Chapter 7: Reactions Involving α-Hydrogen and Distinguishing Tests
What you will learn
Why aldehydes are easily oxidised and how Tollens' and Fehling's tests use this.
Why hydrogens on the α-carbon are acidic.
Aldol and cross aldol condensation, step by step.
The Cannizzaro reaction of aldehydes with no α-hydrogen.
The haloform (iodoform) reaction and which compounds give it.
How to identify an unknown carbonyl compound with a sequence of tests.
7.1 Oxidation of aldehydes and ketones
An aldehyde has an H on its carbonyl carbon. Even mild oxidising agents remove it and give a carboxylic acid with the same number of carbons.
Ketones have no such H. Mild oxidants do not affect them. Strong oxidants (hot KMnO₄, K₂Cr₂O₇/H₂SO₄, conc. HNO₃) oxidise ketones only under vigorous conditions. Then a C–C bond next to C=O breaks, and a mixture of carboxylic acids with fewer carbons forms.
This difference is the basis of the tests that tell aldehydes from ketones.
7.2 Tollens' test
Tollens' reagent is freshly made ammoniacal silver nitrate. It contains the complex ion [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺. Warm the carbonyl compound with it. An aldehyde reduces Ag⁺ to metallic silver, which coats the clean glass as a bright mirror.
Both aliphatic and aromatic aldehydes give the silver mirror. Ketones do not. Methanoic acid, HCOOH, also gives it, because it has an aldehyde-like H.
7.3 Fehling's test
Fehling's solution is made by mixing equal volumes of two solutions just before use:
Fehling A: aqueous copper(II) sulphate.
Fehling B: alkaline sodium potassium tartrate (Rochelle salt). The tartrate holds Cu²⁺ in solution as a deep blue complex.
On warming with an aliphatic aldehyde, the blue Cu²⁺ is reduced to a reddish-brown precipitate of copper(I) oxide.
Aromatic aldehydes such as benzaldehyde do not respond to Fehling's test. Ketones do not respond either. Benedict's solution, which uses citrate in place of tartrate, behaves the same way.
| Reagent | Active species | Aliphatic aldehyde | Aromatic aldehyde | Ketone |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tollens' | [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺ | silver mirror | silver mirror | no change |
| Fehling's | Cu²⁺–tartrate complex | red-brown Cu₂O | no change | no change |
7.4 Acidity of α-hydrogen
The carbon next to the carbonyl carbon is the α-carbon. Its hydrogens are α-hydrogens. They are far more acidic than ordinary C–H hydrogens. The pKa of propanone is about 19, against about 50 for ethane.
Two effects explain this:
The C=O group pulls electrons from the α-carbon (–I effect), which weakens the C–H bond.
When a base removes an α-H, the carbanion formed is an enolate ion. Its negative charge is shared by resonance between the α-carbon and the more electronegative oxygen. This makes the enolate fairly stable.
The enolate is a carbon nucleophile. It drives aldol condensation and the haloform reaction. A carbonyl compound with α-hydrogens also exists in small amounts as its enol form (keto–enol tautomerism).
7.5 Aldol condensation
Aldehydes and ketones that have at least one α-hydrogen react with dilute alkali. Two molecules join to form a β-hydroxy aldehyde (an aldol) or a β-hydroxy ketone (a ketol). On heating, these lose water to give an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compound.
The product names: 3-hydroxybutanal (aldol), then but-2-enal (crotonaldehyde).
For propanone, Ba(OH)₂ is often used:
The ketol is 4-hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one. The unsaturated ketone is 4-methylpent-3-en-2-one (mesityl oxide).
Mechanism (ethanal).
Enolate formation. OH⁻ removes an α-H from one ethanal molecule. The enolate ion ⁻CH₂CHO forms.
Nucleophilic attack. The α-carbon of the enolate attacks the carbonyl carbon of a second ethanal. A new C–C bond forms, giving an alkoxide ion.
Protonation. The alkoxide takes H⁺ from water. 3-Hydroxybutanal forms and OH⁻ is regenerated.
Dehydration (on heating). An α-H and the β-OH are lost as water. The C=C forms in conjugation with C=O, which makes the product stable.

Follow the CH₂ that loses its α-H in step 1: in step 2 it becomes the new C–C link, and in step 4 it is one end of the new C=C.
