Chapter 7 of 11 · 22 min read

Chapter 5: Relative Velocity

What you will learn

  • How to find the velocity of one body as seen from another

  • Crossing and overtaking problems in one dimension

  • Relative velocity in two dimensions using vector subtraction

  • Rain-and-umbrella problems

  • River-crossing problems: least time and shortest path

5.1 The basic idea

You sit in a train moving at 20 m/s. A second train overtakes at 25 m/s on the next track. To you, it seems to crawl past at only 5 m/s. That 5 m/s is its velocity relative to you.

The velocity of A relative to B is A's velocity as measured by an observer moving with B:

v⃗AB=v⃗A−v⃗B\vec{v}_{AB} = \vec{v}_A - \vec{v}_B

It follows that v_BA = −v_AB. If A sees B moving east at 5 m/s, B sees A moving west at 5 m/s.

The same idea works for acceleration: a_AB = a_A − a_B.

5.2 Relative velocity in one dimension

Take one direction as positive.

  • Same direction: v_rel = v_A − v_B (the speeds subtract).

  • Opposite directions: v_rel = v_A + v_B (the speeds add).

Crossing and overtaking trains. For two trains of lengths L₁ and L₂ to pass each other completely, the relative distance to cover is L₁ + L₂:

t=L1+L2vrelt = \frac{L_1 + L_2}{v_{\text{rel}}}

Worked example 5.1: Trains of length 100 m and 150 m move at 20 m/s and 30 m/s on parallel tracks. How long do they take to cross each other if they move (a) in opposite directions, (b) in the same direction?

Solution: Total length = 250 m. (a) v_rel = 50 m/s → t = 5 s. (b) v_rel = 10 m/s → t = 25 s.

Worked example 5.2: Chase. A thief's car is 100 m ahead, moving at 20 m/s. A police car follows at 30 m/s. When does the police car catch up?

Solution: Relative speed = 10 m/s, gap = 100 m → t = 10 s.

Bodies under gravity. Two bodies moving freely under gravity have the same acceleration g, so their relative acceleration is zero. Their relative velocity stays constant, and the gap between them changes at a steady rate.

Worked example 5.3: Two balls are thrown straight up at the same instant from the same point, at 10 m/s and 20 m/s. Find their separation after 1 s.

Solution: Relative velocity = 10 m/s, relative acceleration = 0. Separation = 10 × 1 = 10 m. (Check: heights are 10 − 5 = 5 m and 20 − 5 = 15 m.)

Worked example 5.4: Inside a lift. A lift moves up at constant speed. A person inside throws a ball up at 20 m/s relative to the lift. How high above the release point does the ball rise, as seen by the person?

Solution: Relative to the lift, u = 20 m/s and a = g (the lift is not accelerating). Height = 400/20 = 20 m, the same as on the ground. A lift moving at constant velocity is just another inertial frame.

5.3 Relative velocity in two dimensions

For velocities in different directions, subtract them as vectors. Reverse v_B and add it to v_A:

∣v⃗AB∣=vA2+vB2−2vAvBcos⁡θ|\vec{v}_{AB}| = \sqrt{v_A^2 + v_B^2 - 2v_Av_B\cos\theta}

where θ is the angle between v_A and v_B.

Worked example 5.5: Car A moves east at 60 km/h and car B moves north at 80 km/h. Find the velocity of A relative to B.

Solution: v_AB = 60 (east) − 80 (north) = 60 east + 80 south. Magnitude = √(60² + 80²) = 100 km/h, at tan⁻¹(80/60) = 53° south of east.

5.4 Rain and umbrella

Rain falls vertically at speed v_r. A man walks horizontally at v_m. The rain's velocity relative to the man is:

v⃗rm=v⃗r−v⃗m\vec{v}_{rm} = \vec{v}_r - \vec{v}_m

This has a downward part v_r and a backward part v_m, so the rain seems to come towards his face at an angle θ from the vertical:

tan⁡θ=vmvr\tan\theta = \frac{v_m}{v_r}

He should tilt his umbrella forward by θ.

