b: weak push, small θ. Very large b means almost no deflection.

The exact relation (Rutherford's result) is:

b=14πε0 Ze2cot⁡(θ/2)Kb = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0}\,\frac{Ze^2\cot(\theta/2)}{K}

Compare with r₀ = k(2Ze²)/K. This gives a neat form:

b=r02cot⁡θ2b = \frac{r_0}{2}\cot\frac{\theta}{2}

Check: θ = 180° gives cot 90° = 0, so b = 0. Good. θ = 90° gives cot 45° = 1, so b = r₀/2.

The path is a hyperbola with the nucleus at one focus. The Coulomb force always points along the line joining alpha and nucleus, so the alpha's angular momentum about the nucleus is conserved. Its kinetic energy far away before and after scattering is also the same (the nucleus is treated as fixed). Linear momentum of the alpha alone is not conserved, because its direction changes.

Since only a tiny fraction of alphas are aimed with small b, only a tiny fraction scatter through large angles. That is exactly what Geiger and Marsden saw.

1.6 Where Rutherford's model fails

Rutherford's model got the nucleus right. But it had two serious problems.

  1. Stability. An electron moving in a circle is accelerating (centripetal acceleration). Classical electromagnetism says an accelerating charge radiates energy. So the electron should lose energy, spiral inward and crash into the nucleus in about 10⁻⁸ s. Real atoms are stable.

  2. Spectrum. As the electron spirals in, its frequency of revolution changes smoothly. So it should emit a continuous spread of frequencies. Real atoms emit sharp lines at particular wavelengths.

Bohr fixed both problems in 1913. That is Chapter 2.

Worked examples

Worked example 1.1: An alpha particle with kinetic energy 5 MeV moves head-on towards a gold nucleus (Z = 79). Find the distance of closest approach. Compare it with the size of the atom.

Solution: r₀ = 2Z × 1.44/K = 2 × 79 × 1.44/5 = 45.5 fm = 4.55 × 10⁻¹⁴ m. An atom is about 10⁻¹⁰ m across. So the alpha turns back at a distance about 2000 times smaller than the atom. The nucleus must be smaller still.

Worked example 1.2: What kinetic energy must an alpha particle have to come within 20 fm of a silver nucleus (Z = 47) in a head-on approach?

Solution: K = 2Z × 1.44/r₀ = 2 × 47 × 1.44/20 = 6.77 MeV.

Worked example 1.3: A proton and an alpha particle have the same kinetic energy. Each moves head-on towards the same nucleus. Find the ratio of their distances of closest approach.

Solution: r₀ = kqZe/K. Z and K are the same, so r₀ ∝ q. The proton has charge e and the alpha 2e. So r_p : r_α = 1 : 2. The proton gets closer.

Worked example 1.4: Repeat Example 1.3 if both particles have the same speed instead.

Solution: K = ½mv², so r₀ ∝ q/m at fixed v. Proton: q/m = e/m. Alpha: 2e/4m = e/2m. So r_p : r_α = 1 : ½ = 2 : 1. Now the alpha gets closer, because at the same speed it carries 4 times the kinetic energy.

Worked example 1.5: A 6 MeV alpha particle is scattered by a gold nucleus (Z = 79). Find the impact parameter for scattering through (a) 90° and (b) 60°.

Solution: First r₀ = 2 × 79 × 1.44/6 = 37.92 fm. (a) b = (r₀/2) cot 45° = 18.96 fm, about 19 fm. (b) b = (r₀/2) cot 30° = 18.96 × 1.732 = 32.8 fm. A larger b gives the smaller angle, as expected.

Worked example 1.6: In a scattering experiment, 112 alpha particles per minute are counted at θ = 60°. How many per minute would be counted at θ = 90°, all else unchanged?

Solution: N ∝ 1/sin⁴(θ/2). N₉₀/N₆₀ = sin⁴ 30°/sin⁴ 45° = (1/16)/(1/4) = 1/4. So N₉₀ = 112/4 = 28 per minute.

Worked example 1.7: A 4 MeV alpha particle moves head-on towards a tin nucleus (Z = 50). (a) Find the distance of closest approach. (b) At what distance from the nucleus is its speed half of its initial speed?