The word "aldol" joins "ald" (aldehyde) and "ol" (alcohol), the two groups in the product. Note that the new C–C bond always joins the α-carbon of one molecule to the carbonyl carbon of the other.
7.6 Cross aldol condensation
When two different carbonyl compounds are used, the reaction is a cross aldol condensation. If both have α-hydrogens, each can act as the enolate and each as the acceptor. So four products form.
Ethanal + propanal give these four β-hydroxy aldehydes:
| Enolate from | Attacks | β-Hydroxy aldehyde | After dehydration |
|---|---|---|---|
| ethanal | ethanal | 3-hydroxybutanal | but-2-enal |
| propanal | propanal | 3-hydroxy-2-methylpentanal | 2-methylpent-2-enal |
| ethanal | propanal | 3-hydroxypentanal | pent-2-enal |
| propanal | ethanal | 3-hydroxy-2-methylbutanal | 2-methylbut-2-enal |
A mixture of four products is of little use. Cross aldol is useful when one partner has no α-hydrogen, such as methanal or benzaldehyde. That partner can only accept. The other partner supplies the enolate.
Claisen–Schmidt condensation. Benzaldehyde condenses with a ketone that has α-hydrogens. Dehydration is fast because the new C=C is conjugated with the ring.
The product is 1,3-diphenylprop-2-en-1-one (benzalacetophenone, a chalcone). With propanone in a 1:1 ratio, benzaldehyde gives 4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one.
7.7 Cannizzaro reaction
Aldehydes with no α-hydrogen cannot form an enolate. With concentrated NaOH or KOH they undergo self oxidation–reduction (disproportionation). One molecule is oxidised to the carboxylate salt. The other is reduced to the alcohol.
Examples of aldehydes that give it: methanal, benzaldehyde, 2,2-dimethylpropanal, (CH₃)₃CCHO, and substituted benzaldehydes.
Mechanism.
OH⁻ adds to the carbonyl carbon of one aldehyde molecule. A tetrahedral anion forms.
This anion transfers a hydride ion (H⁻) to the carbonyl carbon of a second aldehyde molecule. The C=O of the first molecule reforms as a carboxylic acid. This hydride transfer is the slow step.
The acid gives its H⁺ to the alkoxide ion. The products are a carboxylate ion and an alcohol.

The molecule that OH⁻ attacks in step 1 ends as benzoate (oxidised); the one that receives H⁻ in step 2 ends as benzyl alcohol (reduced).
Crossed Cannizzaro. A mixture of methanal and benzaldehyde with conc. NaOH gives mainly sodium methanoate and benzyl alcohol. Methanal is the more reactive aldehyde, so OH⁻ attacks it first, and it is the one oxidised.
| Feature | Aldol condensation | Cannizzaro reaction |
|---|---|---|
| Needs | at least one α-H | no α-H |
| Alkali | dilute | concentrated |
| Key intermediate | enolate (carbanion) | tetrahedral anion that gives H⁻ |
| Products | β-hydroxy carbonyl, then α,β-unsaturated carbonyl | alcohol + carboxylate salt |
7.8 Haloform reaction
Compounds with a CH₃CO– group (methyl ketones and ethanal) react with a halogen in excess NaOH (that is, with sodium hypohalite, NaOX). The methyl group becomes a haloform, CHX₃. The rest of the molecule becomes a carboxylate with one carbon fewer.
The steps are:
OH⁻ removes an α-H from CH₃. The enolate takes up X from X₂.
Each X added makes the remaining α-H more acidic, so the second and third halogenations are faster. RCOCX₃ forms.
OH⁻ attacks the carbonyl carbon. CX₃⁻ leaves; it is a fair leaving group because three X atoms stabilise the charge.
Proton exchange gives RCOO⁻ and CHX₃.
Iodoform test. With I₂ and NaOH, the product is iodoform, CHI₃. It is a yellow solid with a typical antiseptic smell.
NaOI is also an oxidising agent. So alcohols with the CH₃CH(OH)– unit are first oxidised to CH₃CO– compounds and then give the test. A C=C elsewhere in the molecule is not attacked.
| Gives iodoform test | Does not give it |
|---|---|
| Ethanal, CH₃CHO | Methanal, propanal, benzaldehyde |
| Propanone, butanone, pentan-2-one, acetophenone | Pentan-3-one, benzophenone |
| Ethanol, CH₃CH₂OH | Methanol, propan-1-ol |
| Propan-2-ol, butan-2-ol, 1-phenylethanol | 2-Methylpropan-2-ol (no H on carbinol carbon) |
For ethanol, I₂ is needed for both oxidation and iodination. The balanced equation is:
The haloform reaction is also a way to make a carboxylic acid with one fewer carbon from a methyl ketone.