Worked example 5.6: Rain falls vertically at 30 m/s. A cyclist rides east at 10 m/s. How should she hold her umbrella?

Solution: tan θ = 10/30 = 1/3. Tilt forward (towards east) at θ = tan⁻¹(1/3) ≈ 18° from the vertical.

Worked example 5.7: Two-condition rain problem. When a man walks east at 3 km/h, rain seems to fall vertically. When he walks east at 6 km/h, it seems to fall at 45° to the vertical. Find the actual velocity of the rain.

Solution: Let the rain's velocity be a (east) and b (down).

  • At 3 km/h: relative horizontal part = a − 3 = 0 → a = 3 km/h.

  • At 6 km/h: relative horizontal part = 3 − 6 = −3 (westward). At 45°, horizontal = vertical, so b = 3 km/h.

Actual rain speed = √(3² + 3²) = 3√2 km/h, falling at 45° to the vertical, towards the east.

5.5 Crossing a river

Let the river be of width d, flowing at u. A boat (or swimmer) moves at v relative to the water.

The boat's velocity relative to the ground is the vector sum of its velocity in water and the water's velocity.

Figure 5.1 · River crossing: least time versus zero drift
Figure 5.1 · River crossing: least time versus zero drift

On the left the river carries the boat downstream; on the right part of the boat's velocity is spent cancelling the flow, so the crossing is slower.

Case 1: Crossing in the least time. Point the boat straight across (perpendicular to the flow). The whole of v is used for crossing:

tmin⁡=dv,drift=u tmin⁡=udvt_{\min} = \frac{d}{v}, \qquad \text{drift} = u\,t_{\min} = \frac{ud}{v}

The river carries the boat downstream while it crosses. The least time does not depend on u.

Case 2: Crossing straight across (shortest path, zero drift). Point the boat upstream at angle θ to the perpendicular so that the upstream part cancels the flow:

vsin⁡θ=u  ⇒  sin⁡θ=uv,t=dv2−u2v\sin\theta = u \;\Rightarrow\; \sin\theta = \frac{u}{v}, \qquad t = \frac{d}{\sqrt{v^2 - u^2}}

This is possible only if v > u. If the river is faster than the boat, it cannot go straight across.

Case 3: Along the river. Downstream speed = v + u. Upstream speed = v − u.

Worked example 5.8: A river 400 m wide flows at 3 m/s. A boat moves at 5 m/s in still water. Find (a) the least crossing time and the drift, (b) the heading and time for crossing straight across.

Solution:

(a) t = 400/5 = 80 s. Drift = 3 × 80 = 240 m downstream.

(b) sin θ = 3/5 → θ = 37° upstream from the perpendicular. Speed across = √(25 − 9) = 4 m/s. Time = 400/4 = 100 s.

Notice that the straight-across trip takes longer than the least-time trip.

Worked example 5.9: A boat goes 10 km downstream in 1 h and returns in 2 h. Find the boat's speed in still water and the river's speed.

Solution: v + u = 10 and v − u = 5. So v = 7.5 km/h and u = 2.5 km/h.

Aircraft in wind works the same way: the wind plays the role of the river.

Quick revision

  • v_AB = v_A − v_B; v_BA = −v_AB.

  • Same direction: subtract speeds. Opposite: add.

  • Two freely falling bodies: relative acceleration zero, relative velocity constant.

  • Rain: tilt the umbrella forward at tan θ = v_man / v_rain.

  • River: least time t = d/v (head across); zero drift needs sin θ = u/v, t = d/√(v² − u²).

NEET traps

  • Adding velocities when the bodies move in the same direction.

  • Forgetting the train lengths in crossing problems.

  • Tilting the umbrella backward. It goes forward, into the direction of walking.

  • Using t = d/v for the straight-across path. That time is for the least-time path.