Solution: (a) r₀ = 2 × 50 × 1.44/4 = 36 fm. (b) Half the speed means a quarter of the kinetic energy: K = 1 MeV. So the potential energy at that point is 4 − 1 = 3 MeV. Then r = 2 × 50 × 1.44/3 = 48 fm. Note the alpha loses three quarters of its kinetic energy before it reaches 48 fm, and the last quarter in the next 12 fm.

Quick revision

  • Most alphas pass undeflected: the atom is mostly empty. About 1 in 8000 is turned through more than 90°: there is a tiny, dense, positive nucleus.

  • Nucleus size about 10⁻¹⁵ to 10⁻¹⁴ m; atom about 10⁻¹⁰ m.

  • Closest approach (head-on): r₀ = 2kZe²/K. Shortcut: r₀ (fm) = 2Z × 1.44/K (MeV).

  • r₀ ∝ qZ/K; at the same speed r₀ ∝ q/m.

  • Impact parameter: b = (r₀/2) cot(θ/2). b = 0 gives θ = 180°.

  • N(θ) ∝ 1/sin⁴(θ/2).

  • Angular momentum about the nucleus is conserved during scattering.

  • Rutherford's model cannot explain atomic stability or line spectra.

NEET traps

  • Using charge e for the alpha particle. Its charge is 2e. Forgetting the 2 halves your answer.

  • Writing r₀ ∝ 1/v instead of 1/v². Doubling the speed makes r₀ one quarter, not one half.

  • Calling r₀ the radius of the nucleus. It is only an upper limit on the radius.

  • Thinking a larger impact parameter gives a larger angle. It is the other way round.

  • Saying the alpha's linear momentum is conserved. Only its angular momentum about the nucleus (and its speed far away) are.

  • Blaming electrons for large-angle scattering. Electrons are far too light.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 1

Level 1: Concept check

1. Most alpha particles passed through the gold foil without any deflection. This shows that (a) most of the atom is empty space (b) the positive charge is spread uniformly (c) electrons are heavier than alpha particles (d) the nucleus carries negative charge

2. The fraction of alpha particles deflected by more than 90° in the Geiger–Marsden experiment was (a) about one half (b) about one quarter (c) a very small fraction (d) exactly zero

3. The distance of closest approach r₀ of an alpha particle depends on its kinetic energy K as (a) r₀ ∝ K (b) r₀ ∝ K² (c) r₀ ∝ 1/√K (d) r₀ ∝ 1/K

4. For a head-on collision, the impact parameter is (a) r₀/2 (b) zero (c) equal to r₀ (d) infinite

5. Gold was chosen for the foil mainly because (a) it has a low atomic number (b) it can be hammered into extremely thin sheets (c) it does not interact with alpha particles (d) it is itself an alpha emitter

6. The force that deflects alpha particles in Rutherford scattering is (a) gravitational attraction (b) magnetic force (c) strong nuclear attraction (d) electrostatic repulsion

7. According to classical physics, Rutherford's atom should be unstable because an orbiting electron (a) is accelerated, radiates energy and spirals into the nucleus (b) moves with constant velocity (c) is repelled by the nucleus (d) gains mass as it moves

8. The number of alpha particles scattered at angle θ varies as (a) sin⁴(θ/2) (b) cos⁴(θ/2) (c) 1/sin⁴(θ/2) (d) 1/sin²θ

9. As the impact parameter increases, the scattering angle (a) increases (b) becomes 180° (c) does not change (d) decreases

10. At the point of closest approach in a head-on collision, the alpha particle (a) has maximum kinetic energy (b) is momentarily at rest, with all its kinetic energy stored as potential energy (c) has zero potential energy (d) has zero acceleration

Level 2: NEET standard

11. An alpha particle of kinetic energy 5.76 MeV approaches a gold nucleus (Z = 79) head-on. Take e²/(4πε₀) = 1.44 MeV fm. The distance of closest approach is (a) 19.75 fm (b) 39.5 fm (c) 79 fm (d) 3.95 fm

