Chapter 5: Second Law, Reversible and Irreversible Processes
What you will learn
Why the first law alone cannot tell the direction of a process.
The Kelvin–Planck and Clausius statements of the second law, and why they are equivalent.
What makes a process reversible, and why every real process is irreversible.
The main causes of irreversibility, with everyday examples.
Free expansion: Q, W and ΔU, and why it is irreversible.
Why a reversible process gives the most work between two states.
5.1 Why we need a second law
The first law only checks the energy account. Many processes that balance the account never happen on their own:
A cup of chai cools to room temperature. The reverse, chai warming by taking heat from cooler air, never happens.
A moving auto-rickshaw brakes to a stop and its brakes get hot. Hot brakes never cool down and push the auto forward.
A drop of ink spreads through a glass of water. It never gathers itself back into a drop.
Each reverse process conserves energy. The first law has no objection. Yet nature runs only one way. The second law states this one-way rule.
5.2 Kelvin–Planck statement
Kelvin–Planck statement: no process is possible whose sole result is the absorption of heat from a reservoir and its complete conversion into work.
The key words are sole result. In an isothermal expansion an ideal gas does turn all absorbed heat into work. But the gas ends up at a larger volume, so that is not the sole result. To repeat the process the gas must be brought back, and that needs heat to be given out somewhere.
What this means for engines: an engine working in a cycle must reject some heat to a colder body. No heat engine can be 100% efficient. A ship cannot run by simply cooling sea water and turning all that heat into work.
5.3 Clausius statement
Clausius statement: no process is possible whose sole result is the transfer of heat from a colder object to a hotter object.
A refrigerator does move heat from its cold inside to the warmer kitchen. It does not break the rule, because it needs electrical work from the compressor. Heat flowing from cold to hot is never the sole result.
5.4 The two statements are equivalent
If one statement fails, the other must fail too. Here is the idea in one direction.
Suppose a device breaks Clausius: it moves heat Q₂ from cold to hot with no work.
Run an ordinary engine between the same two bodies. It takes Q₁ from the hot body, does work W and rejects Q₂ to the cold body.
Combine the two. The cold body has no net change. The hot body has given out Q₁ − Q₂ = W, and all of it became work.
That combined device breaks Kelvin–Planck.
A similar argument works the other way. So both are two faces of one law.
5.5 Reversible processes
A process is reversible if it can be run backwards so that both the system and its surroundings return exactly to their original states, with no change anywhere in the universe.
Two conditions are needed:
The process must be quasi-static: the system passes through equilibrium states, so every step can be reversed by a tiny change in conditions.
There must be no dissipative effects: no friction, viscosity, electrical resistance or inelastic deformation, which turn work into heat irreversibly.
Examples close to reversible: very slow isothermal expansion of gas in a frictionless cylinder kept in a large bath; very slow adiabatic compression in a frictionless, insulated cylinder. A truly reversible process is an ideal limit. It would take infinite time.
5.6 Irreversible processes
Every natural process is irreversible. Irreversibility has two main sources.
Source 1: the process passes through non-equilibrium states.
Free expansion of a gas into vacuum.
Heat flow across a finite temperature difference, such as chai cooling in a room.
Sudden (fast) expansion or compression, where pressure is not uniform.
Mixing of two gases, or diffusion of ink in water.
Burning of fuel and other fast chemical reactions.
Source 2: dissipative effects.
Friction between moving parts, such as brakes or a piston rubbing a cylinder.
Viscosity in a liquid being stirred.
Current flowing through a resistor and heating it.
| Feature | Reversible | Irreversible |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Infinitely slow (quasi-static) | Finite speed |
| States passed through | All equilibrium states | Some non-equilibrium states |
| Dissipation (friction, resistance) | None | Present |
| Can be drawn on P-V diagram | Yes, as a line | Only the end states |
| Universe after reversing | Fully restored | Some change remains |
| Occurs in nature | No, ideal limit | Yes, every real process |
| Work in expansion between two states | Maximum | Less |
5.7 Free expansion: a classic irreversible process
Take an insulated rigid box split by a partition. One side holds an ideal gas, the other is vacuum. Remove the partition. The gas rushes into the empty side.