7.9 Distinguishing tests: putting it together
| Pair | Test | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Propanal vs propanone | Tollens' or Fehling's | propanal positive, propanone negative |
| Ethanal vs propanal | iodoform | ethanal gives yellow CHI₃ |
| Ethanal vs benzaldehyde | Fehling's | ethanal gives red-brown Cu₂O |
| Benzaldehyde vs acetophenone | Tollens' | benzaldehyde gives silver mirror |
| Acetophenone vs benzophenone | iodoform | acetophenone positive |
| Pentan-2-one vs pentan-3-one | iodoform | pentan-2-one positive |
| Ethanol vs methanol | iodoform | ethanol positive |
| Any C=O vs alcohol or ether | 2,4-DNP | carbonyl compound gives a coloured precipitate |
Schiff's reagent (a dye decolourised by SO₂) is also used: aldehydes restore its pink colour; most ketones do not.

Run the tests in this order: 2,4-DNP confirms a C=O group, Tollens' splits aldehydes from ketones, then Fehling's or iodoform splits each branch in two.
Worked example 7.1: Which of these undergo aldol condensation: methanal, ethanal, benzaldehyde, propanone, 2,2-dimethylpropanal?
Solution: Aldol needs an α-H. Ethanal (CH₃ next to CHO) and propanone (two CH₃ groups) have α-H, so they react. Methanal has no α-carbon. Benzaldehyde's α-carbon is a ring carbon with no H. 2,2-Dimethylpropanal's α-carbon has three methyls and no H. These three give Cannizzaro instead.
Worked example 7.2: Give the aldol and the final product when propanal is warmed with dilute NaOH.
Solution: The enolate forms at C2 of propanal: CH₃C⁻HCHO. It attacks the carbonyl carbon of a second propanal. The aldol is CH₃CH₂CH(OH)CH(CH₃)CHO, 3-hydroxy-2-methylpentanal. On heating it loses water to give CH₃CH₂CH=C(CH₃)CHO, 2-methylpent-2-enal.
Worked example 7.3: Benzaldehyde and propanone (1:1) are warmed with dilute NaOH. Give the product and explain why self-condensation of benzaldehyde does not occur.
Solution: Only propanone has α-H, so its enolate ⁻CH₂COCH₃ attacks benzaldehyde. After dehydration the product is C₆H₅CH=CHCOCH₃, 4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one. Benzaldehyde has no α-H, so it cannot form an enolate to attack itself.
Worked example 7.4: 21.2 g of benzaldehyde is heated with excess concentrated NaOH. Find the masses of the two organic products.
Solution: Molar mass of benzaldehyde = 106 g/mol, so moles = 0.20. Two aldehyde molecules give one alcohol and one carboxylate. So 0.10 mol benzyl alcohol (108 g/mol) = 10.8 g, and 0.10 mol sodium benzoate (144 g/mol) = 14.4 g.
Worked example 7.5: Methanal and benzaldehyde are heated together with conc. NaOH. Which is oxidised and which is reduced?
Solution: Methanal is the more reactive aldehyde. OH⁻ adds to it first, and it donates the hydride. So methanal is oxidised to sodium methanoate. Benzaldehyde accepts the hydride and is reduced to benzyl alcohol.
Worked example 7.6: Which of these give the iodoform test: butan-2-ol, pentan-3-one, 1-phenylethanol, propan-1-ol, ethanal?
Solution: Look for CH₃CO– or CH₃CH(OH)–. Butan-2-ol has CH₃CH(OH)–: yes. Pentan-3-one has ethyl groups on both sides: no. 1-Phenylethanol, C₆H₅CH(OH)CH₃: yes. Propan-1-ol has CH₃CH₂CH₂OH: no. Ethanal: yes.
Worked example 7.7: 4.6 g of ethanol is warmed with excess I₂ and NaOH. Find the mass of iodoform and the moles of I₂ used.
Solution: Moles of ethanol = 4.6 ÷ 46 = 0.10. One mole of ethanol gives one mole of CHI₃. Molar mass of CHI₃ = 12 + 1 + 381 = 394 g/mol. Mass = 39.4 g. From the balanced equation, 4 mol I₂ per mol ethanol, so 0.40 mol I₂.