  • Applying the zero-drift formula when the river is faster than the boat.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 5

Level 1: Concept check

1. The velocity of A relative to B is: (a) v_A + v_B (b) v_A − v_B (c) v_B − v_A (d) v_A × v_B

2. Two cars move the same way at 60 km/h and 40 km/h. Their relative speed is: (a) 100 km/h (b) 20 km/h (c) 50 km/h (d) 2400 km/h

3. If they move in opposite directions, the relative speed is: (a) 100 km/h (b) 20 km/h (c) 50 km/h (d) zero

4. v_BA equals: (a) v_AB (b) −v_AB (c) zero (d) 2v_AB

5. The relative acceleration of two freely falling bodies is: (a) g (b) 2g (c) zero (d) g/2

6. To cross a river in the least time, a boat should head: (a) upstream at an angle (b) downstream at an angle (c) perpendicular to the flow (d) along the flow

7. To cross along the shortest path, a boat should head: (a) perpendicular to the flow (b) upstream at an angle (c) downstream (d) along the flow

8. A man walking in vertical rain should tilt his umbrella: (a) backward (b) forward (c) sideways (d) not at all

9. A boat's speed downstream is: (a) v − u (b) v + u (c) √(v² + u²) (d) √(v² − u²)

10. From a moving train, roadside trees seem to move backward because: (a) trees move (b) motion is relative (c) of light refraction (d) of the Earth's rotation

Level 2: NEET standard

11. Trains 100 m and 150 m long move in opposite directions at 20 and 30 m/s. They cross each other in: (a) 5 s (b) 10 s (c) 25 s (d) 50 s

12. If they move in the same direction, the time is: (a) 5 s (b) 10 s (c) 25 s (d) 50 s

13. A moves east at 60 km/h, B north at 80 km/h. The speed of A relative to B is: (a) 20 km/h (b) 70 km/h (c) 100 km/h (d) 140 km/h

14. Rain falls vertically at 30 m/s, and a cyclist rides at 10 m/s. The umbrella should make an angle with the vertical of: (a) tan⁻¹(3) (b) tan⁻¹(1/3) (c) 45° (d) 30°

15. A river 400 m wide flows at 3 m/s; a boat moves at 5 m/s in still water. The least crossing time is: (a) 50 s (b) 80 s (c) 100 s (d) 133 s

16. For Q15, the drift in the least-time crossing is: (a) 120 m (b) 240 m (c) 300 m (d) 400 m

17. For Q15, the time to cross straight across is: (a) 80 s (b) 100 s (c) 120 s (d) 133 s

18. For Q17, the boat must head upstream at an angle to the perpendicular of: (a) 30° (b) 37° (c) 53° (d) 60°

19. A boat goes 10 km downstream in 1 h and returns in 2 h. Its speed in still water is: (a) 5 km/h (b) 7.5 km/h (c) 10 km/h (d) 2.5 km/h

20. For Q19, the speed of the river is: (a) 2.5 km/h (b) 5 km/h (c) 7.5 km/h (d) 1 km/h

21. Two balls are thrown up together at 10 m/s and 20 m/s. After 1 s their separation is: (a) 5 m (b) 10 m (c) 15 m (d) 20 m

22. A police car at 30 m/s chases a car 100 m ahead moving at 20 m/s. It catches up in: (a) 2 s (b) 5 s (c) 10 s (d) 20 s

Level 3: Challenge

23. Rain appears vertical when a man walks east at 3 km/h, and at 45° when he walks east at 6 km/h. The actual speed of the rain is: (a) 3 km/h (b) 3√2 km/h (c) 6 km/h (d) 6√2 km/h

24. A boat's speed in still water is less than the river's speed. Then the boat: (a) can cross along the shortest path (b) cannot cross straight across (c) cannot cross at all (d) crosses in zero time

25. A moves north at 20 m/s, B moves east at 20 m/s. The velocity of A relative to B is: (a) 20√2 m/s north-east (b) 20√2 m/s north-west (c) 40 m/s north (d) zero

26. A river flows at 2 km/h. A boat with speed 6 km/h in still water goes 8 km upstream and returns. The total time is: (a) 2 h (b) 2.67 h (c) 3 h (d) 4 h