Q = 0: the box is insulated.
W = 0: the gas pushes against nothing, so it does no work.
So ΔU = Q − W = 0. For an ideal gas this means the temperature does not change.
The pressure drops, in line with PV = constant at the same T.
The process is not quasi-static. In the middle, the gas swirls and has no single pressure. So it cannot be drawn as a line on a P-V diagram. Only the start and end points can be marked.
Note that free expansion is adiabatic (Q = 0) but it does not follow PV^γ = constant. That equation is only for a quasi-static adiabatic process.
The gas never gathers itself back into one half. To push it back, you must compress it and remove heat. The gas returns, but the surroundings have lost work and gained heat. So the process is irreversible.
5.8 Reversible work is the maximum work
Let a gas expand from P₁ to P₂ at constant temperature T.
Reversibly, the outside pressure is kept just below the gas pressure at every stage. W = nRT ln(P₁/P₂).
Irreversibly, against a constant outside pressure P₂, the gas jumps out at once. W = P₂(V₂ − V₁), which is smaller.
In the reversible path the gas always pushes against the highest possible opposing pressure, so it does the most work. Any irreversibility loses some useful work.
5.9 First law versus second law
| Point | First law | Second law |
|---|---|---|
| Main idea | Energy is conserved | Natural processes have a direction |
| Tells us | How much energy changes | Whether a process can occur on its own |
| Limit on engines | Work cannot exceed heat taken in | Work must be less than heat taken in; some heat must be rejected |
| Statement form | Q = ΔU + W | Kelvin–Planck, Clausius |
A bridging idea: physicists measure this one-way nature with a state function called entropy. In every irreversible process, the total entropy of the system and surroundings increases. In a reversible process it stays the same. NEET does not need entropy calculations from this unit.
Worked example 5.1: An inventor claims an engine that, in each cycle, takes 2000 J of heat from the sea and delivers 2000 J of work, with no other effect. Comment.
Solution: Energy is conserved, so the first law is satisfied. But the sole result is turning heat from one reservoir fully into work. This breaks the Kelvin–Planck statement. The engine is impossible.
Worked example 5.2: Classify as reversible (ideal) or irreversible: (i) a ball bouncing to lower heights each time; (ii) very slow frictionless isothermal compression; (iii) chai cooling in a cup; (iv) ink spreading in water; (v) very slow frictionless adiabatic expansion.
Solution: (ii) and (v) are reversible in the ideal limit. (i) has dissipation (inelastic impacts). (iii) is heat flow across a finite temperature difference. (iv) is diffusion. So (i), (iii) and (iv) are irreversible.
Worked example 5.3: 2 mol of an ideal gas at 300 K, in an insulated rigid box, expands freely into vacuum and doubles its volume. Find Q, W, ΔU, the final temperature and the ratio of final to initial pressure.
Solution: Q = 0 (insulated), W = 0 (no opposing pressure), ΔU = 0. Final temperature = 300 K. At the same T, PV is constant, so P₂/P₁ = V₁/V₂ = 1/2.
Worked example 5.4: 1 mol of an ideal gas at 300 K and 2.0 × 10⁵ Pa expands isothermally to 1.0 × 10⁵ Pa. Find the work done (i) reversibly and (ii) against a constant outside pressure of 1.0 × 10⁵ Pa.
Solution: (i) W = nRT ln(P₁/P₂) = 8.3 × 300 × 0.693 = 1726 J. (ii) W = P₂(V₂ − V₁) = P₂ × nRT(1/P₂ − 1/P₁) = nRT(1 − P₂/P₁) = 8.3 × 300 × 0.5 = 1245 J. The irreversible path gives less work.
Worked example 5.5: Two equal copper blocks, one at 80 °C and one at 20 °C, are placed in contact inside an insulated box. Find the final temperature. Is the process reversible?
Solution: Equal masses and the same specific heat give T = (80 + 20)/2 = 50 °C. Heat flowed across a finite temperature difference. The blocks will never separate back into 80 °C and 20 °C on their own. The process is irreversible.