Worked example 7.8: Suggest one test each to distinguish: (i) ethanal and benzaldehyde (ii) acetophenone and benzophenone (iii) propanal and propanone.
Solution: (i) Fehling's: only ethanal gives red-brown Cu₂O. (Iodoform also works.) (ii) Iodoform: only acetophenone has CH₃CO–. (iii) Tollens': only propanal gives a silver mirror.
Worked example 7.9: X (C₅H₁₀O) gives an orange precipitate with 2,4-DNP. It does not reduce Tollens' reagent. It gives a yellow precipitate with I₂/NaOH. Clemmensen reduction of X gives n-pentane. Identify X.
Solution: 2,4-DNP positive: a carbonyl compound. Tollens' negative: a ketone. Iodoform positive: a methyl ketone, CH₃CO–. Clemmensen gives an unbranched C₅ chain, so the skeleton is straight. X = pentan-2-one, CH₃COCH₂CH₂CH₃. (3-Methylbutan-2-one would give branched 2-methylbutane.)
Quick revision
Aldehydes are oxidised by mild reagents; ketones need strong oxidants and break C–C bonds.
Tollens' ([Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺): silver mirror with all aldehydes. Fehling's (Cu²⁺-tartrate): red-brown Cu₂O with aliphatic aldehydes only.
α-H is acidic (pKa of propanone about 19) because the enolate is resonance-stabilised.
Aldol: α-H + dilute alkali gives β-hydroxy carbonyl; heat gives α,β-unsaturated carbonyl.
Cross aldol with two α-H partners gives 4 products; Claisen–Schmidt uses benzaldehyde as the acceptor.
Cannizzaro: no α-H + conc. alkali gives alcohol + carboxylate; hydride transfer is the slow step. In crossed Cannizzaro, HCHO is oxidised.
Haloform: CH₃CO– or CH₃CH(OH)– with NaOX gives CHX₃ + RCOO⁻. Iodoform is yellow.
Ethanol needs 4 mol I₂ per mol in the iodoform reaction.
NEET traps
Saying benzaldehyde gives Fehling's test. It gives Tollens' but not Fehling's.
Expecting methanal or benzaldehyde to undergo aldol. No α-H, so they give Cannizzaro.
Using dilute alkali for Cannizzaro or conc. alkali for aldol. The concentrations are reversed.
Giving the iodoform test to propan-1-ol or pentan-3-one. Neither has CH₃CO– or CH₃CH(OH)–.
In crossed Cannizzaro, writing benzoate and methanol. The products are methanoate and benzyl alcohol.
Counting only two products for the cross aldol of ethanal and propanal. There are four.
Practice MCQs: Chapter 7
Level 1: Concept check
1. Tollens' reagent is: (a) Alkaline copper sulphate with tartrate (b) Ammoniacal silver nitrate (c) Acidified potassium dichromate (d) Iodine in NaOH
2. With an aliphatic aldehyde, Fehling's solution gives a precipitate of: (a) Silver, grey (b) CuO, black (c) Cu(OH)₂, blue (d) Cu₂O, red-brown
3. The aldol formed from ethanal is: (a) 3-Hydroxybutanal (b) 2-Hydroxybutanal (c) But-2-enal (d) Butane-1,3-diol
4. Which aldehyde undergoes the Cannizzaro reaction? (a) Ethanal (b) Propanal (c) Benzaldehyde (d) Butanal
5. Which gives the iodoform test? (a) Methanol (b) Ethanol (c) Propan-1-ol (d) Benzaldehyde
6. α-Hydrogens of carbonyl compounds are acidic mainly because: (a) The enolate ion formed is stabilised by resonance (b) Carbon is more electronegative than oxygen (c) They are bonded to oxygen (d) Carbonyl compounds are ionic
7. The colour of iodoform is: (a) Red (b) White (c) Violet (d) Yellow
8. Which does NOT undergo aldol condensation? (a) Ethanal (b) Propanone (c) Methanal (d) Propanal
9. Benzaldehyde warmed with Fehling's solution gives: (a) No red precipitate (b) A red-brown precipitate (c) A silver mirror (d) A yellow precipitate
10. Methanal with concentrated KOH gives: (a) Ethanol and potassium ethanoate (b) Methanol and potassium methanoate (c) Ethane-1,2-diol (d) Methane and CO₂
