LATEST
StrategyBy Pareeksha Editorial Team· ⏱ 14 min read

Syllogism Tricks: Venn Method, Possibility and Either-Or Cases

Share𝕏fin
Alongside this guide

Practise Syllogism

Explore related questions and check the available practice options.

Explore this topic →
Syllogism Tricks: Venn Method, Possibility and Either-Or Cases
On this page
  1. What the chapter tests
  2. The four statement types and what they let you draw
  3. The core method: draw the minimum, then try to break it
  4. The combination table (the fast route)
  5. Possibility conclusions
  6. Either-or: the strict test
  7. Worked examples
  8. Example 1 (easy)
  9. Example 2 (easy)
  10. Example 3 (easy)
  11. Example 4 (easy)
  12. Example 5 (moderate)
  13. Example 6 (moderate)
  14. Example 7 (moderate)
  15. Example 8 (moderate)
  16. Example 9 (moderate, three statements)
  17. Example 10 (moderate, "only a few")
  18. Example 11 (harder)
  19. Example 12 (harder, three statements)
  20. Example 13 (harder)
  21. Example 14 (trap)
  22. Common traps
  23. Revision box
  24. A practice routine (our advice)
  25. Frequently asked questions
  26. Do I have to draw a diagram for every syllogism question?
  27. What is the difference between "Some A are B" and "Only a few A are B"?
  28. When exactly is the answer "Either I or II"?
  29. Can a possibility conclusion follow even when a definite conclusion also follows?

Syllogism questions look like logic and feel like guessing. You read "Some pens are books. All books are bags", glance at a conclusion that sounds sensible, and tick it. Often it is wrong, because the question was never about what sounds sensible. It was about what must be true in every picture you could draw from those two sentences.

Seen that way, syllogism becomes one of the most reliable chapters in reasoning. There is one method (draw the least-overlapping diagram, then try to break the conclusion) and a short table of rules that lets you skip the drawing most of the time. This post covers both, plus the two types that cost the most marks: "possibility" and "either I or II". Every example is original, and every answer was checked by listing all the possible diagrams with a small program.

What the chapter tests

You get two or three statements and two (sometimes more) conclusions. Take the statements as true even if they are absurd ("All fish are birds" is fine) and decide which conclusions follow. The types that come up in SSC, RRB and bank papers:

  1. Two statements, two conclusions, with options "Only I", "Only II", "Either I or II", "Neither", "Both".
  2. Three statements, chained. Common in bank prelims; the same rules applied twice.
  3. Possibility conclusions. "All apples being trains is a possibility" asks whether something can be true, not whether it must be.
  4. "Only a few" statements. "Only a few A are B" means some A are B and some A are not B.
  5. Either-or pairs. Neither conclusion is certain, but one of them has to be.

The number of questions on this topic changes from paper to paper, so check your own exam's recent papers.

The four statement types and what they let you draw

Learn exactly what each kind allows.

Statement What it means What it does NOT mean
All A are B A circle sits entirely inside B (or A and B are the same) It does not say all B are A
No A is B A and B do not touch at all Nothing else
Some A are B A and B overlap at least a little It does not rule out "All A are B"
Some A are not B Part of A lies outside B It does not rule out "Some A are B"

Two details matter. Every class named is assumed to have members, so "All A are B" also gives "Some B are A". And "some" means "at least one, possibly all", so "Some A are B" never contradicts "All A are B".

Reading backwards (conversion): All A are B gives Some B are A. No A is B gives No B is A (and Some B are not A). Some A are B gives Some B are A. Some A are not B gives nothing backwards.

The core method: draw the minimum, then try to break it

For every statement, draw only what is forced: for "Some A are B", a small overlap. Then, for each conclusion, ask: "Can I redraw the circles, still obeying every statement, so that this conclusion becomes false?" If you can, it does not follow. If no legal redrawing breaks it, it follows. Students who look only at the first diagram they draw tend to accept conclusions that happen to be true in that one picture.

The combination table (the fast route)

For two statements sharing a middle term (A–B and B–C), these are the only definite conclusions between A and C, each confirmed against every possible diagram.

First statement (A–B) Second statement (B–C) Definite conclusion
All A are B All B are C All A are C (and Some C are A)
All A are B No B is C No A is C (either way round)
Some A are B All B are C Some A are C (and Some C are A)
Some A are B No B is C Some A are not C
No A is B All B are C Some C are not A
No A is B Some B are C Some C are not A
All A are B Some B are C No definite conclusion
Some A are B Some B are C No definite conclusion
No A is B No B is C No definite conclusion
Some A are not B anything No definite conclusion
anything Some B are not C No definite conclusion

In the two "No A is B" rows, the conclusion runs from C to A; reading it the other way is a common slip. If the statements are not in A–B, B–C order, first try swapping the two statements. If you still need to convert one, convert a Some or a No statement, never an All: turning "All A are B" into "Some B are A" throws information away and can hide a real conclusion. For example, "All books are pens. Some books are bags." Swap them and convert the Some: Some bags are books + All books are pens gives Some bags are pens (so Some pens are bags too).