Worked example 5.6: A refrigerator is said to take 400 J from its freezer and give 400 J to the kitchen, using no electricity. Which law does this break?
Solution: Energy is balanced, so the first law is fine. The sole result is heat moving from cold to hot, which breaks the Clausius statement of the second law.
Worked example 5.7: 1 mol of an ideal gas at 300 K expands freely from V to 3V. It is then pushed back to V by a slow isothermal compression at 300 K. How much heat goes to the surroundings in the compression? What does this show?
Solution: In the compression, W = RT ln(V/3V) = −8.3 × 300 × 1.099 = −2736 J. ΔU = 0, so Q = −2736 J: about 2.74 kJ of heat goes to the surroundings, and the surroundings supplied 2.74 kJ of work. The gas is back to its start, but the surroundings are changed. So the free expansion was irreversible.
Quick revision
The first law conserves energy; the second law decides direction.
Kelvin–Planck: heat from one reservoir cannot be turned completely into work as the sole result. No engine is 100% efficient.
Clausius: heat cannot pass from cold to hot as the sole result. A refrigerator needs work.
The two statements are equivalent.
Reversible = quasi-static + no dissipation. It is an ideal limit and gives maximum work.
All natural processes are irreversible: free expansion, heat flow across finite ΔT, friction, mixing, burning.
Free expansion of an ideal gas: Q = 0, W = 0, ΔU = 0, T unchanged.
NEET traps
Saying isothermal expansion breaks Kelvin–Planck. It does not, because the gas state also changes; conversion is not the sole result.
Saying a refrigerator breaks Clausius. It uses external work.
Applying PV^γ = constant to free expansion. Free expansion is not quasi-static.
Thinking free expansion cools an ideal gas. Its temperature stays the same.
Calling any slow process reversible. Friction or a finite temperature gap still makes it irreversible.
Thinking a process allowed by the first law must happen. The second law may forbid it.
Practice MCQs: Chapter 5
Level 1: Concept check
1. The second law of thermodynamics tells us about (a) conservation of energy (b) the direction of natural processes (c) the definition of temperature (d) the value of the gas constant
2. According to the Kelvin–Planck statement, it is impossible to (a) convert work completely into heat (b) transfer heat from a hot body to a cold body (c) convert heat from a single reservoir completely into work as the sole result of a cycle (d) compress a gas adiabatically
3. The Clausius statement says that (a) heat cannot flow by itself from a colder body to a hotter body (b) heat cannot be converted into work (c) energy is conserved (d) work cannot be converted into heat
4. Which of these is irreversible? (a) very slow frictionless isothermal expansion (b) free expansion of a gas into vacuum (c) very slow frictionless adiabatic compression (d) an ideal Carnot cycle
5. For a process to be reversible it must be (a) quasi-static with no dissipative effects (b) fast (c) adiabatic (d) isothermal
6. In the free expansion of an ideal gas, its temperature (a) rises (b) falls (c) stays the same (d) first rises, then falls
7. Which of these is a dissipative effect? (a) slow compression (b) heat flow across zero temperature difference (c) an equilibrium state (d) friction
8. All natural processes are (a) reversible (b) irreversible (c) quasi-static (d) isothermal
9. A refrigerator moves heat from cold to hot without breaking the Clausius statement because (a) external work is done on it (b) heat flows naturally from cold to hot (c) it works adiabatically (d) energy is not conserved in it
10. The law that rules out a 100% efficient heat engine is the (a) zeroth law (b) first law (c) second law (d) none of these
Level 2: NEET standard
11. An inventor claims an engine that takes 500 J per cycle from a single reservoir at 400 K and gives 500 J of work, with no other effect. The claim breaks the (a) first law (b) zeroth law (c) no law (d) second law