Level 2: NEET standard
11. Propanone with Ba(OH)₂, followed by heating, gives finally: (a) 4-Hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one (b) Pent-3-en-2-one (c) 4-Methylpent-3-en-2-one (d) Hexane-2,5-dione
12. A mixture of ethanal and propanal with dilute NaOH can give how many different β-hydroxy aldehydes? (a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 4
13. Propanal and propanone can be distinguished by: (a) Tollens' reagent (b) 2,4-DNP (c) NaBH₄ (d) HCN
14. Pentan-2-one and pentan-3-one can be distinguished by: (a) Tollens' reagent (b) Iodoform test (c) Fehling's solution (d) 2,4-DNP
15. Methanal and benzaldehyde are heated with conc. NaOH. The main products are: (a) Methanol and sodium benzoate (b) Methanol and benzyl alcohol (c) Sodium methanoate and benzyl alcohol (d) Sodium methanoate and sodium benzoate
16. 4.6 g of ethanol gives iodoform with excess I₂/NaOH. The mass of iodoform is: (a) 39.4 g (b) 19.7 g (c) 78.8 g (d) 25.4 g
17. Benzaldehyde and propanone (1:1) with dilute NaOH give mainly: (a) Benzyl alcohol (b) 1,3-Diphenylprop-2-en-1-one (c) Mesityl oxide (d) 4-Phenylbut-3-en-2-one
18. Which compound gives both the Tollens' test and the iodoform test? (a) Propanone (b) Ethanal (c) Benzaldehyde (d) Methanal
19. The slow step of the Cannizzaro reaction is: (a) Formation of an enolate (b) Loss of water (c) Transfer of a hydride ion (d) Attack of a halogen
20. Acetophenone with excess NaOI gives: (a) Sodium benzoate and iodoform (b) Benzaldehyde and iodoform (c) Phenol and iodoform (d) Benzyl alcohol only
21. Which alcohol gives a positive iodoform test? (a) Propan-1-ol (b) Methanol (c) 2-Methylpropan-2-ol (d) Propan-2-ol
22. On vigorous oxidation, ketones give: (a) An aldehyde with the same carbons (b) Carboxylic acids with fewer carbons (c) An alcohol (d) No reaction ever
Level 3: Challenge
23. 21.2 g of benzaldehyde undergoes complete Cannizzaro reaction. The mass of benzyl alcohol formed is: (a) 21.6 g (b) 14.4 g (c) 10.8 g (d) 5.4 g
24. The first step in the base-catalysed aldol condensation of ethanal is: (a) Removal of an α-H by OH⁻ to form an enolate (b) Addition of OH⁻ to the carbonyl carbon (c) Protonation of the carbonyl oxygen (d) Hydride transfer
25. X (C₅H₁₀O) gives a 2,4-DNP precipitate, does not reduce Tollens' reagent, gives the iodoform test, and on Clemmensen reduction gives n-pentane. X is: (a) Pentanal (b) Pentan-3-one (c) 3-Methylbutan-2-one (d) Pentan-2-one
26. Which does NOT give the iodoform test? (a) Butan-2-ol (b) Pentan-3-one (c) Acetophenone (d) Ethanal
27. 2,2-Dimethylpropanal heated with conc. NaOH gives: (a) An aldol (b) 2,2-Dimethylpropene (c) 2,2-Dimethylpropan-1-ol and sodium 2,2-dimethylpropanoate (d) No reaction
28. The number of moles of I₂ consumed per mole of ethanol in the iodoform reaction is: (a) 4 (b) 3 (c) 2 (d) 1
29. Assertion (A): Benzaldehyde undergoes the Cannizzaro reaction with concentrated NaOH. Reason (R): Benzaldehyde has no α-hydrogen. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true
30. Statement I: Tollens' test can distinguish ethanal from benzaldehyde. Statement II: Fehling's test can distinguish ethanal from benzaldehyde. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true
Answer key with reasons
| Q | Ans | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | b | [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺ in ammonia. |
| 2 | d | Cu²⁺ is reduced to red-brown Cu₂O. |
| 3 | a | CH₃CH(OH)CH₂CHO. |
| 4 | c | No α-H in benzaldehyde. |