The two Some-not rows hold only in this A–B, B–C order. Two forms outside it do give a conclusion: "All A are B" + "Some C are not B" gives Some C are not A, and "Some B are not C" + "All B are A" gives Some A are not C. Some-not statements cannot be converted, so learn these two as they are.

Possibility conclusions

A possibility conclusion ("X being Y is a possibility") follows if at least one legal diagram makes it true. So the test flips: you try to make it true, not to break it. It fails only when it contradicts something definite. If the statements force "No boat is a car", then "Some cars being boats is a possibility" is impossible.

Either-or: the strict test

"Either I or II follows" is the answer only when all three of these hold:

  1. Neither conclusion follows on its own.
  2. Both conclusions are about the same two terms.
  3. They form a contradictory pair: "Some X are Y" with "No X is Y", or "All X are Y" with "Some X are not Y".

In a contradictory pair, exactly one is true in every possible diagram. If the terms differ, or the pair is not one of these two, the answer is "neither".

Worked examples

Each example uses the five standard options. Work it yourself before reading the solution.

Example 1 (easy)

Statements: All pens are books. All books are bags. Conclusions: I. All pens are bags. II. Some bags are pens.

Solution: Pens sit inside books, books sit inside bags, so pens sit inside bags. I follows. Converting I gives Some bags are pens, so II follows too. Shortcut: All + All = All, and All always converts to Some. Answer: Both follow.

Example 2 (easy)

Statements: Some cups are plates. All plates are spoons. Conclusions: I. Some cups are spoons. II. Some spoons are cups.

Solution: The cups that are plates are inside spoons, so some cups are spoons. II is just I read backwards. Shortcut: Some + All = Some. Answer: Both follow.

Example 3 (easy)

Statements: All mangoes are fruits. Some fruits are sweets. Conclusions: I. Some mangoes are sweets. II. No mango is a sweet.

Solution: The sweets can overlap the part of fruits that holds mangoes, or a part that does not. So neither I nor II is certain. But they are about the same two terms and form the Some/No pair, so in every diagram exactly one is true. Shortcut: All + Some = no definite conclusion; then check for the pair. Answer: Either I or II follows.

Example 4 (easy)

Statements: No pencil is an eraser. All erasers are rulers. Conclusions: I. No pencil is a ruler. II. Some rulers are not pencils.

Solution: Rulers are a big circle containing erasers. Pencils stay away from erasers, but they can still overlap the rest of the ruler circle, so I fails. The erasers are rulers that are not pencils, so II follows. Shortcut: No + All gives "Some C are not A", here Some rulers are not pencils. Answer: Only II follows.

Example 5 (moderate)

Statements: Some keys are locks. No lock is a door. Conclusions: I. Some keys are not doors. II. Some doors are keys.

Solution: The keys that are locks cannot be doors, so some keys are not doors. Doors may or may not touch the other keys, so II is not certain. (I and II are not a contradictory pair, so "either" is out.) Shortcut: Some + No = Some-not, running from the first term. Answer: Only I follows.

Example 6 (moderate)

Statements: All boats are ships. No ship is a car. Conclusions: I. No boat is a car. II. Some cars being boats is a possibility.

Solution: Boats sit inside ships and ships never touch cars, so boats never touch cars. I is definite, and it makes II impossible. Shortcut: All + No = No. A possibility that contradicts a definite conclusion fails. Answer: Only I follows.

Example 7 (moderate)

Statements: Some apples are kites. All kites are trains. Conclusions: I. All apples being trains is a possibility. II. Some trains are apples.

Solution: Some + All gives Some apples are trains, so II follows. For I, try to draw it: put the whole apple circle inside trains. Nothing in the statements forbids that, so the possibility exists. Shortcut: For a possibility, look for a definite contradiction. There is none. Answer: Both follow.

Example 8 (moderate)

Statements: Some bricks are stones. Some stones are tiles. Conclusions: I. Some bricks are tiles. II. No brick is a tile.

Solution: Some + Some gives nothing definite between bricks and tiles. But I and II are the Some/No pair about bricks and tiles, so one of them must be true. Shortcut: No conclusion from the table, same two terms, contradictory pair. Answer: Either I or II follows.

Example 9 (moderate, three statements)

Statements: All cats are dogs. Some dogs are rats. No rat is a mouse. Conclusions: I. Some dogs are not mice. II. All cats being mice is a possibility.

Solution: Take the second and third statements: Some dogs are rats, No rat is a mouse, so Some dogs are not mice. I follows. For II, the cats can sit in the part of dogs that is outside rats, and the mouse circle can swallow all the cats there without touching any rat. Every statement still holds, so II is possible. Shortcut: Chain only pairs that share a term; for the possibility, look for a definite "No" between cats and mice. Answer: Both follow.

Example 10 (moderate, "only a few")

Statements: Only a few books are pens. All pens are copies. Conclusions: I. Some books are copies. II. All books being pens is a possibility.