27. A swimmer's speed in still water is 5 km/h. A river 1 km wide flows at 3 km/h. The least crossing time is: (a) 10 min (b) 12 min (c) 15 min (d) 20 min

28. A person in a lift moving up at constant speed throws a ball up at 20 m/s relative to the lift. Its maximum height above the release point, as seen by the person, is: (a) 10 m (b) 20 m (c) 25 m (d) 40 m

29. Assertion (A): Two balls dropped from the same height 1 s apart move farther apart as they fall. Reason (R): Once both are falling, their relative velocity is constant and non-zero. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true

30. Statement I: To cross a river in the least time, a boat should head perpendicular to the flow. Statement II: The least crossing time does not depend on the speed of the river. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true

Answer key with reasons

QAnsReason
1bDefinition.
2bSubtract.
3aAdd.
4bReverse the observer.
5cBoth have g.
6cAll of v used across.
7bCancels the drift.
8bRain seems to come from the front.
9bSpeeds add.
10bRelative to the train.
11a250/50.
12c250/10.
13c√(3600 + 6400).
14btan θ = 10/30.
15b400/5.
16b3 × 80.
17b400/4.
18bsin θ = 3/5.
19b(10 + 5)/2.
20a(10 − 5)/2.
21b10 m/s × 1 s.
22c100/10.
23bWorked example 5.7.
24bNeeds v > u.
25b20 N + 20 W.
26c8/4 + 8/8 = 3 h.
27b1/5 h = 12 min.
28bLift is an inertial frame: 400/20.
29aConstant relative velocity means a growing gap.
30at = d/v.

Chapter 5 revision sheet

One-page summary

  • Velocity of A relative to B: v_AB = v_A − v_B; and v_BA = −v_AB.

  • Same direction on a line: relative speed = difference of speeds; opposite directions: sum of speeds.

  • Two trains crossing: time = (sum of lengths)/(relative speed).

  • In two dimensions, reverse v_B and add it to v_A: magnitude √(v_A² + v_B² − 2v_Av_B cos θ).

  • Relative acceleration a_AB = a_A − a_B; two freely falling bodies have zero relative acceleration.

  • So the relative velocity of two bodies in free fall stays constant, and each sees the other move in a straight line.

  • Rain: v_rain relative to man = v_rain − v_man; hold the umbrella against the apparent rain direction, tilted forward by tan θ = v_man/v_rain for vertical rain.

  • River of width d, river speed u, boat speed v in still water.

  • Least time: head straight across; t = d/v; drift = ud/v.

  • Zero drift: head upstream at sin θ = u/v from the straight-across line; t = d/√(v² − u²); possible only if v > u.

  • Downstream speed = v + u; upstream speed = v − u.

  • Aircraft in wind works exactly like a boat in a river.

  • Closest approach: work in the frame of one body; the other moves in a straight line with the relative velocity.

Must-remember table

SituationKey resultCondition
Same direction on a linev_A − v_BSigns taken along one axis
Opposite directionsv_A + v_B (magnitude)—
Least-time river crossingt = d/v, drift = ud/vBoat heads straight across
Shortest-path crossingsin θ = u/v, t = d/√(v² − u²)v > u
Downstream / upstreamv + u / v − uAlong the flow
Umbrella for vertical raintan θ = v_man/v_rain, tilt forwardMan moves horizontally

Memory aids

  • "Me minus You": v_AB = v_A − v_B, the velocity of me as seen by you.

  • "Straight across, Shortest time; Slant upstream, Shortest path" (SS-SS): heading Straight gives Shortest time; heading Slanted gives Shortest path.

  • "Umbrella leans into the walk": you tilt the umbrella forward, in the direction you walk.

  • "Falling together, flying straight": two bodies in free fall see each other move in a straight line at constant velocity.

Concept connections

  • Vector subtraction from Chapter 4 is the whole method; the same idea returns as relative motion in collisions in Physics Book 4: Work, Energy and Power.