| 5 | b | Ethanol is oxidised to ethanal, which has CH₃CO–. |
| 6 | a | Negative charge spreads onto oxygen. |
| 7 | d | CHI₃ is a yellow solid. |
| 8 | c | Methanal has no α-carbon. |
| 9 | a | Aromatic aldehydes do not respond to Fehling's. |
| 10 | b | Disproportionation: CH₃OH + HCOOK. |
| 11 | c | Ketol loses water to give mesityl oxide. |
| 12 | d | Each compound can act as donor and as acceptor. |
| 13 | a | Only the aldehyde reduces Ag⁺. |
| 14 | b | Only pentan-2-one has CH₃CO–. |
| 15 | c | HCHO is oxidised, C₆H₅CHO reduced. |
| 16 | a | 0.10 mol × 394 g/mol = 39.4 g. |
| 17 | d | Propanone enolate attacks benzaldehyde, then dehydration. |
| 18 | b | Aldehyde with a CH₃CO– unit. |
| 19 | c | Hydride transfer between two molecules. |
| 20 | a | C₆H₅COCH₃ gives C₆H₅COONa + CHI₃. |
| 21 | d | Has the CH₃CH(OH)– unit. |
| 22 | b | C–C cleavage gives smaller acids. |
| 23 | c | 0.20 mol aldehyde gives 0.10 mol (10.8 g) alcohol. |
| 24 | a | OH⁻ removes an α-H. |
| 25 | d | Straight-chain methyl ketone. |
| 26 | b | No CH₃CO– group in pentan-3-one. |
| 27 | c | No α-H: Cannizzaro products. |
| 28 | a | 1 I₂ for oxidation + 3 I₂ for iodination. |
| 29 | a | No α-H means no enolate, so Cannizzaro occurs. |
| 30 | d | Both give Tollens' mirror; only ethanal gives Fehling's. |
Chapter 7 revision sheet
One-page summary
α-Hydrogens (on the carbon next to C=O) are acidic: the enolate formed spreads its negative charge over C and O.
Aldol reaction: aldehyde or ketone with α-H + dilute NaOH → β-hydroxy aldehyde (aldol) or β-hydroxy ketone (ketol).
On heating, the aldol loses water → α,β-unsaturated carbonyl (aldol condensation). Ethanal → 3-hydroxybutanal → but-2-enal.
Cross aldol: two different carbonyls, both with α-H → four products. With one partner lacking α-H (e.g., benzaldehyde + propanone), the products are fewer (Claisen–Schmidt).
Cannizzaro: aldehyde with no α-H + conc. NaOH → alcohol + carboxylate salt (disproportionation by hydride transfer). 2HCHO → CH₃OH + HCOONa.
Cross Cannizzaro with HCHO: HCHO is oxidised to formate; the other aldehyde is reduced to the alcohol.
Haloform (iodoform) test: CH₃CO– or CH₃CH(OH)– + NaOI → yellow CHI₃ + carboxylate with one carbon fewer.
Tollens' reagent ([Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺): all aldehydes give a silver mirror. Methanoic acid also does. Ketones do not.
Fehling's (CuSO₄ + sodium potassium tartrate + NaOH): aliphatic aldehydes give red-brown Cu₂O. Aromatic aldehydes do not.
–CHO and –COR on a ring are deactivating and meta-directing (e.g., nitration of benzaldehyde gives 3-nitrobenzaldehyde).
Distinguishing pairs: ethanal vs propanal (iodoform); propanal vs propanone (Tollens'/Fehling's); pentan-2-one vs pentan-3-one (iodoform); benzaldehyde vs ethanal (Fehling's or iodoform).
Must-remember table
| Test | Reagent | Positive sign | Positive for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tollens' | Ammoniacal AgNO₃ | Silver mirror | All aldehydes, HCOOH |
| Fehling's | CuSO₄ + Rochelle salt + NaOH | Red-brown ppt (Cu₂O) | Aliphatic aldehydes |
| Iodoform | I₂ + NaOH | Yellow ppt (CHI₃) | CH₃CO–, CH₃CH(OH)–, ethanol, ethanal |
| 2,4-DNP | 2,4-Dinitrophenylhydrazine | Orange-yellow ppt | Aldehydes and ketones |
| Sodium bisulphite | Saturated NaHSO₃ | Crystals | Aldehydes, most methyl ketones |
| Has α-H? | Dilute alkali | Conc. alkali |
|---|---|---|
| Yes (CH₃CHO, CH₃COCH₃) | Aldol | — |
| No (HCHO, C₆H₅CHO, (CH₃)₃CCHO) | No aldol | Cannizzaro |
Memory aids
"ALDOL = ALDehyde + alcohOL": the product carries both groups.