12. The kinetic energy of an alpha particle is made four times. Its distance of closest approach to a given nucleus becomes (a) 4r₀ (b) r₀/2 (c) r₀/4 (d) 2r₀

13. A proton and an alpha particle with equal kinetic energies approach the same nucleus head-on. The ratio of their distances of closest approach r_p : r_α is (a) 1 : 2 (b) 2 : 1 (c) 1 : 1 (d) 1 : 4

14. A proton and an alpha particle with equal speeds approach the same nucleus head-on. The ratio r_p : r_α is (a) 1 : 2 (b) 1 : 1 (c) 2 : 1 (d) 4 : 1

15. A proton and an alpha particle with equal momenta approach the same nucleus head-on. The ratio r_p : r_α is (a) 1 : 8 (b) 8 : 1 (c) 1 : 2 (d) 1 : 4

16. For a certain alpha particle and target, r₀ = 30 fm. The impact parameter for scattering through 90° is (a) 30 fm (b) zero (c) 60 fm (d) 15 fm

17. For the same alpha particle and target as in Q16, the impact parameter for scattering through 60° is about (a) 8.7 fm (b) 26 fm (c) 15 fm (d) 52 fm

18. In a scattering experiment, 400 alpha particles per minute are counted at 90°. The count per minute expected at 180° is (a) 100 (b) 200 (c) 1600 (d) 50

19. An alpha particle moving head-on towards a nucleus of Z = 50 comes to rest momentarily at 24 fm. Its initial kinetic energy was (e²/4πε₀ = 1.44 MeV fm) (a) 3 MeV (b) 12 MeV (c) 6 MeV (d) 1.5 MeV

20. In a head-on approach, the electrostatic potential energy of the alpha–nucleus system at closest approach equals (a) twice the initial kinetic energy (b) half the initial kinetic energy (c) zero (d) the initial kinetic energy

21. Which of these could Rutherford's model NOT explain? (a) The existence of a small nucleus (b) Large-angle scattering of alpha particles (c) The line spectrum of hydrogen (d) That most of the atom is empty

22. The speed of an alpha particle is doubled. Its distance of closest approach to a given nucleus becomes (a) r₀/2 (b) r₀/4 (c) 2r₀ (d) 4r₀

Level 3: Challenge

23. A 7.2 MeV alpha particle moving head-on comes to rest momentarily at 31.6 fm from a nucleus. Taking e²/(4πε₀) = 1.44 MeV fm, the atomic number of the nucleus is (a) 47 (b) 50 (c) 82 (d) 79

24. A nucleus with Z = 20 has a radius of 4.1 fm. Treating the alpha particle as a point charge, the minimum kinetic energy an alpha particle needs to just touch the nuclear surface in a head-on approach is about (a) 7.0 MeV (b) 14 MeV (c) 28 MeV (d) 3.5 MeV

25. For alpha particles of one energy on one target, the ratio of impact parameters for scattering angles 60° and 90° is (a) √3 : 1 (b) 1 : √3 (c) 3 : 1 (d) 1 : 1

26. A 4 MeV alpha particle moves head-on towards a nucleus of Z = 50. Its kinetic energy when it is 72 fm from the nucleus is (e²/4πε₀ = 1.44 MeV fm) (a) 4 MeV (b) 1 MeV (c) 3 MeV (d) 2 MeV

27. During the scattering of an alpha particle by a heavy nucleus, which quantity of the alpha particle stays constant throughout? (a) Its linear momentum (b) Its angular momentum about the nucleus (c) Its kinetic energy (d) Its velocity

28. Alpha particles of the same energy and the same impact parameter are aimed first at gold (Z = 79) and then at silver (Z = 47). Compared with gold, the scattering angle for silver is (a) larger (b) the same (c) smaller (d) always 180°

29. Assertion (A): In the Geiger–Marsden experiment, a few alpha particles bounce almost straight back from the gold foil. Reason (R): The positive charge and nearly all the mass of an atom are concentrated in a very small nucleus. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true

30. Statement I: The distance of closest approach of an alpha particle gives an upper limit on the size of the target nucleus. Statement II: The distance of closest approach does not depend on the atomic number of the target. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true