12. An engine is claimed to take 500 J of heat and give 600 J of work per cycle. The claim breaks the (a) first law (b) second law only (c) zeroth law (d) no law
13. 2 mol of an ideal gas at 27 °C in an insulated rigid vessel expands freely into vacuum and doubles its volume. Its final temperature is (a) 13.5 °C (b) 27 °C (c) 54 °C (d) −123 °C
14. For the free expansion of an ideal gas, (a) Q = 0, W = 0, ΔU = 0 (b) Q = 0, W > 0, ΔU < 0 (c) Q > 0, W > 0, ΔU = 0 (d) Q = 0, W < 0, ΔU > 0
15. 1 mol of an ideal gas at 300 K and 3.0 × 10⁵ Pa expands isothermally against a constant outside pressure of 1.0 × 10⁵ Pa until the pressures are equal. The work done by the gas is (R = 8.3 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹) (a) 2736 J (b) 830 J (c) 1660 J (d) 2490 J
16. If the expansion in Q15 were done reversibly at 300 K, the work done would be about (ln 3 = 1.099) (a) 2736 J (b) 1660 J (c) 3320 J (d) 911 J
17. Which statement is correct? (a) Reversible processes are common in nature (b) Every reversible process is adiabatic (c) A reversible process can be retraced so that the system and the surroundings both return to their initial states (d) Irreversible processes do not obey the first law
18. Heat conduction from a hot reservoir to a cold reservoir through a metal rod is irreversible because (a) heat flows across a finite temperature difference (b) the rod does work (c) energy is destroyed (d) the rod has a uniform temperature
19. Equal masses of water at 70 °C and 30 °C are mixed in an insulated flask. The final temperature and the nature of the process are (a) 50 °C, reversible (b) 50 °C, irreversible (c) 40 °C, irreversible (d) 60 °C, reversible
20. Which of these is NOT a cause of irreversibility? (a) friction (b) viscosity (c) heat flow across a finite temperature difference (d) a quasi-static change with no friction
21. If the Clausius statement could be broken, then (a) the Kelvin–Planck statement could also be broken (b) energy would not be conserved (c) the zeroth law would fail (d) nothing else would follow
22. The free expansion of a gas cannot be drawn as a line on a P-V diagram because (a) it is a hyperbola (b) its volume does not change (c) its in-between states are not equilibrium states (d) its pressure stays constant
Level 3: Challenge
23. 2 mol of an ideal gas at 400 K expands isothermally from 10 L to 20 L against a constant outside pressure equal to its final pressure. The work done by the gas is (R = 8.3 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹) (a) 4602 J (b) 6640 J (c) 3320 J (d) 1660 J
24. In Q23, the ratio of the work done to the work that a reversible isothermal expansion between the same states would give is about (a) 0.72 (b) 1.39 (c) 0.50 (d) 1.00
25. 1 mol of an ideal gas at 300 K expands freely from V to 3V. It is then brought back to V by a slow isothermal compression at 300 K. The heat given to the surroundings in the compression is about (ln 3 = 1.099) (a) zero (b) 1660 J (c) 911 J (d) 2736 J
26. Which pair contains only irreversible processes? (a) slow frictionless isothermal compression and slow frictionless adiabatic expansion (b) diffusion of two gases and burning of fuel (c) quasi-static heating through tiny temperature steps and slow frictionless adiabatic compression (d) the four steps of an ideal Carnot cycle
27. An engine is claimed to take 1000 J from a hot source per cycle, reject no heat, and deliver 1000 J of work. It (a) obeys both laws (b) breaks the first law (c) breaks the second law only (d) breaks both laws
28. A device is claimed to take 300 J per cycle from a cold box and give 300 J to a warm room, with no work input. It breaks (a) the second law (Clausius) only (b) the first law only (c) both first and second laws (d) no law
29. Assertion (A): The free expansion of an ideal gas is irreversible. Reason (R): In the free expansion of an ideal gas, the temperature does not change. (a) Both true, R explains A (b) Both true, R does not explain A (c) A true, R false (d) A false, R true