  • Frames of reference and pseudo forces are developed in Physics Book 3: Laws of Motion.

  • Relative velocity of a source and observer underlies the Doppler effect in Physics Book 10: Oscillations and Waves.

Practice MCQs: Chapter 5, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)

31. Car A moves at 60 km/h and car B at 40 km/h. Match the situation with the relative velocity.

List I:

  • A. Same direction on a straight road: v_AB

  • B. Opposite directions on a straight road: magnitude of v_AB

  • C. A north, B east: magnitude of v_AB

  • D. Same direction on a straight road: v_BA

List II:

  • (i) 100 km/h

  • (ii) 20√13 km/h

  • (iii) 20 km/h in the direction of motion

  • (iv) 20 km/h opposite to the direction of motion

(a) A-i, B-iii, C-ii, D-iv (b) A-iii, B-ii, C-i, D-iv (c) A-iii, B-i, C-ii, D-iv (d) A-iv, B-i, C-ii, D-iii

32. A river 120 m wide flows at 3 m/s. A boat moves at 5 m/s in still water. Match.

List I:

  • A. Least time to cross

  • B. Drift when crossing in least time

  • C. Time to cross with zero drift

  • D. Speed relative to the bank in least-time crossing

List II:

  • (i) 30 s

  • (ii) √34 m/s

  • (iii) 72 m

  • (iv) 24 s

(a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-i, B-iii, C-iv, D-ii (c) A-iv, B-ii, C-i, D-iii (d) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii

33. Rain falls vertically at 12 m/s. Match the man's horizontal walking speed with what he observes or does.

List I:

  • A. 5 m/s

  • B. 12 m/s

  • C. 4√3 m/s

  • D. 0 (standing still)

List II:

  • (i) Umbrella tilted 30° forward from vertical

  • (ii) Umbrella held vertical

  • (iii) Rain appears to fall at 13 m/s

  • (iv) Umbrella tilted 45° forward from vertical

(a) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-i, C-iv, D-ii (c) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (d) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii

34. A boat moves at 8 km/h in still water. A river flows at 2 km/h. The boat makes a 30 km trip along the river each way. Match.

List I:

  • A. Speed downstream

  • B. Speed upstream

  • C. Time for 30 km downstream

  • D. Time for 30 km upstream

List II:

  • (i) 5 h

  • (ii) 10 km/h

  • (iii) 3 h

  • (iv) 6 km/h

(a) A-iv, B-ii, C-iii, D-i (b) A-ii, B-iv, C-iii, D-i (c) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii (d) A-ii, B-iii, C-iv, D-i

35. How many of the following statements are correct (air resistance ignored)?

  • A. v_AB = −v_BA.

  • B. The relative velocity of two bodies in free fall stays constant.

  • C. The relative acceleration of two freely falling bodies is zero.

  • D. A boat can cross a river with zero drift only if its speed in still water is greater than the river speed.

  • E. A least-time river crossing has zero drift.

(a) 4 (b) 3 (c) 5 (d) 2

36. Trains of length 120 m and 80 m run on parallel tracks at 54 km/h and 36 km/h. Choose the correct set.

  • A. Moving in opposite directions, they cross each other in 8 s.

  • B. Moving in the same direction, the faster one overtakes the other completely in 40 s.

  • C. Moving in the same direction, a passenger in the faster train sees the slower train move backward at 5 m/s.

  • D. Moving in opposite directions, their relative speed is 5 m/s.

(a) A, B and C only (b) A and B only (c) C and D only (d) A, B, C and D

37. A lift moves up at a steady 5 m/s. A boy inside throws a ball straight up at 10 m/s relative to the lift (g = 10 m/s²). How many statements are correct?

  • A. Relative to the ground, the ball starts upward at 15 m/s.

  • B. The ball returns to his hand after 2 s.

  • C. The ball rises 5 m relative to the lift.

  • D. Relative to the ground, the ball rises 5 m above the point of release.