Answer key with reasons

QAnsReason
1aNo deflection means no charge or mass met on the way
2cAbout 1 in 8000 turned through more than 90°
3dK = 2kZe²/r₀, so r₀ ∝ 1/K
4bHead-on means aimed at the centre, b = 0
5bA thin foil means mostly single scattering
6dCoulomb repulsion between +2e and +Ze
7aAn accelerated charge radiates classically
8cRutherford's formula N ∝ 1/sin⁴(θ/2)
9dA farther pass feels a weaker push
10bKE becomes zero, all stored as PE
11br₀ = 2 × 79 × 1.44/5.76 = 39.5 fm
12cr₀ ∝ 1/K
13ar₀ ∝ q at equal K
14cr₀ ∝ q/m: 1 versus 1/2
15aK = p²/2m, so r₀ ∝ qm: 1 versus 8
16db = (r₀/2) cot 45° = 15 fm
17bb = 15 cot 30° = 26 fm
18aN ∝ 1/sin⁴(θ/2): ratio (1/4)/1 gives 100
19cK = 2 × 50 × 1.44/24 = 6 MeV
20dEnergy conservation with KE = 0 at r₀
21cIt predicts a continuous spectrum
22br₀ ∝ 1/v²
23dZ = 31.6 × 7.2/2.88 = 79
24bK = 2 × 20 × 1.44/4.1 = 14 MeV
25acot 30° : cot 45° = √3 : 1
26dPE at 72 fm = 2 MeV, so KE = 4 − 2 = 2 MeV
27bCentral force: no torque about the nucleus
28ccot(θ/2) ∝ 1/Z, so smaller Z gives smaller θ
29aA dense nucleus pushes back near head-on alphas
30cr₀ ∝ Z, so II is false

Chapter 1 revision sheet

One-page summary

  • Geiger and Marsden fired alpha particles (charge +2e, mass about 4 u) at a thin gold foil and counted them at different angles.

  • Most passed straight through: the atom is mostly empty space.

  • About 1 in 8000 turned back through more than 90°: positive charge and almost all mass sit in a tiny nucleus.

  • Thomson's "plum pudding" model cannot give large-angle scattering, so it was rejected.

  • Nucleus size is about 10⁻¹⁵ to 10⁻¹⁴ m; atom size is about 10⁻¹⁰ m.

  • Distance of closest approach (head-on): all kinetic energy becomes electric potential energy.

  • r₀ = 2kZe²/K. Shortcut: r₀ (fm) = 2 × 1.44 × Z / K (MeV).

  • r₀ is an upper limit on the nuclear radius.

  • For any charge q: r₀ ∝ qZ/K; at the same speed, r₀ ∝ q/m.

  • Impact parameter b is the perpendicular distance of the initial line of motion from the nucleus.

  • b = (r₀/2) cot(θ/2). Small b gives large θ; b = 0 gives θ = 180°.

  • Number scattered: N(θ) ∝ 1/sin⁴(θ/2); also N ∝ Z² and N ∝ 1/K².

  • Angular momentum about the nucleus is conserved; kinetic energy is not constant during the path.

  • Rutherford's model fails to explain why atoms are stable and why spectra are lines.

Must-remember table

QuantityFormula or valueNote
Closest approachr₀ = 2kZe²/KAlpha, head-on
ke²1.44 MeV fmUse with K in MeV
Impact parameterb = (r₀/2) cot(θ/2)b = 0 at θ = 180°
Scattering countN ∝ 1/sin⁴(θ/2)Falls fast with θ
Fraction back-scatteredAbout 1 in 8000Gold foil
Nuclear size10⁻¹⁵ to 10⁻¹⁴ mAtom: 10⁻¹⁰ m
ConservedAngular momentum, total energyNot speed

Memory aids

  • "MESS" for the observations: Most go straight, Empty atom, Some deflect, Small dense nucleus.

  • "Two-Z over K": r₀ = 2Z(1.44)/K. The "2" is the alpha's charge, Z is the target's charge.

  • "Small b, big bend": impact parameter and scattering angle move in opposite directions.