30. Statement I: The Kelvin–Planck and Clausius statements of the second law are equivalent. Statement II: Any process that obeys the first law will take place on its own. (a) Both true (b) Both false (c) I true, II false (d) I false, II true
Answer key with reasons
| Q | Ans | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | b | Second law sets direction |
| 2 | c | Kelvin–Planck statement |
| 3 | a | Clausius statement |
| 4 | b | Passes through non-equilibrium states |
| 5 | a | Both conditions are needed |
| 6 | c | Q = 0, W = 0 so ΔU = 0 |
| 7 | d | Friction turns work into heat irreversibly |
| 8 | b | Every real process is irreversible |
| 9 | a | Compressor supplies work |
| 10 | c | Kelvin–Planck statement |
| 11 | d | Complete conversion from one reservoir |
| 12 | a | Output exceeds input energy |
| 13 | b | ΔU = 0 so T unchanged |
| 14 | a | No heat, no opposing pressure |
| 15 | c | nRT(1 − 1/3) = 8.3 × 300 × 2/3 = 1660 J |
| 16 | a | 8.3 × 300 × 1.099 = 2736 J |
| 17 | c | Definition of reversible process |
| 18 | a | Finite ΔT causes irreversibility |
| 19 | b | Average 50 °C; heat flow across finite ΔT |
| 20 | d | That is the reversible ideal |
| 21 | a | The two statements are equivalent |
| 22 | c | No single P during the process |
| 23 | c | P = 2 × 8.3 × 400/0.02 = 3.32 × 10⁵ Pa; × 0.01 m³ = 3320 J |
| 24 | a | 3320/4602 = 0.72 |
| 25 | d | RT ln 3 = 2736 J |
| 26 | b | Diffusion and burning are natural, one-way |
| 27 | c | Energy balances, but no heat rejected |
| 28 | a | Energy balances; heat moves cold to hot with no work |
| 29 | b | Irreversible because not quasi-static, not because T is constant |
| 30 | c | First law alone does not ensure a process occurs |
Chapter 5 revision sheet
One-page summary
The first law allows many processes that never happen, like a cold cup of chai heating itself from the table. The second law rules them out.
Kelvin–Planck: no process is possible whose sole result is taking heat from a reservoir and turning all of it into work.
So no heat engine can have efficiency 1. Some heat must go to a colder sink.
Clausius: no process is possible whose sole result is moving heat from a colder body to a hotter body.
So a refrigerator always needs work input.
The two statements are equivalent: breaking one lets you break the other.
"Sole result" matters. Isothermal expansion turns all heat into work, but the gas ends in a new state, so no law is broken.
Work can turn fully into heat (friction, brakes). The reverse, in a cycle, cannot.
Reversible process: system and surroundings can both be returned to their initial states with no change anywhere.
Conditions for reversibility: quasi-static and free of dissipative effects (friction, viscosity, electrical resistance).
Every natural process is irreversible. Reversible processes are an ideal limit.
Sources of irreversibility: friction and other dissipation; heat flow across a finite temperature difference; sudden, non-equilibrium changes such as free expansion or mixing.
Free expansion of an ideal gas into vacuum in an insulated box: Q = 0, W = 0, ΔU = 0, so T is unchanged.
Free expansion is not quasi-static. It cannot be drawn as a curve on a P-V graph and PV^γ = constant does not apply.
Bridge to entropy: in every irreversible process the total entropy of system plus surroundings increases; in a reversible one it stays the same.
Must-remember table
| Statement or process | Key idea | What it forbids or gives |
|---|---|---|
| Kelvin–Planck | Heat to work in a cycle needs a sink | Engine with η = 1 |
| Clausius | Cold to hot needs work | Refrigerator with no work input |
| Reversible process | Quasi-static and no dissipation | Ideal limit only |
| Free expansion (ideal gas) | Q = W = ΔU = 0 | T same, P halves when V doubles |
| Reversible isothermal, V to 2V | ΔU = 0 | Q = W = nRT ln 2 |
| Mixing hot and cold water | Irreversible | Equal final temperatures |
Memory aids
"KP = Keep a Pit": Kelvin–Planck says every engine needs a pit (sink) to dump some heat.
"Clausius Can't Climb": heat cannot climb from cold to hot on its own.
"QS-ND": a reversible process is Quasi-Static and has No Dissipation.