"No α-H? Cannizzaro calls": aldehydes without α-H take the Cannizzaro route in strong base.
"Fehling Fails Phenyl": aromatic aldehydes do not give Fehling's test; Tollens' works for all aldehydes.
"Iodoform hunts CH₃ next door": a CH₃ next to C=O, or next to CH(OH), gives yellow CHI₃.
"HCHO is the Helpful sacrifice": in cross Cannizzaro, formaldehyde gets oxidised so the other aldehyde becomes the alcohol.
Concept connections
Enolate resonance and carbanion stability come from Chemistry Book 14: Some Basic Principles of Organic Chemistry.
Glucose reduces Tollens' and Fehling's reagents: see Chemistry Book 19: Biomolecules.
These functional group tests are practised in Chemistry Book 20: Principles Related to Practical Chemistry.
Practice MCQs: Chapter 7, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)
31. Match List I (compound) with List II (behaviour in tests).
List I:
A. Benzaldehyde
B. Propanone
C. Ethanal
D. Pentan-3-one
List II:
(i) Gives a silver mirror, a red precipitate with Fehling's and a yellow iodoform precipitate
(ii) Gives a silver mirror but no red precipitate with Fehling's
(iii) Gives none of these three tests
(iv) Gives only the iodoform test
(a) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii (b) A-iv, B-ii, C-i, D-iii (c) A-ii, B-i, C-iv, D-iii (d) A-ii, B-iv, C-iii, D-i
32. Match List I (reaction) with List II (product).
List I:
A. Ethanal, dilute NaOH, cold
B. Ethanal, dilute NaOH, heat
C. Methanal, conc. NaOH
D. Propanone, I₂ + NaOH
List II:
(i) Methanol + sodium methanoate
(ii) Iodoform + sodium ethanoate
(iii) But-2-enal
(iv) 3-Hydroxybutanal
(a) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (b) A-iv, B-iii, C-ii, D-i (c) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (d) A-i, B-iii, C-iv, D-ii
33. Match List I (reagent) with List II (composition).
List I:
A. Tollens' reagent
B. Fehling's solution
C. Iodoform reagent
D. Benedict's solution
List II:
(i) CuSO₄ with sodium citrate and Na₂CO₃
(ii) I₂ with NaOH
(iii) CuSO₄ with sodium potassium tartrate and NaOH
(iv) [Ag(NH₃)₂]⁺
(a) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (b) A-iv, B-ii, C-iii, D-i (c) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (d) A-iv, B-iii, C-ii, D-i
34. Match List I (reactants) with List II (type of reaction).
List I:
A. Benzaldehyde + conc. NaOH
B. Propanal + dilute NaOH
C. Benzaldehyde + propanone + dilute NaOH
D. Butanone + I₂/NaOH
List II:
(i) Haloform reaction
(ii) Cannizzaro reaction
(iii) Cross aldol (Claisen–Schmidt) reaction
(iv) Self aldol reaction
(a) A-iv, B-ii, C-iii, D-i (b) A-ii, B-iv, C-iii, D-i (c) A-ii, B-iii, C-iv, D-i (d) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii
35. How many of the following give a positive iodoform test?
Ethanol
Methanol
Propan-2-ol
Propanal
Acetophenone
Pentan-3-one
Ethanal
Butan-2-ol
(a) Three (b) Four (c) Six (d) Five
36. Choose the correct set of statements.
A. The Cannizzaro reaction needs an aldehyde with no α-hydrogen.
B. In cross Cannizzaro of HCHO with C₆H₅CHO, HCHO is oxidised to formate.
C. 2,2-Dimethylpropanal undergoes aldol condensation.
D. The aldol reaction needs concentrated NaOH.
(a) A only (b) A and B only (c) A, B and C only (d) B and D only
37. Choose the correct statements about α-hydrogens.
A. They are acidic because the enolate ion is resonance-stabilised.
B. Ethanal has three α-hydrogens.
C. Benzaldehyde has one α-hydrogen.
D. Propanone has six α-hydrogens.
(a) A and B only (b) B, C and D only (c) A, B and D only (d) A, C and D only
38. How many of these aldehydes undergo the Cannizzaro reaction?
Methanal
Benzaldehyde
2,2-Dimethylpropanal
Ethanal
2-Methylpropanal
4-Methylbenzaldehyde
(a) Four (b) Three (c) Five (d) Two
39. Four compounds P, Q, R and S give these results (+ = positive, − = negative).
| Compound | Tollens' | Fehling's | Iodoform |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | + | + | + |
| Q | + | − | − |
| R | − | − | + |
| S | + | + | − |
Which identification fits?