  • "Sine to the four": the count falls as the fourth power of sin(θ/2), so doubling the angle cuts the count sharply.

Concept connections

  • The r₀ formula is energy conservation with Coulomb potential energy from Physics Book 11: Electrostatics.

  • Conservation of angular momentum about the nucleus uses ideas from Physics Book 5: Rotational Motion.

  • Rutherford's size estimate is refined by R = R₀A^(1/3) in Chapter 4 of this book.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 1, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)

31. Match List I with List II for alpha-particle scattering.

List I:

  • A. Distance of closest approach

  • B. Impact parameter

  • C. Number scattered at angle θ

  • D. Quantity conserved about the nucleus

List II:

  • i. (r₀/2) cot(θ/2)

  • ii. 2kZe²/K

  • iii. Proportional to 1/sin⁴(θ/2)

  • iv. Angular momentum

(a) A-i, B-ii, C-iii, D-iv (b) A-ii, B-i, C-iii, D-iv (c) A-ii, B-iii, C-i, D-iv (d) A-iv, B-i, C-iii, D-ii

32. Match each observation (List I) with what it tells us (List II).

List I:

  • A. Most alpha particles pass undeflected

  • B. A few turn back through more than 90°

  • C. Atomic electrons hardly change the alpha's path

  • D. The scattered count rises as Z² of the foil

List II:

  • i. The atom is mostly empty

  • ii. Electrons are far too light to deflect an alpha

  • iii. Positive charge and mass sit in a tiny core

  • iv. The nucleus carries a charge proportional to atomic number

(a) A-iii, B-i, C-ii, D-iv (b) A-i, B-ii, C-iii, D-iv (c) A-i, B-iii, C-iv, D-ii (d) A-i, B-iii, C-ii, D-iv

33. In a head-on collision, one change is made at a time (List I). Match each with its effect on r₀ (List II).

List I:

  • A. Kinetic energy doubled

  • B. Target atomic number doubled

  • C. Alpha replaced by a deuteron moving at the same speed

  • D. Speed of the alpha halved

List II:

  • i. Halved

  • ii. Doubled

  • iii. Unchanged

  • iv. Four times

(a) A-ii, B-i, C-iii, D-iv (b) A-i, B-ii, C-iv, D-iii (c) A-i, B-ii, C-iii, D-iv (d) A-iii, B-ii, C-i, D-iv

34. For a fixed alpha energy and target, match the scattering angle (List I) with the impact parameter (List II), in terms of r₀.

List I:

  • A. 180°

  • B. 90°

  • C. 60°

  • D. 120°

List II:

  • i. 0.87 r₀

  • ii. 0

  • iii. 0.29 r₀

  • iv. 0.5 r₀

(a) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii (b) A-ii, B-i, C-iv, D-iii (c) A-iv, B-ii, C-iii, D-i (d) A-ii, B-iv, C-iii, D-i

35. How many of the following statements are correct?

  • A. The kinetic energy of an alpha particle stays constant throughout its scattering path.

  • B. The angular momentum of the alpha about the nucleus is conserved.

  • C. In a head-on collision, the alpha is momentarily at rest at the distance of closest approach.

  • D. Thomson's model predicts frequent large-angle scattering.

(a) 1 (b) 3 (c) 2 (d) 4

36. Choose the correct set of statements.

  • A. For a 5 MeV alpha on gold (Z = 79), r₀ is about 45 fm.

  • B. r₀ is a lower limit on the size of the nucleus.

  • C. A head-on collision has impact parameter zero.

  • D. For the same scattering angle, doubling the alpha's kinetic energy halves the impact parameter.

(a) A, C and D only (b) A and B only (c) B, C and D only (d) A, B, C and D

37. Which statements about Rutherford's nuclear model are correct?

  • A. It explains the line spectrum of hydrogen.

  • B. By classical physics, it predicts that the orbiting electron should radiate and spiral into the nucleus.

  • C. It places almost all the mass of the atom in the nucleus.

  • D. It says electrons move only in fixed, quantised orbits.

(a) A and B only (b) C and D only (c) A, B and C only (d) B and C only

38. How many of these statements about the scattered count N(θ) are correct?

  • A. N(60°)/N(90°) = 4.