"Free means Zero-Zero-Zero": free expansion has Q, W and ΔU all zero.
"Sole is the soul": the phrase "sole result" is the heart of both statements.
Concept connections
Chemistry Book 4: Chemical Thermodynamics uses entropy and Gibbs energy to decide whether a reaction is spontaneous.
Physics Book 9: Kinetic Theory of Gases explains free expansion of an ideal gas through molecules that do not attract each other.
Physics Book 4: Work, Energy and Power shows how friction turns mechanical energy into heat, a main source of irreversibility.
Practice MCQs: Chapter 5, Level 4 (new NEET pattern)
31. Match the statement in List I with the law in List II.
List I:
A. Energy is conserved when heat and work are both counted.
B. No process has as its sole result the full conversion of heat into work.
C. No process has as its sole result the transfer of heat from a colder to a hotter body.
D. Two systems each in equilibrium with a third are in equilibrium with each other.
List II:
(i) Clausius statement
(ii) Zeroth law
(iii) First law
(iv) Kelvin–Planck statement
(a) A-iii, B-i, C-iv, D-ii (b) A-iii, B-iv, C-i, D-ii (c) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii (d) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii
32. Match each process with its nature.
List I:
A. Very slow isothermal expansion with a frictionless piston
B. Gas rushing into a vacuum
C. Heat flowing from a hot cup to a cooler table
D. Brakes warming a car wheel
List II:
(i) Reversible in the ideal limit
(ii) Irreversible: sudden, non-quasi-static change
(iii) Irreversible: dissipative effect
(iv) Irreversible: heat across a finite temperature difference
(a) A-i, B-iv, C-ii, D-iii (b) A-iii, B-ii, C-iv, D-i (c) A-i, B-ii, C-iii, D-iv (d) A-i, B-ii, C-iv, D-iii
33. An ideal gas at pressure P expands freely into vacuum in an insulated box until its volume doubles. Match List I with List II.
List I:
A. Heat absorbed
B. Final temperature compared with initial
C. Final pressure
D. Path on a P-V graph
List II:
(i) Cannot be drawn as a curve
(ii) Zero
(iii) P/2
(iv) Unchanged
(a) A-ii, B-iv, C-iii, D-i (b) A-iv, B-ii, C-iii, D-i (c) A-ii, B-iii, C-iv, D-i (d) A-ii, B-iv, C-i, D-iii
34. Match the claimed device with the verdict.
List I:
A. An engine with efficiency 1
B. A refrigerator that cools with no work input
C. An engine giving more work than the heat it takes in
D. A household refrigerator running on electricity
List II:
(i) Allowed
(ii) Breaks the first law
(iii) Breaks the Clausius statement
(iv) Breaks the Kelvin–Planck statement
(a) A-iii, B-iv, C-ii, D-i (b) A-iv, B-iii, C-i, D-ii (c) A-iv, B-iii, C-ii, D-i (d) A-ii, B-iii, C-iv, D-i
35. How many of the following statements are correct?
A. The Kelvin–Planck and Clausius statements are equivalent.
B. If the Clausius statement were false, a perfect heat engine could be built.
C. The second law forbids converting work completely into heat.
D. Isothermal expansion of an ideal gas turns all absorbed heat into work without breaking the Kelvin–Planck statement.
(a) One (b) Two (c) Three (d) Four
36. Choose the correct set of statements.
A. A reversible process must be quasi-static.
B. Every quasi-static process is reversible.
C. All natural processes are irreversible.
D. Friction makes a process irreversible.
(a) A and B only (b) B, C and D only (c) A and C only (d) A, C and D only
37. How many statements about the free expansion of an ideal gas are correct?
A. The gas does no work because it pushes against nothing.
B. The internal energy of the gas does not change.
C. The process is quasi-static.
D. The gas will later collect back into its original half on its own.
(a) One (b) Two (c) Three (d) Four
38. 1 mol of ideal gas at temperature T doubles its volume, once by free expansion and once by reversible isothermal expansion. Choose the correct set of statements.