(a) P propanal, Q benzaldehyde, R propanone, S ethanal (b) P ethanal, Q propanone, R benzaldehyde, S propanal (c) P ethanal, Q benzaldehyde, R propanone, S propanal (d) P ethanal, Q propanal, R propanone, S benzaldehyde
40. A diagram shows two resonance structures for the anion formed when base removes an α-H from propanone: one with the negative charge on the α-carbon, one with the charge on oxygen and a C=C bond. Which statement follows?
(a) The carbon carries more charge because carbon is more electronegative (b) The charge is shared between C and O, which stabilises the anion and makes α-H acidic (c) The two structures are two different molecules in fast equilibrium (d) The anion is an electrophile
41. 2.9 g of propanone (M = 58 g/mol) is warmed with excess I₂ and NaOH. The mass of iodoform (CHI₃, M = 394 g/mol) formed at 100% yield is:
(a) 39.4 g (b) 9.85 g (c) 29.0 g (d) 19.7 g
Passage for Q42–43: Two isomers of formula C₃H₆O are tested. A gives a yellow precipitate with I₂/NaOH but no silver mirror with Tollens' reagent. B gives a silver mirror but no yellow precipitate.
42. A and B are:
(a) Propanone and propanal (b) Propanal and propanone (c) Prop-2-en-1-ol and propanone (d) Propanone and methoxyethene
43. B is warmed with dilute NaOH. The final aldol condensation product is:
(a) Hex-2-enal (b) 3-Hydroxyhexanal (c) 2-Methylpent-2-enal (d) Propanoic acid
44. Ethanal and propanal are mixed and treated with dilute NaOH. Ignoring stereoisomers, how many different β-hydroxy aldehydes can form?
(a) Two (b) Four (c) Three (d) Six
45. Benzaldehyde and propanone are warmed with dilute NaOH. The main product is:
(a) C₆H₅CH₂OH + CH₃COONa (b) C₆H₅COOH (c) C₆H₅CH(OH)CH₃ (d) C₆H₅CH=CHCOCH₃
Level 4 answer key
| Q | Ans | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 31 | a | Benzaldehyde fails Fehling's; propanone gives only iodoform; ethanal passes all three; pentan-3-one has no CH₃CO– and is a ketone |
| 32 | c | Aldol, then crotonaldehyde on heating; Cannizzaro of HCHO; haloform of propanone |
| 33 | d | Tollens' is the silver–ammonia complex; Fehling's uses tartrate; Benedict's uses citrate |
| 34 | b | No α-H → Cannizzaro; propanal self aldol; mixed partners → Claisen–Schmidt; butanone has CH₃CO– |
| 35 | d | Ethanol, propan-2-ol, acetophenone, ethanal, butan-2-ol give it; methanol, propanal, pentan-3-one do not |
| 36 | b | 2,2-Dimethylpropanal has no α-H (C false); aldol uses dilute alkali (D false) |
| 37 | c | The CHO carbon of benzaldehyde is attached to the ring carbon, which has no H, so it has no α-H |
| 38 | a | Methanal, benzaldehyde, 2,2-dimethylpropanal, 4-methylbenzaldehyde lack α-H |
| 39 | c | All three = ethanal; Tollens' only = aromatic aldehyde; iodoform only = methyl ketone; Tollens' + Fehling's only = propanal |
| 40 | b | Delocalisation onto the more electronegative oxygen stabilises the enolate |
| 41 | d | 2.9/58 = 0.05 mol → 0.05 mol CHI₃ × 394 = 19.7 g |
| 42 | a | Methyl ketone without aldehyde H = propanone; aldehyde without CH₃CO = propanal |
| 43 | c | Propanal aldol: 3-hydroxy-2-methylpentanal; losing water gives 2-methylpent-2-enal |
| 44 | b | Two self aldols + two cross aldols = 4 |
| 45 | d | Claisen–Schmidt: propanone enolate attacks benzaldehyde, then water is lost |