  • E. If the lift were accelerating upward at 2 m/s², the ball would take longer than 2 s to return.

(a) 2 (b) 4 (c) 5 (d) 3

38. Car A moves north at 30 m/s and car B moves east at 40 m/s. Choose the correct set.

  • A. The magnitude of v_AB is 50 m/s.

  • B. v_BA points tan⁻¹(3/4) south of east.

  • C. If they leave the same crossing together, they are 100 m apart after 2 s.

  • D. The magnitude of the relative velocity depends on which car is taken as the reference.

(a) A and C only (b) B and D only (c) A, B and C only (d) A, B, C and D

39. Two cars move on the same straight road. On an x–t graph, car P's line passes through (0, 0) and (5 s, 100 m). Car Q's line passes through (0, 300 m) and (5 s, 200 m). They meet at: (a) 15 s (b) 7.5 s (c) 5 s (d) 10 s

40. The velocities in a river crossing are:

VelocityMagnitudeDirection
Boat relative to water4 m/sNorth
Water relative to ground3 m/sEast

The boat's velocity relative to the ground is 5 m/s directed: (a) about 37° east of north (b) about 53° east of north (c) about 37° north of east (d) exactly north-east

41. A cyclist rides east on a rainy day and notes how the rain appears:

Cyclist's speed (east)How the rain appears to fall
6 m/sVertically
14 m/sAt 45° to the vertical, coming from the front

The actual speed of the rain is: (a) 8 m/s (b) 6 m/s (c) 14 m/s (d) 10 m/s

Case for Q42–Q43: A ferry crosses a river 1 km wide that flows at 4 km/h. The ferry's speed in still water is 5 km/h.

42. If the ferry must land at the point directly opposite, the crossing takes: (a) 12 min (b) 15 min (c) 20 min (d) 25 min

43. If instead it heads straight across, it lands downstream of the opposite point by: (a) 0.8 km (b) 1.0 km (c) 0.6 km (d) 1.2 km

44. Ship A moves east at 10 km/h. At noon, ship B is 20 km due north of A and moves south at 10 km/h. The closest distance between them is: (a) 20 km (b) 10√2 km (c) 10 km (d) zero

45. Two stones are thrown at the same instant from the same point with different velocities in different directions. Ignoring air resistance, the path of one as seen from the other is: (a) a parabola (b) a circle (c) a straight line (d) an ellipse

Level 4 answer key

QAnsReason
31c60 − 40 = 20 forward; 60 + 40 = 100; √(3600 + 1600) = 20√13; v_BA = −20
32a120/5 = 24 s; 3 × 24 = 72 m; 120/√(25 − 9) = 30 s; √(25 + 9)
33d√(144 + 25) = 13; tan θ = 1 gives 45°; tan θ = 1/√3 gives 30°; at rest, vertical
34b8 + 2 = 10; 8 − 2 = 6; 30/10 = 3 h; 30/6 = 5 h
35aA, B, C, D true; least-time crossing drifts by ud/v
36a200/25 = 8 s; 200/5 = 40 s; 15 − 10 = 5 m/s backward; opposite gives 25 m/s
37dA, B, C true; ground-frame rise = 15²/20 = 11.25 m; upward a makes effective g = 12, so time is shorter
38c√(900 + 1600) = 50; v_BA = 40î − 30ĵ; 50 × 2 = 100 m; magnitude is the same either way
39bv_P = 20, v_Q = −20 m/s; 20t = 300 − 20t
40atan⁻¹(3/4) ≈ 37° from north towards east
41dHorizontal part 6 m/s; at 14 m/s relative horizontal is 8, so vertical part is 8; √(36 + 64) = 10
42cSpeed across = √(25 − 16) = 3 km/h; 1/3 h
43at = 1/5 h; drift = 4 × 0.2 = 0.8 km
44bIn A's frame B moves at 10√2 km/h at 45° to the line joining them; closest distance = 20 sin 45°
45cRelative acceleration is zero, so relative velocity is constant
22 min left
‹
›