A. ΔU is zero in both cases.
B. The work done by the gas is the same in both cases.
C. In the reversible case the heat absorbed is RT ln 2.
D. The final state of the gas is the same in both cases.
(a) A and B only (b) B and D only (c) A, C and D only (d) A, B, C and D
39. Four engine designs are listed. Temperatures are not given, so judge them only by the first law and the Kelvin–Planck statement.
| Design | Heat taken in (J) | Work out (J) | Heat rejected (J) |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | 1000 | 400 | 600 |
| Q | 1000 | 1000 | 0 |
| R | 1000 | 500 | 600 |
| S | 1000 | 200 | 800 |
Which is correct? (a) Only P and S are possible (b) Only Q is impossible (c) Only R is impossible (d) P, Q and S are possible
40. Equal masses of water at 30 °C and 70 °C are put in contact inside an insulated flask. Four claimed final states are given.
| Outcome | Water that started at 30 °C | Water that started at 70 °C |
|---|---|---|
| W | 50 °C | 50 °C |
| X | 10 °C | 90 °C |
| Y | 60 °C | 60 °C |
| Z | 40 °C | 40 °C |
Which outcome obeys the first law but breaks the second law? (a) W (b) X (c) Y (d) Z
41. A student shows the free expansion of an ideal gas from V to 2V as a smooth rectangular hyperbola on a P-V graph. The correct way to show it is: (a) a smooth adiabatic curve PV^γ = constant (b) a horizontal line at pressure P (c) a vertical line at volume V (d) only the initial and final points, both on the same isotherm, with no curve between them
Case for Q42–43: A rigid insulated box of 2 L is split into two halves by a thin partition. The left half holds 1 mol of ideal gas at 300 K. The right half is empty. A pin punctures the partition and the gas fills the box. Take R = 8.3 J mol⁻¹ K⁻¹ and ln 2 = 0.693.
42. After the gas settles, its temperature and pressure compared with the start are: (a) temperature falls, pressure halves (b) temperature rises, pressure halves (c) temperature unchanged, pressure halves (d) temperature unchanged, pressure unchanged
43. The walls are now made conducting and the gas is pushed back to 1 L slowly and isothermally at 300 K. The heat given to the surroundings is about: (a) 1.73 kJ (b) 0 (c) 2.49 kJ (d) 0.86 kJ
44. An inventor claims a ship engine that takes heat from sea water at one temperature and turns all of it into work to drive the propeller, in a repeating cycle. The claim: (a) breaks the first law only (b) breaks the Clausius statement only (c) is allowed because the sea is very large (d) breaks the Kelvin–Planck statement, though energy is conserved
45. A working refrigerator is left with its door open inside a sealed, insulated room. Over a few hours, the room temperature will: (a) fall steadily (b) rise, because the electrical work also ends up as heat in the room (c) stay the same, because the fridge only moves heat around (d) first fall, then stay constant at the freezer setting
Level 4 answer key
| Q | Ans | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| 31 | b | First law, Kelvin–Planck, Clausius, zeroth law |
| 32 | d | Ideal slow process; sudden; finite ΔT; friction |
| 33 | a | Q = 0, T same, P/2, no curve |
| 34 | c | η = 1 breaks K-P; no-work fridge breaks Clausius; W > Q breaks first law |
| 35 | c | A, B, D true; work to heat is always allowed |
| 36 | d | A quasi-static process with friction is not reversible |
| 37 | b | A and B true; free expansion is sudden and one-way |
| 38 | c | Free expansion does no work; reversible does RT ln 2 |
| 39 | a | Q breaks K-P; R gives out 1100 J from 1000 J |
| 40 | b | X conserves energy (10 + 90 = 30 + 70) but heat flows cold to hot |
| 41 | d | Free expansion is not quasi-static |
| 42 | c | Q = W = 0, so ΔU = 0 and T stays 300 K; V doubles so P halves |
| 43 | a | Q = RT ln 2 = 8.3 × 300 × 0.693 ≈ 1726 J |
| 44 | d | A single reservoir cannot drive a cyclic engine |
| 45 | b | Room gets Q₁ = Q₂ + W, a net gain of W |