Solution: "Only a few books are pens" means some books are pens and some books are not pens. The books that are pens are copies, so I follows. II asks for every book to be a pen, which directly contradicts "some books are not pens". Shortcut: Split "only a few" into its two parts before you start. Answer: Only I follows.

Example 11 (harder)

Statements: All plums are quinces. Some quinces are not radishes. Conclusions: I. Some plums are not radishes. II. All plums being radishes is a possibility.

Solution: The quinces that are not radishes may lie outside the plum circle, so I is not certain. For II, put the whole plum circle inside radishes and keep a separate patch of quince outside radishes. Both statements still hold, so II is possible. Shortcut: A "Some-not" statement gives no definite conclusion, but it rarely blocks a possibility about a different term. Answer: Only II follows.

Example 12 (harder, three statements)

Statements: No coin is a note. Some notes are cheques. All cheques are drafts. Conclusions: I. Some drafts are not coins. II. No coin is a draft.

Solution: Some notes are cheques, all cheques are drafts, so some notes are drafts. Those note-drafts cannot be coins, so some drafts are not coins. I follows. Coins can still overlap the part of drafts that has no notes, so II is not certain. Shortcut: Chain Some + All first, then Some + No. Answer: Only I follows.

Example 13 (harder)

Statements: All jars are pots. Some pots are vases. Conclusions: I. All vases are jars. II. Some vases are not jars.

Solution: Neither is certain: the vases might fit inside jars or might spill outside. But I and II are about the same two terms and form the All/Some-not pair, so exactly one is true in every diagram. Shortcut: All/Some-not on the same terms is the second either-or pair. Answer: Either I or II follows.

Example 14 (trap)

Statements: Some rivers are lakes. Some lakes are ponds. Conclusions: I. Some ponds are rivers. II. All rivers are ponds.

Solution: Some + Some gives nothing, so neither follows. Both mention rivers and ponds, which tempts you into "either", but this is not a contradictory pair: both are false if the ponds sit away from the rivers. Shortcut: Same terms is not enough. Check the pair is Some/No or All/Some-not. Answer: Neither follows.

Common traps

  • Real-world knowledge. If the statement says "All tables are rivers", accept it. A conclusion true in real life but not forced by the statements does not follow.
  • Reversing "All" or "Some-not". Neither can be turned round.
  • The direction of "No + All". No A is B, All B are C gives Some C are not A, not Some A are not C.
  • Calling "either" too quickly. Check all three conditions.
  • Forgetting that "some" can mean "all". So a possibility of "All A are B" often follows.

Revision box

  • Draw the least-overlap diagram; then try to break each conclusion.
  • All + All = All. All + No = No. Some + All = Some. Some + No = Some-not (first term).
  • No + All and No + Some = Some C are not A (third term first).
  • All + Some, Some + Some, No + No: no definite conclusion. Some-not in A–B, B–C order: none.
  • Two Some-not forms that do conclude: All A are B + Some C are not B → Some C are not A; Some B are not C + All B are A → Some A are not C.
  • Out of order? Swap the statements first; convert a Some or No, never an All.
  • All converts to Some. Some and No convert both ways. Some-not does not convert.
  • "Only a few A are B" = Some A are B + Some A are not B.
  • Possibility follows unless it contradicts a definite result.
  • Either-or: neither follows + same two terms + Some/No or All/Some-not.

A practice routine (our advice)

For the first three days, do ten questions a day on the syllogism practice page and draw a diagram for every one, even the easy ones. From day four, use the combination table first and draw only when it gives "no definite conclusion" or there is a possibility. In the second week, add three-statement and "only a few" questions and aim for under 40 seconds on a two-statement question. Label every wrong answer with the trap that caused it; after a week, one or two traps will account for most errors. Then try mixed reasoning in the practice sets or a short paper like the CGL mini mock.

The Venn diagram reasoning guide uses the same circles, and the statement and conclusion guide applies the same "what must be true" test to plain sentences.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to draw a diagram for every syllogism question?

No. Use the combination table for the two-statement core, and draw only when the table gives no definite conclusion, when there is a possibility conclusion, or when three statements make the chain unclear.

What is the difference between "Some A are B" and "Only a few A are B"?

"Some A are B" allows all A to be B. "Only a few A are B" rules that out: it says some A are B and some A are not B. So "All A being B is a possibility" follows from the first and fails with the second.

When exactly is the answer "Either I or II"?

When neither conclusion is certain, both are about the same two terms, and they are a Some/No or All/Some-not pair. If any one of those fails, the answer is "neither" (or whatever the individual checks say).

Can a possibility conclusion follow even when a definite conclusion also follows?

Yes, as long as the two do not contradict each other. Example 7 above has a definite conclusion and a possibility that both follow.

Share:𝕏fin
Put what you read into practice

Practise Syllogism

Explore related questions and check the available practice options.

Explore this topic →

Make this reading part of your preparation

Create your free account to bookmark Reading Room chapters and track your practice scores. You’ll return to this article after signing in.

By continuing, you agree to our terms and privacy policy.

No payment needed. Already registered? Use the same options to sign in.

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the discussion.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.