  • B. N decreases as θ increases from small angles to 180°.

  • C. N is proportional to Z² of the foil nuclei.

  • D. N is proportional to 1/K² of the alphas.

  • E. N does not depend on foil thickness.

(a) 3 (b) 4 (c) 5 (d) 2

39. A detector records these counts per minute, and the data follow the Rutherford formula.

Angle θCount per minute
60°1600
90°400
180°?

The expected count at 180° is:

(a) 400 (b) 200 (c) 50 (d) 100

40. For alphas fired head-on at one foil, a graph of r₀ (fm) against 1/K (MeV⁻¹) is a straight line through the origin with slope 227.5 MeV fm. The foil is most likely made of the element with Z =

(a) 47 (b) 79 (c) 92 (d) 29

41. For 5.76 MeV alphas on a foil, a graph of impact parameter b against cot(θ/2) is a straight line through the origin with slope 20 fm. The atomic number of the foil nuclei is:

(a) 80 (b) 40 (c) 160 (d) 20

Passage for Q42–43. A college lab fires a beam of 7.2 MeV alpha particles at a thin silver foil (Z = 47, A = 108). A student wants to know how close the alphas get, and whether they can touch the nucleus. Take ke² = 1.44 MeV fm and R₀ = 1.2 fm, and ignore the alpha's own size.

42. The distance of closest approach for a head-on alpha is about:

(a) 9.4 fm (b) 37.6 fm (c) 18.8 fm (d) 4.7 fm

43. The minimum kinetic energy an alpha needs to just reach the surface of the silver nucleus is about:

(a) 11.8 MeV (b) 47.4 MeV (c) 7.2 MeV (d) 23.7 MeV

44. An 8 MeV alpha moves head-on towards a heavy nucleus whose distance of closest approach is r₀. When the alpha is at a distance 2r₀ from the nucleus, its kinetic energy is:

(a) 2 MeV (b) 4 MeV (c) 6 MeV (d) 8 MeV

45. A proton and an alpha particle are each accelerated from rest through the same potential difference and then fired head-on at the same nucleus. The ratio r₀(proton) : r₀(alpha) is:

(a) 1 : 1 (b) 1 : 2 (c) 2 : 1 (d) 1 : 4

Level 4 answer key

QAnsReason
31br₀ = 2kZe²/K; b = (r₀/2)cot(θ/2); N ∝ 1/sin⁴(θ/2); angular momentum is conserved under a central force
32dEmpty atom; tiny massive core; light electrons; N ∝ Z² points to nuclear charge Ze
33cr₀ ∝ qZ/K; deuteron and alpha have the same q/m; half speed means K/4, so r₀ × 4
34acot 90° = 0; cot 45° = 1 gives 0.5 r₀; cot 30° = 1.73 gives 0.87 r₀; cot 60° = 0.577 gives 0.29 r₀
35cB and C are true; K falls near the nucleus, and Thomson's model gives only tiny deflections
36a2 × 79 × 1.44/5 = 45.5 fm; r₀ is an upper limit; b ∝ 1/K
37dRutherford's model has no quantised orbits and cannot explain line spectra
38bA: sin⁴4 45°/sin⁴4 30° = 0.25/0.0625 = 4. A to D true; N grows with foil thickness
39dN(180°)/N(90°) = sin⁴4 45°/sin⁴4 90° = 0.25, so 400 × 0.25 = 100
40bSlope = 2Z × 1.44, so Z = 227.5/2.88 = 79 (gold)
41aSlope = r₀/2, so r₀ = 40 fm; Z = 40 × 5.76/2.88 = 80
42cr₀ = 2 × 47 × 1.44/7.2 = 18.8 fm
43dR = 1.2 × 108^(1/3) = 5.71 fm; K = 2 × 47 × 1.44/5.71 = 23.7 MeV
44bU at 2r₀ is half of U at r₀, i.e. 4 MeV; K = 8 − 4 = 4 MeV
45aK = qV, so r₀ ∝ q/K = 1/V for both; the ratio is 1 : 1
26 min left
‹
›